The Mark of Athena
discussion
DON'T READ IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MARK OF ATHEN! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Will Percy and Annabeth have to get shut inside tartarus?
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Selena
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Nov 15, 2012 07:37AM
That is too much math o.0
reply
|
flag
Atleast the would be together! Poor Annabeth and Percy They fell into a botomless pit full of evil
Eissej911 wrote: "well, i think that Nico will be locked in the Underworld, coz he can shadow-travel out, right?"If he could shadow travel to get out. Why didn't he get out that way in Mark of Athena?
Em wrote: "Eissej911 wrote: "well, i think that Nico will be locked in the Underworld, coz he can shadow-travel out, right?"
If he could shadow travel to get out. Why didn't he get out that way in Mark of At..."
I think he was captured by the giants...but the thing is that it's supposed to be bronze walls...or something. idk, im not makeing sense
If he could shadow travel to get out. Why didn't he get out that way in Mark of At..."
I think he was captured by the giants...but the thing is that it's supposed to be bronze walls...or something. idk, im not makeing sense
Darius123 wrote:So long as the sword of hades exists no one will be stuck in Tartarus.
What I am worried about is the fall. According to mythologteny it would
take ten days two fall from Hades to Tartarus. Tartarus has no air so according to the laws of gravity Percy and Annabeth
would hit at a speed of 847200m/s the impact from their fall would be like a nuclear bomb.
The six need to save them before the nine days.
Selena wrote: "That is too much math o.0"
Ughh...i agree...but if that is true...wow...
But if you think about it, even if their friends manage to get there within nine days, Percy and Annabeth would still be falling all this time and unless they found some way to stop their fall without crushing themselves, even if they caught them or even slowed them down some...they would still fall at the least of 700000m/s and that is still a deathly fall.
If Percy still had his powers from swimming in the Styx River he could've had a small chance of survival as long as he didnt fall on his lower back-his Achilles heel.
He would have to position himself to protect Annabeth too...although i dont think she will be able to survive the fall at all (sorry Annabeth!)
Plus you have to think about the piece of rock or whatever was dragging her (annabeth) down when she first slid in, that would add mass to their weight, although it would not make them go any faster it would make the fall harder...and considering they are getting closer to the Earth's core...they would fall even faster...
Conclusion: There is technically no logical reason that they will survive...
Consider:
>This is fiction
>This is Tartarus we are talking about
>They may fall into water (if there is any down there) which is sort of worse than the ground...
What I am worried about is the fall. According to mythologteny it would
take ten days two fall from Hades to Tartarus. Tartarus has no air so according to the laws of gravity Percy and Annabeth
would hit at a speed of 847200m/s the impact from their fall would be like a nuclear bomb.
The six need to save them before the nine days.
Selena wrote: "That is too much math o.0"
Ughh...i agree...but if that is true...wow...
But if you think about it, even if their friends manage to get there within nine days, Percy and Annabeth would still be falling all this time and unless they found some way to stop their fall without crushing themselves, even if they caught them or even slowed them down some...they would still fall at the least of 700000m/s and that is still a deathly fall.
If Percy still had his powers from swimming in the Styx River he could've had a small chance of survival as long as he didnt fall on his lower back-his Achilles heel.
He would have to position himself to protect Annabeth too...although i dont think she will be able to survive the fall at all (sorry Annabeth!)
Plus you have to think about the piece of rock or whatever was dragging her (annabeth) down when she first slid in, that would add mass to their weight, although it would not make them go any faster it would make the fall harder...and considering they are getting closer to the Earth's core...they would fall even faster...
Conclusion: There is technically no logical reason that they will survive...
Consider:
>This is fiction
>This is Tartarus we are talking about
>They may fall into water (if there is any down there) which is sort of worse than the ground...
Juliana~The Story Of Amelia Pond wrote: "Half Blood wrote: "PERCY BETTER NOT GET LOCKED HE'S AWESOME!! AS FOR ANNABETH...I DON'T CARE!!!! I HATE ANNABETH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!..."really? how could you? wait...let me guess, you're a piper fan??
