Harry Potter discussion
Characters
>
If given a chance which three characters would you save and bring back from death?
Armina wrote: "Fred: because George is nothing without Fred
Tonks: because she deserves to spend time with her son
Lupin: because Tonks would never survive without him
I really considered putting Snape down inst..."
Same here!
Tonks: because she deserves to spend time with her son
Lupin: because Tonks would never survive without him
I really considered putting Snape down inst..."
Same here!
I know Cedric driggory death represents voldemort murder but yeah it was sort of a cruel death
Sirius:Because Harry needs a father figure in his life.Dumbldore:
Dobby, Dumbledore, FRED!!!
SorryDumbledore:Because he was Harrys role model
and Dobby:Because he was so loyal to Harry
I would'nt bring back Harrys parwents because of the fact that if they hadnt dided Harry wouldnt have been the person that he is today and also Harry wouldnt have hated Voldemort as much
Fred because George needs him. Dobby because he was awesome.
Cedric because his death was unfair. He wasn't even fighting, he just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
I wouldn't bring back Dumbledore or any of the Marauders. I feel like Harry grew a lot from going through their deaths.
Dobby, Fred and Lupin.
Dumbledore and Sirius needed to die, and it made sense but those three deaths just killed me(irony)
Dumbledore and Sirius needed to die, and it made sense but those three deaths just killed me(irony)
How am I supposed to chose only three? I need them all alive! But I have to say Hedwig, Fred and Dobby. I want Lupin and Tonks alive aswell, those were almost the saddest deaths in the books because now their son has to grow up parent less. Maybe we have another seven books about his years at Hogwarts..?
Hmmm... Why would you bring the villains back?
Hedwig. Sirius. The fox Bellatrix killed at the beginning of Half-Blood Prince ...The animals can't protect themselves ☺️
Certainly, Fred, Lupin, Tonks, Dumbledore are high on the list too!!
Maybe we could pick three animals and three humans?!?
Annamarie wrote: "Hmmm... Why would you bring the villains back?"Having the villains come back to live, it adds more fire to the story
, without them there wouldn't be a story and there wouldn't be a intriguing story
Snape, Sirius and Lily! Why? Because they were all important people who helped Harry in the books!
Pink Fluffy Unicorn wrote: "Snape, Lily and Fred! Definitely!!..And if i could get one more i would pick Dobby ;)"
1.)Sirius 2.)Dobby
3.)Fred
I wish I could bring Lupin back too.
1. Snape2. Lupin
3. Dumbledore
and Fred, Moody and Dobby
remus,dobby, and... hm. maybe hedwig? or maybe sirius - just for harry tho. i didnt like him that much....
Omg don't do this....Fred
Sirius
Dobby
omg Tonks and Hedwig and Bellatrix (Don't ask about the last one;p)
But if you're asking me to kill one charrie and only ONE UMBRIDGE!!!!
Sirius, Lupin, SnapeI agree about killing Umbridge! Most annoying character ever
VERY LONG POST:In short- Fred, Sirius, Cedric. (Lupin&Tonks are discussed) Btw, I love this discussion =)
I would have to say Fred first because honestly why wouldnt I? They found a way to smile and make people laugh even when it wasn't exactly a happy time. Like, remember when George lost his ear? And when they were testing with Umbridge? And all the other countless times things were bad and they made them bearable? Fred needs a place on this list!!
Next would have to be Sirius. Harry never knew his parents. He grew up with a really crappy family and had no friends thanks to Dudely.He finally had someone to call family and that person left as soon as he came. His death was also sort of unnecessary. Someone mentioned this earlier, about how it wouldnt change the story much.
**(Thats why I didnt choose Dumbledore or Snape. Dumbledore was the one wizard Voldemort feared and keeping him alive wouldve made things change big time. Severus had been found out and would no longer be able to double agent his way through the story. Also, someone mentioned this I think, Harry woulnt have ever known what Snape had shared with him in his last moments.
