The Mark of Athena (The Heroes of Olympus, #3) The Mark of Athena discussion


177 views
DON'T READ IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MARK OF ATHEN! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Will Percy and Annabeth have to get shut inside tartarus?

Comments (showing 1-50 of 87) (87 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Dawn (last edited Nov 05, 2012 12:46PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dawn Okay, this has been killing me! If Percy and Annabeth shut the doors from the tartarus side, and the others shut it from the other side, won't Percy and Annabeth get locked in!?


Melissa Nahra i think one peron would have to stay behind:(but i'm sure that they could find a way to get that person back:)


Emma I agree with Melissa. Maybe Nico could close the doors and get saved by his dad somehow.


Anna-Cosette My friend had this prediction (she recently changed it slightly, but I don't remember to what)

It was said Percy would have to make a sacrifice he couldn't make, and that Frank would have to do it for him. So she (my friend) thought that maybe while they're closing the doors, Percy and Annabeth still behind them, Frank grabs Percy and pulls him out at the last second because he couldn't leave Annabeth.

Also, they (Percy and Annabeth) kept promising each other they'd never leave each other (An oath to keep with a final breath)... I lost where I was going with this, anyways I said the main part of what I was going to say!


Dawn That all sounds so sad! :(


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

I'm going to cry. I just...I can't. asdfghjkl


Dawn I seriously hope you guys are wrong!


Yazzy Omg i didn't think of that I really hope it's not true, I'll be pissed if it is. I don't know why but i think Nico will be the one to close it from the inside, I'm not sure why though, maybe he knew that Percy was still needed to finish the battle and Annabeth need to bring back the statue, and everyone else have a part to play, and Nico locks himself behind the doors of death because he is Deaths son. I'm not sure if I'm making sense, it's hard to explain and this won't be a good ending whatever way it goes so i don't wanna be right about anything.

On the bright side maybe one of the bad guys turns good and decides that they'll close the doors and find their friends.

Maybe Coach Hedge will close them, he didn't have too big a role in the Mark of Athena and he'll be able to kill everything in there....


Dawn Maybe, but I like Nico! He's awesome! :( There's no positive way to end the next book!


Yazzy I know I love nico too but someone has to be on the inside to close the door and they need to save percy


Emily maybe Hazel will close the door because she isn't even supposed to be alive now.


message 12: by Dawn (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dawn Maybe, but that would be sad too. :(


Paola Em wrote: "maybe Hazel will close the door because she isn't even supposed to be alive now."

That's what I was thinking. We all need to remember that Nico is not the only son of Hades/Pluto, so there's a possibility that Hazel ends up doing it.


Emily Hazel wrote: "Maybe, but that would be sad too. :("

totaly agree. I love Hazel but i have to say if a child of Hades closes it form inside tartarus I'd rather it be her than Nico.


message 15: by Dawn (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dawn Haha, no my name is not Hazel, I did it for a group I'm in. and I have to agree, it's a childrens book, (but still AWESOME) and Rick can't make it super sad. Someone unimportant will probably close them.


message 16: by [deleted user] (new)

Maybe someone like Reyna will close them. Or maybe Bianca di Angelo will turn up! We can hope...


message 17: by Dawn (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dawn I do like Leo and think he would be better for Hazel, but I like Frank a lot too. And I hope he doesn't have to do it.And I hope it's not Reyna, I like her too. I like everyone! Oh well, we'll see.


Yazzy Maybe frank does it! Cos his stick is running to an end and maybe needs to use his powers to close the doors and as he goes he dies anyway! Than hazel goes back to the afterlife to join him or stays with Leo


Selena yep thats what i said about frank! but interesting theory in hazel/leo/frank love trio :D


Yazzy It is interesting about the low trio! I love them all and I want them all to be happy up I don't hunk Leo and hazel will get together considering hat Hera said 'you will always be the seventh wheel' so that might be it Leo doesn't get someone! So maybe Leo is the one locked inside


Yazzy It is interesting about the low trio! I love them all and I want them all to be happy up I don't hunk Leo and hazel will get together considering hat Hera said 'you will always be the seventh wheel' so that might be it Leo doesn't get someone! So maybe Leo is the one locked inside


Selena yep your right! although i do hate hera


Emily Selena wrote: "yep your right! although i do hate hera"

i think everyone hates Hera


Yazzy Ur right about Hera and I hate Gaia bloody cow making even one do stuff for her and ending up in Tartarus


Emmilly Em wrote: "Hazel wrote: "Maybe, but that would be sad too. :("

totaly agree. I love Hazel but i have to say if a child of Hades closes it form inside tartarus I'd rather it be her than Nico."


