Classic Trash discussion
Assorted Business
>
What Else Are You Reading
date
newest »

message 151:
by
Patrick
(last edited Oct 06, 2024 07:49PM)
(new)
Oct 06, 2024 04:21PM

reply
|
flag

But the book flies off the rails for a few reasons. The plot development depends on not one but two bits of miracle science (one biological, one chemical) which are both hard to believe in themselves, and the implications of the biological leap are not well handled at all.
McLaughlin also pushes way too hard on the ruthless unlikability of his protagonist – you keep expecting someone to at least TRY to kill him, and it would really be the only way to go: “If you strike at a king, you must kill him.” Although the denouement does not acknowledge this.
I am still confused about the snow buggy passages in Part Three (of five) and would like someone to please explain. Also why that one young woman never seemed to be wearing any clothes…
It really is overall kind of a mess.



One of the Humdrums is J.S. Fletcher (1863-1935), whom I have not read before, so last night I started The Charing Cross Mystery (1923), and I will report back. It gets off to a good start with an unexpected death on a train; trains are always aces in my book.

There are certainly traces of this approach in DCD’s first novel, Death in the Back Seat (1936), about a nice young couple who find themselves in way over their heads during a home caretaking gig in Connecticut. I thoroughly enjoyed this story and its small town atmosphere. The solution is VERY complicated, you won’t figure it out.
I obtained this book through one of those many “Megapack” / omnibus editions of genre fiction that are all over Amazon. I find that these often represent a very good value.


Patrick wrote: "Although I very much enjoy reading Golden Age mysteries, I am hopeless at spotting clues and honestly don’t even really care about solving the mystery, or about the rules of “fair play” (shocking, ..."
I also love mysteries of all kinds, but rarely try to solve the mystery! Of course I wanna know who dunnit, but I am happy enough to let the author figure it out for me.
I also love mysteries of all kinds, but rarely try to solve the mystery! Of course I wanna know who dunnit, but I am happy enough to let the author figure it out for me.
Patrick wrote: "Mystery novelist Dorothy Cameron Disney (1903-1992) is easily confused with her contemporaries Dorothy Salisbury Davis (1916-2014) (I’ve read her novel The Clay Hand) and Doris Miles Disney (1907-1..."
I like that so many female authors had their full names listed on their books. And yes, it is sunny how this little group all sounds the same.
I like that so many female authors had their full names listed on their books. And yes, it is sunny how this little group all sounds the same.

There are so many! I have barely scratched the surface myself.




Devon,
I have not read Borderline, but I have read a few books fro this author's Matthew Scudder detective series. I thought they were pretty good.
Books mentioned in this topic
Borderline (other topics)Borderline (other topics)
The Body in the Bed (other topics)
Where There's Smoke (other topics)
Who Told Clutha (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Lawrence Block (other topics)Lawrence Block (other topics)
Ocean Vuong (other topics)
Ocean Vuong (other topics)
Ocean Vuong (other topics)
More...