Darius123 wrote: "So long as the sword of hades exists no one will be stuck in Tartarus.What I am worried about is the fall. According to mythologteny it would
take ten days two fall from Hades to Tartarus. Tarta..."
oh gawd O.O that's probably what's going to happen O.O and is it unlikely that the demigods have about a weeks deadline??? but the fact still remains that anne and percy need to get to the bottom of there and close the gates before...what was it? august first? yeahh that, sooooo i think the ten days will still play into the book but after that time is up then what?
Em wrote: "Eissej911 wrote: "well, i think that Nico will be locked in the Underworld, coz he can shadow-travel out, right?"If he could shadow travel to get out. Why didn't he get out that way in Mark of At..."
kidnapped, he couldn't
Tanya wrote: "Darius123 wrote:So long as the sword of hades exists no one will be stuck in Tartarus.What I am worried about is the fall. According to mythologteny it would
take ten days two fall from Hades to..."
if they fall into water, then obviously they are going to be alive, c'mon! i don't care if it is tarturus, water is water, percy will control it to save annabeth
Janelle wrote: "Tanya wrote: "Darius123 wrote:So long as the sword of hades exists no one will be stuck in Tartarus.
What I am worried about is the fall. According to mythologteny it would
take ten days two fall..."
This is Tartarus we are talking about here!! Some of most powerful monsters and titans are banished here and i bet you most of them could use water somehow to their ability, yet they cant! Percy couldnt even control the waters around alaska because they were technically "out of bounds"...Did i mention this is Tartarus we are talking about here!! Hades himself has very little power over this place...and i dont think even the strongest demigod could control this place, i bet you not even a minor god would have any control. Tarturus is ancient, even before the Gods and titans, it was there!
What I am worried about is the fall. According to mythologteny it would
take ten days two fall..."
This is Tartarus we are talking about here!! Some of most powerful monsters and titans are banished here and i bet you most of them could use water somehow to their ability, yet they cant! Percy couldnt even control the waters around alaska because they were technically "out of bounds"...Did i mention this is Tartarus we are talking about here!! Hades himself has very little power over this place...and i dont think even the strongest demigod could control this place, i bet you not even a minor god would have any control. Tarturus is ancient, even before the Gods and titans, it was there!
But if you think about it in a different way, Tartarus can be like heaven, no matter how far you go up all you reach is space, so Tartarus is more of a different dimensional place, that you can only enter through different places, like Arachnid's shrine or the house of hades, so it would have its own rules on gravity and stuff. There are many possibilities if you think of it like that...Gosh i hope RicK R. finishes the book soon...im going to go insane!! :)
(( HEY! come post on the Hades fan fic!! ))
There is only one river in tartarus. The parthegon the river of fire.There is no light in tartarus. As erebus is trapped there by hades. Every day Nyx goes in to tartarus and comes out during the night. During the day Himera godess of day comes out of tartarus and returns there at night. So
during nightfall percybeth may get some light.
Typhoon is in Tartarus, not to mention Giga is Tartaru's lover.
I think that Percy and Annabeth will encounter a lot in Tartarus but they will make it out Ok.After all Percy is one powerful demigod and Annabeth is pretty smart.
Ok everyone, I know logically the fall will kill them, so there's little of even if something did get there in time they would crush them and kill them as well, we also need to remember that if Percy and Annabeth die falling into the pit they can't close the door from the inside and that means someone else, if not the whole group will enter to go looking for them! You also have to remember that Nico got out, if he can do it I'm sure Percy and annabeth can too! Also there are more giants that need to be killed, so the gods also need to play a role int he next book! Percy and Annabeth will not fall to their deaths, they cants it would just ruin the happy ending that Rick has worked so hard to create! Also frank still needs to make a sacrifice that Percy can't make- I believe that's how the line goes- and Leo is still the seventh wheel, and we've barely seen Jason in action and we haven't even got to see the other half of everyone's journey! We only sore Percy annabeth Leo and pipers side so in the next book I believe we will see Jason hazel frank and maybe even Nicos side to the story, though I do hope we get a bit of info on Percy and annabeth in the Pitt of doom!
I say we look on the bright side, annabeth and Percy can't die. They are the main characters, Rick wouldn't let them die, I imagine they are his favorites considering the Percy Jackson series. And he's gonna get a lot if angry fan mail if he does kill them off so if I were him I'd just wanna make us all sweat but and with a happily ever after!
Maybe one of the others might die, I'm guessing frank cos hazel can still hang around him in the afterlife and she was also given a second chance at life, but that may have an expiry date to it. and that is a bit more happier than anyone else dying and never seeing that loved one again.
