Hedges' 5th Hour 12-13 discussion
SSR Response #1
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Angie
(last edited Jan 24, 2013 05:59PM)
(new)
Jan 24, 2013 05:20PM

reply
|
flag
If I had the opportunity to converse with
, author of Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption , I would have TONS to say and ask. While I’m only about 100 pages into the POIGNANT 400-page book, so much has happened and the writing is so rich, that I am confident we could talk for hours. I would start our conversation by asking her about her research process. The chapter I just finished, titled “Five Hundred and Ninety-four Holes,” relayed a mission gone awry with vivid detail. I could see, taste, touch, and smell every moment—from the exploding sharks to the spurting blood. I noticed that the Notes in the back of the book painstakingly outline her sources: telephone interviews, diary entries, newspaper articles, etc. So, my question isn’t so much WHERE she found her information, but more her process of collecting and organizing it. I can’t imagine writing a 400-page book that includes this level of detail AND attributes sources so painstakingly! Before Hillenbrand and I would wrap up our conversation, I would be remiss if I didn’t tell her how much I appreciated the carefully selected photographs she included. For example, Hillenbrand closed the same chapter with a small portrait of Harry Brooks, looking very young and brave. This portrait followed her deft description of his fate: “Technical Sergeant Harold Brooks died one week before his twenty-third birthday. It took more than a week for word to reach his widowed mother, Edna, at 511 ½ Western Avenue in Clarkville, Michigan. Across town on Harley Road, the news reached his fiancée, Jeannette Burtscher. She learned that he was gone nine days before the wedding date that they had set before he left for the war” (104). Wow.






Angie wrote: "If I had the opportunity to converse with



Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."
Jodi PicoultThe Pact

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."







, author of Inexcusable, I would have a ton of questions for him. The first one being what is this book supposed to be about? I understand the Keir is a "good guy" (107) but beyond that, what is the book trying to hit on? Quite frankly, the book doesn't have a true problem. One could argue that the problem is that Keir is having trouble finding his identity, but every teenager in the world has moments when they are not too sure about themselves. I know I am not done with the book yet, but as of now I do not see how the author could provide a poignant moment in the book. It is difficult to have a climax with no real problem. Also, when the author refers to "all this serious stuff" (113), what is he referring to? I know that the general idea is that there are a large number of drugs, but what kind of drugs? He never specifies which drug the main character takes and therefore leaves the reader in the dark. *side note- he does mention cocaine but leaves out which drugs he takes in the form of a pill* I like the Gigi character in the book, but the author spends so much time descrbing her features that he forgets to describe anything else about her, such as her personality, likes, dislikes, etc. Last but not least I have something I have always been curious about: how do adult authors write books from a teenager's point of view? How do authors even know that what they're putting on paper is accurate? Like when the author makes a reference to "the Kennedy brothers conferring over the Cuban Missile Crisis..."(74). I would like to regretfully inform all authors that if they think that quote would ever come from a teenager in a conversation with friends, then they are WAY off track. Here is a hint: most teenagers hardly know about the Cuban Missile Crisis, heck I only know about it because it was my assigned topic for my research project. Teenagers tend to cuss a ton, and when making comparisons will usually refer to popular singers or figures from THE SAME DECADE. Phew, sorry for the rant Ms. Hedges.
Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."


If I had the opportunity of a lifetime to sit down with Ellen DeGeneres, the author of Seriously...I'm Kidding, I don’t even know what I would say first. Ellen is such an AFFABLE person but at the same time she is a comedian so it would be difficult to get a real answer out of her. This shows in her chapter “The Secret of Life” she goes from talking about packing up a house to the procedures and tests that you must have done as you get older. This really can tell you her perspective about life that you just take it as it comes and never take anything too seriously. I would love to ask her how she lives her life that way and stays out of tabloid drama. Also, in the chapter “Babies, Animals, and Baby Animals” you find more information about her marriage and what her plans are. She says that her and Portia will never have kids, but I want to get her aspect on adopting and why they are so persistant about not having children. Lastly, she has an incredibly busy schedule with doing her talk show and appearances and at one time doing American Idol, I want to know how she kept going through all that without getting tired and staying all put together. I have a super busy schedule with dance and school work and a job that I am barely hanging on myself and I want to know how she does it so flawlessly. Seriously...I'm Kidding

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."

If I had a chance to meet Jennifer E. Smith, author of The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight, I would probably gush for a few minutes about how she is the first famous person I have ever met and then I'd act ditzy and giggly until I regained self-control. Then I would immediately start in with lots of questions and comments…just enough to make her feel even more uncomfortable than she probably already is. I am only 266 pages in (so just about halfway) but I am already emotionally connected to the characters. I would ask her where she got her ideas for the main character’s love interest, Oliver. I would tell her that if he was a real person I would totally be hard-core crushing on him. I would also ask why Oliver kisses her while waiting in line at the airport, and why did he say “What the hell” before he did so (p. 177). I mean…whoa there, home boy… Ya’ll just met. It was super cute though, so if it happened to me I would not complain. Not one bit. I would ask if she thinks the story is very realistic. Personally, Hadley and Oliver meeting and bonding on the airplane seems very similar to the last time I went to airport, except my mom was there too, talking the guy’s ear off, and then when we all stood up I had about 3 or 4 inches on the guy and decided to avoid him after that. I also want to ask her why she adds so much detail to her parents’ divorce and her father’s new bride, such as the wedding ring details and how they interacted. Also, why the heck did her dad just let her run off through London in the middle of the reception?! SO UNSAFE! I would also tell Jen that she made me want to see London. I had always imagined it as a dull, dreary, DOUR place, but the way she spoke of the gardens and brightly colored houses seemed fantastic. I would end by trying to awkwardly hug and/or take a picture with her and then I would leave and tweet about it.

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."


Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."

If I met with Tolkien, author of "The Hobbit" I would be extremely excited for him to inspire my comparitavely PEDANTIC mind. I would ask him how he got his inspiration for such a massive, vivid, living world and how he kept it all under control. What were his inspirations for different creatures like the mountain giants that attack the company. I would ask him if any of the encounters were inspired by real life expierences; is the at-first unadventurous, dull character Bilbo based on anyone? How long did it take him to make various language? I'm sure it would be otherworldly.

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."

Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."
Angie wrote: "If I had the opportunity to converse with [authorimage:Laura Hillenbrand], author of Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption , I would have TONS to say and ask. While..."
Angie wrote: "If I had the opportunity to converse with [authorimage:Laura Hillenbrand], author of Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption , I would have TONS to say and ask. While..."


Angie wrote: "If you were able to meet with author of your book right now, what would you say to him or her? What questions would you ask? Support your response with at least two specific details or quotations f..."
Books mentioned in this topic
The Red Pyramid (other topics)Seriously... I'm Kidding (other topics)
Inexcusable (other topics)
L.A. Candy (other topics)
The Road (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Rick Riordan (other topics)Chris Lynch (other topics)
Lauren Conrad (other topics)
Cormac McCarthy (other topics)
Jodi Picoult (other topics)
More...