Fantasy Book Club discussion
General fantasy discussions
>
What kind of fantasy beginning hooks you the most?
date
newest »

message 51:
by
Justin
(new)
May 11, 2013 07:08AM

reply
|
flag

You need to make it original or I won´t bother to read it. Lame motives as "he-wants to kill me so I better kill him first" or "he killed my father so I´m going to kill him too" are below big NO. If you´re not able to come with something that´s above "general human needs" (sex, food, drink, death) in fantasy book, be sure I won´t give you a chance
I´m a reader (and only a reader) that picks a book by reading the sample and if I´m not interested in your book after sample (89/100% I don´t even finish a sample) I won´t read your book

Aside from that, I'm a big fan of "in media res" or starting in the middle of the action. I was a little more tolerant of the slow, expository introduction to a world when I was first starting and reading stuff like The Hobbit and The Eye of The World, but now I want better pacing than that. I like the feeling of being dropped into the middle of a strange place and picking it up as I go along.


Totally agree with you James. I've just finished the last book in the Glass Books of the Dream Waters and it was like being with an old friend. After over a five year gap between novels it's that kind of voice that really draws you in. Compelling characters also help.

A short (1-2 page) prologue is fine, if it gives a clue or shows a glimpse of the bad guys or some history that will play a part later.
Almost any beginning can work well, if the author knows what he/she is doing.







A good example of this is the prelude of Rothfuss' "Name of the Wind", but the book earlier in this thread that started off with an often-beaten slave suddenly smiling wide to his master sounds like one of those mysteries as well


I'm probably the only one, but I hate it when a book starts in the middle of an action scene. It makes me feel disorientated and confused, and vaguely like I'm watching a Bruce Willis action movie (all the action, zero story).

An info-dump pretty much by definition does not get things going, that's why it's a dump.
Celine wrote: "I hate it when a book starts in the middle of an action scene."
A lot of authors mistake an action-scene beginning for 'in media res', which is a beginning in the middle of an action, but not necessarily action-movie type action. One of my favorite books begins with a janitor pushing a mop bucket through a doorway. A lot of writing advice says to avoid the action-movie opening, as the characters won't have had time to develop any sympathy from the reader.

though I will say that introducing too many characters with their own scenes is dangerous, if I can't see any connections between them.
Books mentioned in this topic
Beauty: A Retelling of the Story of Beauty and the Beast (other topics)Tinker (other topics)
Wizard's First Rule (other topics)
Mistborn: The Final Empire (other topics)
Gardens of the Moon (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robin McKinley (other topics)Roger Zelazny (other topics)