Rick is a great author and we need to trust he will do the right thing and let everyone live happily ever after.
Yasmin wrote: Rick is a great author and we need to trust he will do the right thing and let everyone live happily ever after.
AGREED
AGREED
i kno right i think tht too
There are two more books coming so its only reasonable!!
It's so intense the waiting! I with we're out so I could just finish then so I know what happens!!!
I think Hazel/Frank will be left behind because they're the two most likely to die. I love them both, but I do think they are the ones who will.
Thomas wrote: "Citlaly wrote: "PERCY BETTER NOT GET LOCKED HE'S AWESOME!! AS FOR ANNABETH...I DON'T CARE!!!! I HATE ANNABETH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!..."Rick Riordan is not a bloody author. There is no such thing as oversmart. SO what she had a crush on Luke first? She didn't go after Percy just because he killed a couple bloody monsters! And Rachel was never meant for Percy.
Thomas wrote: "Citlaly wrote: "PERCY BETTER NOT GET LOCKED HE'S AWESOME!! AS FOR ANNABETH...I DON'T CARE!!!! I HATE ANNABETH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!..."i agree with thomas on the first part but he is not a bloody author rick is the best author I've whom i've read books from.
Rick is awesome but Percy would never leave annabeth! They're a package deal. So if one gets out the other will as well. Also if annabeth is left than pert will do whatever he can to get her back! He will probably enter again to find and spend his life with her in Tartarus.
if they do survive, then they can say that they went to Tartarus and back together. doesn't get much more romantic than that.
Percy and Annabeth will end up together neither will die (they better not get trapped either) or I'm going to find Rick and tell him to re write the whole damn book until I'm satisfied with the ending! And apparently there is a book after this one, doors of hades I think, so something else has to happen as well. They'll get out alive but I want to know what happens after that! They go back to camp settle the war and have a dinner with the gods, that can all fit into the one book. So the new question we should be asking is what's gonna happen next? Percy will not be left in Tartarus and he will not leave Annabeth so they make it out, I'm note sure who will close the door from the inside but who will do it is an unknown question! No one will know until we read the book. I wanna know what could happen at the end that means a new book?
Yasmin wrote: "This is all to much for an ending!!! Why didn't he release the next book straight after the mark of Athena!!!"For Rick to do that, it would have taken twice as long for both the Mark of Athena and the House of Hades to come out, as he'd have to write both of them before releasing them. I don't know about you, but I want to have the new books as soon as they're written! If you just want to read the books one after the other, then you wait until Rick has finished the whole series and read them all then.
Thomas wrote: "I must say that iam reading his novels for instant enjoyment and not for the bloody ways in which story goes. It's unbelivable that percy is with annabeth. SHe is ambtious and cleaver and a leech. ..."What is wrong with being ambitious and clever? Those are two positive attributes.
Thomas wrote: "I dont think so. She is not an affordable gf. Also you are missing the last adjectives."Well clever and moronic are opposites so that makes no sense, therefore I didn't feel the need to include that one. Also, 'a leech' isn't an adjective.
Camron wrote: "NO percy is the greatest character in the world and annabeth is just well amazing."
exactly
exactly
Thomas wrote: "Leah wrote: "Thomas wrote: "I dont think so. She is not an affordable gf. Also you are missing the last adjectives."Well clever and moronic are opposites so that makes no sense, therefore I didn'..."
How can a person be clever and moronic? how can a person be smart and dumb at the same time? Can they be ugly and pretty at the same time? Can they be tall and short at the same time?
Thomas wrote: "I must say that iam reading his novels for instant enjoyment and not for the bloody ways in which story goes. It's unbelivable that percy is with annabeth. SHe is ambtious and cleaver and a leech. ..."haha i agree i will feed her head to the monsters myself, but i bet not even the monsters would want her! haha
Leah wrote: "Thomas wrote: "Leah wrote: "Thomas wrote: "I dont think so. She is not an affordable gf. Also you are missing the last adjectives."Well clever and moronic are opposites so that makes no sense, th..."
I agree with Leah. I really dont get why do you think that way.
I dont know but i really hope annabeth and percy get out together and yeah maybe nico can close the doors and hades will help him out or maybe someone new will come along and save them
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
