The Mark of Athena (The Heroes of Olympus, #3) The Mark of Athena discussion


1910 views
who of the 7 is the strongest?

Comments Showing 101-150 of 488 (488 new)    post a comment »

message 101: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Lauren wrote: "Truly, I really dislike Piper. Nico said himself, "Percy is one of the strongest demigod." But she can't accept that." Well she says Jason is strongest. Accept that, why don't you? Opinions are opinions, not facts.


Christina O. All of them are pretty powerful but if it came down to a fight, I would bet on Annabeth. Despite not having any special powers like the rest of them she could out smart all of them.


message 103: by Ananth (last edited Dec 20, 2013 04:54PM) (new)

Ananth Dria wrote: "Lauren wrote: "Truly, I really dislike Piper. Nico said himself, "Percy is one of the strongest demigod." But she can't accept that." Well she says Jason is strongest. Accept that, why don't you? O..."
Piper really gets on my nerve too. I think she is just too adamant to realize that Jason seriously sucks.


Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~ Rogers/America percy,frank, and LEO! Personally I think Piper is the weakest...


message 105: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Well, so am I. Give up now.


Gayathri Ok. I am kind of surprised by seeing all of your really long answers. My answer is short and steady and I will remain faithful to the heroes who were there from the beginning of the book- PERCY AND ANNABETH A.K.A PERCABETH!!!!! Have an awesome Sunday to all the proud Indians! A merry christmas!


message 107: by Gowan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gowan nico


message 108: by Ananth (new)

Ananth I'm wondering what their fatal flaws are:
Percy Jackson - Personal loyalty
Annabeth Chase - Pride
Nico di Angelo - Holding Grudges
Hazel Levesque - Holding Grudges?
Leo Valdez - Inferiority?
Frank Zhang - Inferiority?
Piper McLean - ?
Jason Grace - ?


Kaivallya Ananth wrote: "I'm wondering what their fatal flaws are:
Percy Jackson - Personal loyalty
Annabeth Chase - Pride
Nico di Angelo - Holding Grudges
Hazel Levesque - Holding Grudges?
Leo Valdez - Inferiority?
Frank ..."

Their fatal flaws will help judge how strong they are, and I also think it would give us a new look at their personalities. It's an interesting question. I think I might like some of them better if I knew their fatal flaw. I hope it's mentioned in Blood of Olympus.


message 110: by Ananth (last edited Dec 25, 2013 12:34PM) (new)

Ananth They all are pretty powerful though.Here is a list of their powers
Percy Jackson - Hydrokinesis,Aerokinesis,Geokinesis,Electrokinesis,Cryokinesis,Toxikinesis,Heat Resistance

Nico di Angelo - Geokinesis,Umbrakinesis,Necromancy,Shadow Travel,Death Trance,Induced Fear,Life Aura,Sensitivity to Death,Telepathy with the Dead

Jason Grace - Aerokinesis,Electrokinesis

Hazel Levesque - Geokinesis,Ferrokinesis,Shadow Travel,Death Sense,Flashbacks,Mist Manipulation

Leo Valdez - Pyrokinesis,Technokinesis,Trap Detection,Fire Immunity,Fighting Skills

Annabeth Chase - Divine Wisdom,Strategy and Battle Skill,Crafts

Frank Zhang - Necromancy,Blessing of Mars,Archery,Swordsman,Tactician,Father's Voices

Piper McLean - Amokinesis,Charmspeak,Beauty,French

Source:camphalfblood.wikia.com


message 111: by Ananth (new)

Ananth When Nico,Percy and Thalia encountered Melinoe,goddess of ghosts she showed them deaths they regret.
Percy Jackson -?
Annabeth Chase - Luke Castellan
Jason Grace - Ms.Grace
Piper McLean -?
Leo Valdez - Esperanza Valdez
Nico di Angelo - Maria di Angelo
Hazel Levesque - Marie Levesque
Frank Zhang - Emily Zhang


message 112: by Neha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neha For Frank it could be her Grandmother too

For Percy it could be Bob, i guess.
And for Piper....no one, she'll be the one who charmspeak others out of it.


Unicorn 1.Percy
2.Nico(although technically he is not a part of the seven)
3.Annabeth
4.Jason
5.Frank
6.Leo
7.Hazel
8.Piper(not even worth mentioning!)


message 114: by Ananth (new)

Ananth 1.Percy
2.Nico
3.Jason
4.Annabeth
5.Leo
6.Frank
7.Hazel
8.Piper


message 115: by [deleted user] (new)

ANNABETH ANNABETH ANNABETH ANNABETH ANNABETH ANNABETH ANNABETH ANNABETH!


message 116: by Ananth (new)

Ananth Maddie wrote: "Define strongest.

Strongest like muscles, or character, strong values, strong heart, or all of the above?"


