Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
discussion
Did anyone else think that..............
message 51:
by
Amna
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Feb 06, 2013 03:30AM
yes...DAETT harry would become the minister?
reply
|
flag
Nope,DAETT the horcrux in harry should have been destroyed in the chamber of secrets?
Brooke wrote: "Yes. :(DAETT Dumbledore was manipulative?"
Laura wrote: "Absolutely!
@Dhanu YES! That is what makes Sirius' death the hardest for me to handle besides Fred's.
DAETT Hagrid was going to die by the end of the series (but glad he didn't :)"
hell yes i hate that in him
Big yes but that isn't in the Order book but wtevrDAETT with all time traveling clocks in the minster no body use them to defeat the dark lord ?
NoDAETT Hagrid would get married to the professor from the girls school?
No, but he probably would have anywayDAETT Harry should have remained single?
no
DAETT think that Draco Malfoy wasn't going to kill dumbledore (sob) before it actually happened
DAETT think that Draco Malfoy wasn't going to kill dumbledore (sob) before it actually happened
Yes I just didn't think he would have the guts to kill such an amazing headmaster.
DAETT that Hermione and Ron shouldn't have ended up together
DAETT that Hermione and Ron shouldn't have ended up together
yeah they are OK but not perfect DAETT the original form of magic (without wand) is stronger than the wand magic (after practicing) like for e.g. Tom Riddle, Lily Evans, Severus Snape, Minerva McGonagall, and possibly Ariana Dumbledore.?
Yes, but I think it is less easy to control or somethingDAETT the Hog's head bartender was Aberforth Dumbledore before book 7?
nooooDAETT harry would end up with ginny before book 6 ?
No way. I thought Dumbledore wouldn't die at all. D:DAETT that Sirius and Harry would actually get to live a long life together?
No, as much as I wanted it. It was too good to be true.DAETT In a twist, Neville was going to turn out to be the Chosen one (he and Harry had the same birthday)?
NOooo i thought he would do something big but not the chosen one no that doesn't make sense DAETT Percy would return to his family at the end?
No. DAETT Bellatrix shouldn't have died?
YES!! DEATT... Sirus was gonna get out alive?
nopeDEATT belletrix and voldemort had a secret relationship
YES!!! DEATT that Harry would end up with Hermione?
Well duh, of course! they should have!DAETT Ginny is stuck up?
guys what are talking about Ginny was the best thing happened to harry in the whole 7 books, he didn't need a bookworm bossing him around he need love and care after what he been through.DAETT Hermione should be the minister of magic in the end?
That would have been nice, but maybe when she was older. DAETT Dumbledore knew Sirius was innocent all along?
For sure. DAETT Crookshanks was a BAMF?
Lisa wrote: "For sure. DAETT Crookshanks was a BAMF?"
LOL Sure
DAETT Crookshanks would turn out to be an animagus too?
Nope.. well she was a clever cat but I didn't get that impression.DAETT the film (OOTP) would show the ST Mungo's christmas scene where Harry and gang find out what really happened to Neville's parents. (so disappointed they left it out =()
Well they should have the movies always skipped the good part. ( I hated the movies)DAETT snape was actually in love with Harry's mom before harry finds about that ?
No way.I never would've guessed that. Especially with how he always treated Harry. But it was awesome to discover.DAETT Dean Thomas or Neville would be killed in DH? Especially with Dean being on the run, and Neville stuck at Hogwarts with DEATHEATER professors.
Yes! My friend figured it out the moment Sirius mentioned his brothers name!
DAETT Dean and Ginny were actually going to make it?
DAETT Dean and Ginny were actually going to make it?
NO! They fought too much.DAETT Luna could kinda tell what others were thinking?
Yes!!!DAETT CHO and Harry were going to last?
NEVER!!!DEATT...
Luna was the smartest person EVER!!
DAETT Hermione was annoying in OoTP when she was all 'anti-Sirius and 'Sirius-is-too-irresponsible-to-be-taken-seriously'? It pissed me off so bad!
Yes absolutely, it's like she had something against him. I mean, he's all cooped up, give him a break, and she's acting like he's an idiot or something.
DAETT we'd get to see Neville's gran in the films?
we didn't?? I just assumed that I did! odd!DEATT Luna was/is the smartest person alive, like ever?!?
I think she is very smart and profound in some ways yes but not smartest person ever.DEATT Moody/Barty Crouch Jr. was joking at first when he told Harry he was a death eater?
sortaDEATT Sirius was going to somehow come back to life after he died?
Keep Calm and Read a Book wrote: "sortaDEATT Sirius was going to somehow come back to life after he died?"
Yes. Especially with the constant reference to "the arch veil". There seemed to be something there and I keep expecting that at some interval Sirius is going to "pop up" and explained to Harry what had happened to him. Harry was so heart broken I felt so sorry for him.
DAETT that Ian McKellen should be Dumbledore? (my son actually asked me "isn't that Dumbledore" when we watch The Hobbit and Gandolf appeared)
Yes: It would have prevented the Dumbledore switcharoo in the series.DAETT that a Prequel(with James, Lily, Sirius, Snape, Lupin, and Wormtail) would have been AMAZING?
Yes!! absolutelyDAETT Harry should not have ended up with Ginny?
No. Harry-Ginny match was ok. (Though their story should've been developed slowly, not rushed like in HP6).Did anyone in their wildest dreams imagine that Neville was going to turn into a badass?
(*** Huge SPOILERS ahead, so those who haven't finished HP7, stay away!
"Neville became courageous when all hope was lost.At that moment, he became my hero! :D Hee hee. I had tears streaming down my face with all the overwhelming emotion after knowing Snape's tale, and that Harry was acting dead; after Neville's speech and act of slaying the snake, I literally jumped up and down!"
End of SPOILERS.)
Yeah I could sorta see it happening and his confidence growing, especially in OOTP when he was working hard in the DA and the battle in the Ministry at the end.DAETT Rita Skeeter was an animagus before Hermione found out?
NOPE!DAETT that Sirius BLack's death was one of the sadest part of the entire series
Amna wrote: "DAETT one of the member of the golden trio should have died?"funny you should ask that since JKR originally had planned for Ron to die
Shoe-mena wrote: "NOPE!
DAETT that Sirius BLack's death was one of the sadest part of the entire series"
Yes.
DAETT Luna Lovegood is one of the best characters ever?
DAETT that Sirius BLack's death was one of the sadest part of the entire series"
Yes.
DAETT Luna Lovegood is one of the best characters ever?
yes, Dobby shouldn't have. that's the saddest memory for me.That Dumbledore would come back alive?
Yes, thought he wouldDAET What happened to fluffy?
Oh, yeah, of course.
DAETT Professor Dumbledore would die by Snape??
(Replying to Message 8) I thought Dumbledore and McGonagall had a relationship of some romantic type in the past but since it was never brought up in the books, I guess I was wrong.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
