The Next Best Book Club discussion
Revive a Dead Thread
>
APRILS GROUP READS ARE>>>>>
date
newest »


I've read the other two, so I'll be interested to see what everyone says about them.

Would you please endulge me again and repost?
Thanks!
Jill


It's not the best format, just one page of scrolling, but maybe it will save some people some money if they read it online rather than buying it. (Not that I think it shouldn't be bought - the entire series is fantastic!)
Woah, Becky, is that the entire book? It almost looks to short to be real. Thats great! Thanks for linking it for everyone! Perhaps you want to create a separate post for this so people have instant access to it...../???

And yeah, it does appear to be the whole book. I didn't read the entire thing, but I scrolled through and the ending is how I remember it. None of them are really long on their own. My copy is only 144 pages.

I have read Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy before -- it is also fun to listen to and there is a BBC dramatized version around that I think is better than the movie. My favorite Douglas Adams books are his mysteries.

Probably the 1971 version... They had a bunch of the old miniseries on there for instant play.

It's not the best format, just one page of scrolling, but maybe it will sa..."
That is awesome! Maybe now I have a reason to read the book. I have zero time to go to the library and will only get reading done while I am here at work. You save me! :-)


Books mentioned in this topic
The Shadow of the Wind (other topics)Persuasion (other topics)
The Book Thief (other topics)
Parlor Games (other topics)
The Serious Kiss (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
William Shakespeare (other topics)Kurt Vonnegut Jr. (other topics)
Terry Pratchett (other topics)
Neil Gaiman (other topics)
Louise Erdrich (other topics)
More...
1971 Miniseries
1995 Version
2007 Version
They all have their good points.
The 1971 sticks closest to the book (since it's much longer, it makes sense). The budget on this one didn't seem like it was terribly high... The clothes weren't as pretty... I loved Anne's voice, but she was pretty... I don't know... dull, overall (acting-wise). I liked it, though. (I got it from Netflix, so it was worth it.)
The 1995 version... Anne. The girl who played her has deep frown lines and really big expressive eyes. She wasn't as pretty as 2007 Anne, but I liked her a lot. Captain Wentworth was really good in this one, also. ... This one was probably the best one. True (as much as time allowed) to the story, and to the feeling of the book.
The 2007 version has the prettiest Anne and the hottest Captain Wentworth... ;) It was good. They took more liberties with the plot. (Not as many as the new 2008 version of Sense & Sensibility. Speaking of which, the guy who plays Edward Ferrars... WOW.) ANYWAY, The ending was more dramatized... It was overall more "Hollywood" than the previous versions.
In order of best to not-best, I'd say 1995, 2007, 1971. Others might disagree...