Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
discussion
Did anyone else think that..............
date
newest »
newest »
noDAETT that hermoine should have ended up with malfoy instead of ron?
No.DAETT There should have been a Muggle born professor?
Heck no! DAETT Dumbledore would come back from the dead or was never really killed in the first place?
I don't think so.DAETT Neville should have killed Bellatrix?
Wait, Thomas was that a "Heck no" to Hermoine/Draco or a Muggle born teacher?
Yes, I was so upset when that didn't happenDAETT Harry shouldn't have ended up with Ginny
Cheryl wrote: "I don't think so.DAETT Neville should have killed Bellatrix?
Wait, Thomas was that a "Heck no" to Hermoine/Draco or a Muggle born teacher?"
Sorry,that was a "Heck No" to the Hermoine ending up with Malfoy.
Meiyu wrote: "Yes,he shouldn't haveDAETT that Weasley sounds strange with the name Hermione:Hermione Weasley...."
It fits her okay in the books. In the books she was not a hot model looking woman like she is in the movies.
Andrea wrote: "NO. Neville and Luna don't seem like a good match. DAETT it was weird that all adults of James and Lily's clan had pretty much no living family whatsoever?"
Andrea wrote: "NO. Neville and Luna don't seem like a good match.
DAETT it was weird that all adults of James and Lily's clan had pretty much no living family whatsoever?"
Harry's aunt who raised him was Lily's sister.
Farheen wrote: "NoDAETT Draco would come to the good side at the end?"
Farheen wrote: "No
DAETT Draco would come to the good side at the end?"
I'm surprised that Draco wasn't sent to azkaban with his parents.
I love Hermione Weasley, it sounds adorable :D DAETT it wouldn't have been as sad if both twins had died as opposed to just Fred?
No, it wouldn't have been as sad. :(
DAETT there were too many plot devices in DH?
DAETT there were too many plot devices in DH?
DAETT neville would become the hero in the last part??
Leon wrote: "Nope. DAETT that RAB was Regulus Black before Book 7 came out?"no
Shahdia wrote: "Yeah!DAETT Neville would kill Voldemort?"
That would have been cool, though, huh?
Brooke wrote: "YES, YES, HECK YES!!!DAETT Snape was a bad guy?"
Yes. I was surprised by the seventh book, especially with the part about Harry's mother. Whoa! Didn't see that one coming.
Leon wrote: "Yeah the epilogue didn't really tell us anything expect that it was a happy ending.DAETT that Voldemort was going to drown in the cauldron in book 4?"
Wait, do you mean hope? 'Cause I did. ;)
DAETT Mrs. Weasley would have adopted Harry if she could? (Of course, this would have been a problem with Harry and Ginnys relationship)
Eliza wrote: Wait, do you mean hope? Cause I did. ;)DAETT Mrs. Weasley would have adopted Harry if she could? (Of course, this would have been a problem with Harry and Ginnys relationship)
Yeah, I guess you could say hope. I really wasn't expecting all that bad stuff to happen right after they touched the cup, and I hoped Pettigrew was secretly plotting against Voldemort and made the potion wrong.
Yeah, I think Mrs. Weasley would definitely have adopted Harry, the way she said he was as good as his son in book 5. Funnily enough, I always thought Harry and Ginny's relationship felt a little incestuous from the start, but I also felt the same about Ron and Hermione's lol.
DAETT Tom Riddle was evil in book 2 before he mentioned he was Voldemort?
yeah. after all they did let him live in a cupboard and pretend he didn't exist when guest came over. DAETT Harry would end up with Ginny?
No, didn't see it comingDAETT Snape would turn out to be the half-blood prince?
No, I didn't see it coming at allDAETT Neville was important before the seventh book?
Once they cast doubt on Harry as the only 'boy who lived,' it became obvious that the shy underdog Neville had to have an important role to play. One that no one 'saw coming.'I say....duh.
Ivana wrote: "Leon wrote: "No, but he probably would have anywayDAETT Harry should have remained single?"
Why did you think that Harry should have remained single?"
Cause the relationships didn't seem to add much to the story.
Lajonn wrote: "Once they cast doubt on Harry as the only 'boy who lived,' it became obvious that the shy underdog Neville had to have an important role to play. One that no one 'saw coming.'I say....duh."
I didn't really give it that much thought, but I didn't find it surprising.
DAETT catching the snitch should get less points in Quidditch?
no DAETT that Remus and Tonks would live
Oh yeah. I figured that one out after looking up the Black family tree. DAETT... Sirius and Harry would end up going on wild- we're-on-the-run- adventures?
Claire wrote: "no DAETT that Remus and Tonks would live"
yes! they should have!
DAETT that Neville in year one was the kid you'd bully? (or was it just me....he was so, soft)
NoDAETT Dumbledore's death wasn't THAT important plot-wise?
coming to think of it no but it did have a lot of shock value.DAETT Bellatrix had a thing for Voldemort?
No, but I wasn't surprised when I found out. She always seemed obsessed with him.DAETT Harry should have died in the end of the series?
no DAETT that harry and ginny would have kids
I was hoping for it but I wasnt sure.DAETT that Percy would be such an asshole after he graduated?
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
DAETT harry would become the strongest wizard when he was told he had a "power that could rival voldemort's"
but it turned out to be.... well.... love??
i mean WTFish??!!"
I don't know, I mean personally I find the inter-lying message really sweet and rather brilliant, that being that love is a rival to power. I didn't really think about it until it got further explained in the series.
DAETT Luna and Neville would end up together (in the books, I mean. They did in the movies, but in the books they're never expressed as a couple) ?