Harry Potter discussion
Characters
>
If given a chance which three characters would you save and bring back from death?
Pamela wrote: "Fred, Sirius, and HEDWIG!!"Oh, yeah!
sirius,snape,dumbledore.but i would also save fred & dobby!!
Fred, Sirius and Dobby but also Snape Dumbldore and everyone!!!
Sirius, Fred, and Hedwig! :*) I would say Snape, but that would change the story...
Sirius, Lupin, Snape, Tonks and Dobby. These deaths were really cruel and not required.
I'm not trying to be mean but a couple of those Sirius ,Severus etc.Really added to the story even though I miss them all;(
I think that they added to the story too. I hated to see Sirius die, I still do. But without that happening, Harry may have never gotten the strength to actually be what he needed to be. Snape was required, because that's the only reason we ever even found out his story. I still don't understand all the Snape love, but still. He would never have shared all that with Harry unless he needed to.
Hedwig, either Tonks or Lupin? I think that is his name...the werefolf guy that was the Drak Arts professer in book 3. And then Sirius because he never was in trouble. It was all Voldemarts fault because her tricked Harry.
Of all the characters, I think Sirius would be the one I would choose to come back. Harry lost so many family members, that I would have liked to see him with someone to count on. I also think it was a big mistake to have Fred die. That kind of fatality is something George could never recover from. The relationships between twins are totally different than any other, and Fred's death was dealt without mercy for that kind of bond. Other than that, I would love all the "good guys" to come back to life...including Snape. So let's see, there's Hedwig, Lupin, Collin, Tonks, Cedric, Dumbledore, Dobby, etc.
I think Sirius because he gave hope to Harry after everything he'd been through and acted like a fatherly figure and mentor. I also think Fred because losing a twin would be like losing a second half to you. I mean, think about it, they would never have been separated for any huge amount of time, always experiencing new things and working together constantly. Suddenly being separated by an unmovable barrier such as death would crush George forever. I'm not sure who the third person would be though, they're just two deaths that really got to me.
Dobby, Fred and Hedwig. It's saddening that the Marauders all died but somehow fitting because they were all there long enough to impact Harry's life and journey in some way. I can't imagine any of them being brought back without changing the entire story.
Fred, Lupin and Sirius. So he could live with Sirius.
And exactly as everyone has been saying.
You don't just break up Gred and Forge.
SIRIUS, without a doubt. He was the only one Harry ever had the chance to grow close to. Almost like a father figure. If he came back Harry could go live with him and be happy for once.Probably LUPIN, because he had a high impact on harry's life as well, and he was recently married with a son.
Lastly, FRED. You just can't break up Gred and Forge. It's like living with only one side of your body. They balance out each other!
fred n sirius for surethird would be either Dobby or dumbledore
I forgot Colin! His death was so pointless!
There's so much people I want to bring back, but if I can only pick 3 it would be Fred, hedwig, and dumbledore
OMG!!! I feel so bad!!! Can you guess who I forgot??? DUMBLEDORE!!!!!!!!!!!
Yea know how you feel! I wish I could bring back Colin, all those other people who died in battle, Dobby, Tonks, and OMG I forgot Cedric! His death was so unfair
I would like to see Sirius come back. He was a character that had so much potential in Harry's life, and not just as an adult figure. He was one of few who truly understood Harry's loss and I think that was one of the key aspects of their relationship. He could have guided Harry and been the friend and mentor that Dumbledore couldn't always be.
Thanks lilia that's exactly what I was thinking!:)
Fred, Sirius and SnapeFred - because you can't separate Fred and George.
Sirius - because Harry needs him in his life. He was the closest thing Harry had to a parent.
Snape - Because, after everything he did for Harry, he shouldn't be the one dying. Plus he should be able to experience people see his worth and get to know that he was forgiven for what he did.
Fred, Sirius, Lupin (I wish I could save Tonks too...).
Fred, Sirius and Lupin! (I wish I could pick more than three though :p)
Stes65 wrote: "Fred, Lupin and Tonks!"I pick the exact same three!
Pamela wrote: "Fred, Sirius, and HEDWIG!!"I just noticed that my answer was exactly the same as yours! I guess great minds think alike. :)
Fred James and Dumbeldore.If could I would also pick Dobby Sirius and Lily.
I notice nobody's picked mad eye.
Snape was kinda being stupid shoulda drank honey badger anti venom lol.
Fred, Sirius, Dumbledore. I like Snape but I hate the fact that he was the one who decided to become a death eater. The decision was completely up to him and he didn't do it to spy on Voldemort.
I really can't choose but I'll say-
Fred- As said earlier by me George is nothing without Fred. I have to save him.
Snape- Though he was the bad guy all throughout the books but in the Deathly Hallows I was most moved by his death and Fred's. Snape's a hero and deserves a second chance.
Dumbledore- How can I not save the man because of whom Harry got to everything. The brightest wizard. I love Dumbledore.
Please don't think I'm heartless but I had to choose three which I thought were the most reasonable!