I'm at a loss for the last person since I can't really choose. I want to bring both Nymphadora and Lupin back. They were just such a perfect pair. I always adored Tonks and wanted to be her when I was younger!! Lupin was such a tormented soul. He never asked to be a werewolf and doesnt think he should be with Tonks because he is one. But since they both died together (meaning during the same battle- not sure if they were fighting together or anthing) I feel a bit more at peace. If only one of them had died the other would def be on this list. I wouldve also liked to get Lupin back to normal. =)
So, to fill the last place I've chosen Cedric. Yes, Cedric Diggory from Hufflepuff. He was in the wrong place at the wrong time. Not much would've changed had he been left alive. The portkey/Triwizard Cup was meant for Harry but Harry being Harry was an amazing person and decided to share the victory with Cedric no knowing the ill fate that awaited them both. Cedrics death did give the book and movie a bit of what it needed but surely it wouldnt hurt to keep him alive.
Definitely Sirius, for the fact that he was Harry's only true caring family. Remus, because I believe Harry looked up to him as well, and poor Teddy needs one of his parents. And finally I would say Colin Creevy. The last one was a difficult decision. I would love Fred, or Tonks, because all the same, they don't change they story. But I chose Colin because he was very young, and it was brutal for a young child so full of life to die without really experiencing life.
Fred, Sirius, and Tonks (though I really want Remus back as well).
1. Sirius2. Lupin
3. Dumbledore
Sirius Black hands down. He built such a relationship with Harry and I really felt like he stepped up and acted like a Father figure. His death is one of the only deaths I was extremely upset about. Sure I miss Fred, Lupin, Tonks, Dumbledore, Hedwig...the list goes on and on, but I will never EVER stop mourning over Sirius.
I can't just choose 3! I want George, Tonks, Dobby, Sirius, Snape, Lily, James, dumbledor, Ariana, basically everyone who isn't which Voldemort now like Sirius' brother knew he was wrong so I want him alive.
Sirius, Snape and Dumbledore! And Fred. And Dobby. I'm sad.
Hedwig, most importantly.Mad-Eye, definitely - can't do without him.
Sirius, so Harry can have a decent home to look forward to.
Or should the third choice be Snape ?
Yes, let's make it Snape instead - then Harry can have a decent home life, and make up with Snape as well, just as he ought to have at the end of Year 1.
Personally I would choose to relive Fred, Remus and Dobby.To me, Fred represents an irreplacible part of the magical world,which stands for freedom,bravery,creativity and,of course,justice.Together with Gorge, they brought happies and hope to people in the darkest times of Voldemort's power, though I believe that to them it was a hard time too,with all those deaths and breaking of families....but Im also sure that they will be the positive power that the magic world will always need,no matter in times of war or peace.
Remus is brave man that fought against dark power and discimination or racism throughout the entire story.He had a child,yes,but he made his own choice between his own family and the many families that his life could be devoted to.Harry once said he was a coward.I still remember what Remus said in response."I wish him to follow his intuition,which is almost always right."His love for Harry is not a bit less than Sirius ',though quiet it may be.He is a werwolf,but at the same time,one of the people in the story with the coolestind and the purest heart.
From the second Harry Potter book, a little figure joined our journey in the magical world,Dobby.I want to relive him,for very simple reasons,because he is the symbol of freedom and kindness,he dedicated his life,which could have been unnoticed and unconcerned had he not fought for his own belief,to trying to build a world of peace and harmony.I world want to see him free and happy again, cause this is just one of the things people fought for, isn't it?
Many say that they want to bring Dumbledore back from death.Well, in actuality, the thought of it is an almost irresistible lure to me, for I do love the headmaster most deeply among all the characters. Nevertheless, I decided not to bring him back.Dumbledore spent six of his years to protect Harry, even after his death, he continued to help him withou him knowing it.In my opinion, the efforts he made to help Harry get all the deathly hallows safely in the last year, is a kind of redemption.Just like what I read,"In my eyes Dumbledore redeemed himself big time in DH, when all was said and done, he left his past well in the past." My only wish for him is that he may feel less regret when he reminisce the old times.The new era has come with the death of Voldemort,and my dear headmaster, please rest in peace.
Difficult choice....1. Severus
2. Serius
3. Fred
Tonks: because she deserves to spend time with her son
Lupin: because Tonks would never survive without him
I really considered putting Snape down instead of Lupin because I felt like he deserved another chance in life. A chance to prove to people that he really is good. I decided against it because Snape never would have been happy without Lily.