Strongest powers and personalities.


Cera  Hodges Percy is definately in power. But I also think Leo event though you don't really think about it, is one of the strongest, he comes up with alot of the plans with out percy and annabeth being there, gadgets (which everyone needs), and is pretty mentally strong.


Kaivallya I agree. Leo is pretty strong. He's the reason they're all flying around the world, because HE built the ship, he operates it, and he fights. In HoH, he takes on the dwarves more or less alone. In MoA, in my favourite scene, he comes up with a plan to steal the bronze 'mirror' Narcissus is obsessed with. And of course, he has his powers.
But I still think Hazel is stronger.


Cera  Hodges Hazel was one of my favourites but in every book how I feel to chracters are changing. But leo is still the same, He's one of my favourite but I didn't say he was one of the powerfulest just cause he's my favourite, he truey is. There are alot out of the seven that you think are different but Leo is sort of the outcast of the seven because every one is a couple. it's going to be interesting in the next book becasuse Leo has fallen in love with a god. So his pretty srong with being the outcast of the seven and all.


message 120: by Ananth (new)

Ananth I really wish Leo had a sword where he could use his powers to defeat enemies.


message 121: by Anne (last edited Jan 02, 2014 08:05AM) (new)

Anne Emma wrote: "1. Percy
2. Jason
3. Frank*
4. Leo
5. Annabeth
6. Hazel
7. Piper*

*Powers are unreliable, or they are emotionally unstable"


This is true, but if it is from powers, honestly Annabeth should be lower. Instead, if this is about being the most demigodly capable, she should be much higher since she can think her way out of anything pretty much. I totally agree with the rest though. Percy all the way.


message 122: by Ananth (new)

Ananth That's true.


Cera  Hodges Very true. I kind of have a feeling jason isn't as powerful as everyone thinks he is.


message 124: by Maya (new) - rated it 5 stars

Maya Technically, this is two people, but Percy and Annabeth make each other so much stronger. Also, they've had a lot more experience and training then anyone else of the seven. (You might say Jason has, but did he go on a bunch of quests?) They know how to fight together really well, and they could beat almost anyone in a battle.


message 125: by Naja (new) - rated it 5 stars

Naja 1. Percy(Perseus) Jackson
2. Annabeth Chase (Nico di Angelo)
3. Leo Valdez
4. Jason Grace
5. Hazel Levesque
6. Frank Zhang
7. Piper McLean


message 126: by Ananth (new)

Ananth I would have to agree with that.


Bonnick jason and percy for top stop for me i say they are equal. Can't take nico word for it since he is just like piper giving an opinion of someone he cares about and knows longer.

2. Leo as long as he has that sphere with him too oh yea.

3. Frank yea gorilla and dragon transformation are epic

4. Hazel mist bending does count for alot

5. Annabeth

6. Piper i owuld put her higher, because charmspeak is pretty hax, but she doesn't have the martial skills the rest got.


Dauntless Demigod Tomonari wrote: "I am better.
They all suck!
I am better.
They all suck!
I am better.
They all suck!
I am better.
They all suck!
I am better.
They all suck!
I am better.
They all suck!
I am better.
They all suck!
I..."

umm im pretty sure they have the ability to whop your butt so...


Dauntless Demigod Kayla wrote: "I think Percy is the strongest as far as power goes. Not that Jason isn't powerful, it's just I think Percy does better under pressured situations but Jason is usually getting his ass saved by some..."

lol what u said about jason!!!


Dauntless Demigod Sarah wrote: "ωαт¢н ɱє fℓу wrote: "Emma wrote: "1. Percy
2. Jason
3. Frank*
4. Leo
5. Annabeth
6. Hazel
7. Piper*

*Powers are unreliable, or they are emotionally unstable"

I agree :)"

Couldn't have put it tog..."

switch leo and frank and i have the exact list!!


message 131: by Aarya (new) - added it

Aarya 1. Percy
2. Jason
3. Anabeth
4. Frank
4. Leo
5. Hazel
6. Piper

I think Leo and Frank are even because Frank is more shy and unsure of himself. His life is also dependent on a stick. Leo is good with fire and machine and all, but he's not very strong mentally. Leo is also not very good with people. Piper is ranked low because she can't really fight in battle. Sure she can talk and persuade people she just seems to rely on the others for everything else. I in my opinion Anabeth should be given more credit and ranked higher than some people have ranked her. She proved that she is a great thinker in Mark of Athena. She can also use about almost every weapon you give her. She ranks high in my book of heroes..


Georgia PERCY, any one who disagrees has not read the Percy Jackson series...