I love Nico as much as the next guy, but don't forget he technically also shouldn't be alive because he and Bianca were trapped inside The Lotus Hotel and Casino for all those years, but I agree, I would rather is be Hazel, I don't mind her, she is way less anoying than Piper, but still, it's Nico we're talking about...<3


Janelle Hazel wrote: "Maybe, but that would be sad too. :("

ouch


Janelle Em wrote: "Selena wrote: "yep your right! although i do hate hera"

i think everyone hates Hera"


mmm, i think you're right about that.


Janelle Emmilly wrote: "Em wrote: "Hazel wrote: "Maybe, but that would be sad too. :("

totaly agree. I love Hazel but i have to say if a child of Hades closes it form inside tartarus I'd rather it be her than Nico."

I..."


finally someone reads my mind, nico is one step down from leo and leo is one step down from percy, so nico. CAN'T. DIE.


Janelle oh, and

LIKE

to all of your comments, for being technical and truthful about your opinions.


Emily Emmilly wrote: "Em wrote: "Hazel wrote: "Maybe, but that would be sad too. :("

totaly agree. I love Hazel but i have to say if a child of Hades closes it form inside tartarus I'd rather it be her than Nico."

I..."


true but there is a distinct difference between not aging for a period of time and completely dying and coming back to life.


Janelle mhm, well either way, neither of them are supposed to be alive. Well I guess Nico could, but he would be a VERY old man.
Well technically just about none of them are supposed to be living. Hazel, Percy, Jason, and Thalia are obviously not supposed to be alive. Nico, Leo, Annabeth and Frank are very VERY lucky to be alive right now, they've each been practically over the edge of death, and well Piper has had it pretty easy so far :P


message 32: by Maddie (new) - added it

Maddie I predict that Frank will make the sacrifice that Percy couldn't. Since Frank has too many powers for a mortal anyways, maybe he will somehow become a god?


Selena omg i haven't thought about that!


Emmilly Em wrote: "Emmilly wrote: "Em wrote: "Hazel wrote: "Maybe, but that would be sad too. :("

totaly agree. I love Hazel but i have to say if a child of Hades closes it form inside tartarus I'd rather it be he..."


Good point(:


message 35: by King JT (new) - added it

King JT They will be back, I would kill Rick if he let them stay there, plus it would practically be the end if that happened.


Janelle Maddie wrote: "I predict that Frank will make the sacrifice that Percy couldn't. Since Frank has too many powers for a mortal anyways, maybe he will somehow become a god?"

good point, that would definitely make me feel better if t hat happened :)


Yazzy Yer me too its really bad that we have no ending or even a firm idea of how the next book will end


Emily We also can't forget that there are two more books in the series not one


Yazzy I thought there was only the doors of hades left than that's the end of Percy jackson


Janelle nope, there's five books total of HoO


Yazzy Cool


message 42: by [deleted user] (new)

no no no no no no no no not my OTP, haven't they been through enough, seriously cant the gods just leave PERCABETH alone for once


Weiting Hazel wrote: "Okay, this has been killing me! If Percy and Annabeth shut the doors from the tartarus side, and the others shut it from the other side, won't Percy and Annabeth get locked in!?"

Well, like, um..to close the doors, they have to be opened. So what about if Percy and Annabeth go outside with their friends and close both doors at the same time?


Janelle TheEmoQueen wrote: "no no no no no no no no not my OTP, haven't they been through enough, seriously cant the gods just leave PERCABETH alone for once"

LIKE
thank you queen, have i ever told you i love you and your beautiful opinions before?


Citlaly PERCY BETTER NOT GET LOCKED HE'S AWESOME!! AS FOR ANNABETH...I DON'T CARE!!!! I HATE ANNABETH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Yazzy This is all to much for an ending!!! Why didn't he release the next book straight after the mark of Athena!!! You can't leave us on a cliff hanger like that and not even have a blurb in mind for the net book!!!!!

The ending made me cry so bad! When Percy won't let annabeth got! And then try drop together!!! Omg why didn't the other guys leave the damn statue and rescue them! Ohhhhhh great I'm crying now!! Bloody hell I can't even think about the ending without getting super upset at everything!!


message 47: by Kendrastarr (new) - added it

Kendrastarr I never thought about how they get out of tartarus if they're closing the doors. But maybe they convince Hades to do it or someone on that side. I don't know. But they all have to live!


message 48: by [deleted user] (new)

well, i think that Nico will be locked in the Underworld, coz he can shadow-travel out, right?


message 49: by [deleted user] (new)

(its kinda obvious...no offence 2 any1)


message 50: by Darius123 (new)

Darius123 So long as the sword of hades exists no one will be stuck in Tartarus.

What I am worried about is the fall. According to mythologteny it would
take ten days two fall from Hades to Tartarus. Tartarus has no air so according to the laws of gravity Percy and Annabeth
would hit at a speed of 847200m/s the impact from their fall would be like a nuclear bomb.

The six need to save them before the nine days.


« previous 1
back to top