I got into a argument at school because somebody like Jason more, and I found out they hadn't read the Percy Jackson series. I sent them off to read it(I ordered them to go to the library and borrow the Lightning Thief) and a two weeks later they were ranting about how much better Percy was


Dauntless Demigod Georgia wrote: "PERCY, any one who disagrees has not read the Percy Jackson series...

I got into a argument at school because somebody like Jason more, and I found out they hadn't read the Percy Jackson series. ..."

hell ya!!!!!


message 134: by Ananth (new)

Ananth Plus summoning one lightning bolt takes a lot of Jason's energy whereas Percy can easily control the water. Although I think Nico can control his powers better than others.


Dauntless Demigod Ananth wrote: "Plus summoning one lightning bolt takes a lot of Jason's energy whereas Percy can easily control the water. Although I think Nico can control his powers better than others."
uhuh


message 136: by Neha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neha Lets NOT drag the topic to who is better-Percy and Jason. 'Im tired of convincing people that they're brothers and equally strong with different personalitites so theres nothing to compared to between them.'
How about answer in one word- Who is the strongest?

Sorry, just my opinion.


Bonnick Neha (Athena) (Bast) (Queen Elinor) wrote: "Lets NOT drag the topic to who is better-Percy and Jason. 'Im tired of convincing people that they're brothers and equally strong with different personalitites so theres nothing to compared to betw..."

as much as i agree with you it makes the forum more fun so i enjoy the arguments.


message 138: by Ananth (new)

Ananth You have to give credit to Nico. He survived Tartarus on his own, even if he got captured, that is an impressive feat


Kaivallya Ananth wrote: "You have to give credit to Nico. He survived Tartarus on his own, even if he got captured, that is an impressive feat"
True, but he's not one of the Seven, is he?
If by 'strongest', we're talking about powers, then Annabeth should really be ranked lower. I wish she had a power, but she doesn't. She's the only one of the Seven who doesn't.
Emotional strength is a different matter. Personally, I don't think either Annabeth or Percy could've survived Tartarus on their own. They managed only because of each other, and they said as much in the book. I'm not sure about the others.


Bonnick Kaivallya wrote: "Ananth wrote: "You have to give credit to Nico. He survived Tartarus on his own, even if he got captured, that is an impressive feat"
True, but he's not one of the Seven, is he?
If by 'strongest', ..."


you mean because of Bob.


message 141: by Ananth (new)

Ananth Who cares if Nico isn't one of the seven. He scares Jason,Frank and Leo with his powers.


message 142: by Neha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neha Lol. He scares almost everyone with his powers..
Even demigods like Thalia and Clarisse are pretty powerful. Just because they're not one in the prophecy of seven doesn't mean they aren't strong.


message 143: by Sydney (last edited Jan 10, 2014 12:17PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sydney Duval I am starting to read the house of hades, and, after reading what i just did, i have COMPLETE FAITH that Hazel is more powerful than she seems. I say:
1) Percy
2) Annabeth&hazel
4)Frank& Jason
6) Leo
7)Piper


message 144: by 1304Jared (new) - added it

1304Jared percy of course


message 145: by Ananth (last edited Jan 10, 2014 01:24PM) (new)

Ananth I think Leo is powerful since his powers match a child of a Big Three.


message 146: by Ananth (new)

Ananth Katherine wrote: "1.Percy(obviously the best, powers, fighting experience, smart)
2.Leo(powers, very smart and quick thinking, mechanically strong, doesn't take things seriously at times)
3.Jason(powers, fighting ex..."


Annabeth is not too reliant on Percy. She can fight for herself. She doesn't exactly have a gigantic ego.


message 147: by Ananth (new)

Ananth Neha (Athena) (Bast) (Queen Elinor) wrote: "Lol. He scares almost everyone with his powers..
Even demigods like Thalia and Clarisse are pretty powerful. Just because they're not one in the prophecy of seven doesn't mean they aren't strong."

Percy,Annabeth and hazel are not scared of his powers. They respect him though.


message 148: by Ananth (new)

Ananth It depends on what type of strength.
Powers- Percy,Nico,Jason,Leo,Hazel,Frank,Piper,Annabeth
Tactics- Annabeth,Frank,Jason,Percy,Leo,Hazel,Nico,Piper
Fighting- Percy,Annabeth,Nico,Jason,Frank,Hazel,Leo,Piper
Wisdom- Annabeth,Leo,Nico,Jason,Hazel,Frank,Piper,Percy


Srikari i would say annabeth coz she is smart and has things under control even when everything goes wrong (like wen they fall into tarturus ! and piper coz i LOVE her CHARM SPEAK!!! I want it :(


message 150: by Prathar (new)

Prathar Emily wrote: "When you think about it, theres a lot more you could do with water than with lightning. Sure Jason can fly, but thats a bit shaky and rarely used. Percy has used water a lot and yes, he does need w..."

percy can bring water to himself even when there is no water arount him


back to top