City of Ashes (The Mortal Instruments, #2) City of Ashes discussion


140 views
Jace and Clary- to be or not to be? (siblings or lovers ;) )

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rees (new) - added it

Rees theories, for COG ?


Isabel lovers, definately, they r made for each other!!!


message 3: by Sky (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sky Lovers! Let's make some love


Mugdha Definately Lovers... :)


Stormy Tenielle wrote: "Is NOBODY else creeped out by them making out while they thought they were siblings? It's way too.. weird for me.. Def think they are a cute couple and all, but it's still pretty gross that they we..."

Yeah, that is pretty gross but I think that they knew they weren't siblings someway somehow deep down because it like took them so long to believe it and then when they hear they really aren't they are just like "Okay."

What's really nasty is Clary kissing her real brother, Sebastian/Jonathan. Even though she didn't know it. At least nobody knows about it but her, right? Well, and all of us. :/


Hannah lovers forever and for always!!!!


Isabel they r perfect for each other dont u think?
Issi


Mugdha Isabel wrote: "they r perfect for each other dont u think?
Issi"

Totally... :)


Anna McGonnell they are perfect for each other but when they were still siblings (or they thought they were) it was creepy......
stupid Valentine!


Sarah Elder I just started the third book, and I want to say lovers all the way!!!!( I hope)


Sarah LOVERS 4EVS!!!!! (should be engraved on a tree or something....get through the evasiveness and wierdness about them being siblings- dont want to spoil anything 4 anyone-but yes, deffinately lovers!!!!!!


Serena lovers my sis tamara is a ruiner so i think they shud be luvers


Serena lots of us do but we still havnt found a way to jump in the book sooooooooo no jace for us :(


Sarah Abbie wrote: "NOT LOVERS!!! I WANT JACE FOR MYSELF!!!!!"

i think everyone does...lol(ESPECIALLY ME!!!!!)


message 15: by Nora (new) - added it

Nora to be for sure i dont carw if hes her brother


Victoria LOOOOOOVVVVVVVVVERRRRRRRRRRSSSSSSS


Stormy They technically are siblings but not in the natural sense of the way. They both have the same angel blood in their veins but that's unnatural so it really doesn't count because they are brother and sister through experiments but not through birth like Clary and Sebastian/Jonathan. Stupid meddling Valentine!


Tamara Stormy wrote: "They technically are siblings but not in the natural sense of the way. They both have the same angel blood in their veins but that's unnatural so it really doesn't count because they are brother an..."

lol yup valentine pretty much sucks!! he screwed up everyones life!


Nurlely Stormy wrote: "They technically are siblings but not in the natural sense of the way. They both have the same angel blood in their veins but that's unnatural so it really doesn't count because they are brother an..."

I think the Seelie Queen did it deliberately, the siblings case, due to the fairies evil nature. Had Clary asked the right question, the Queen would have told the truth. Fairies do not lie but they will not tell the truth either. But at that moment, both Clary and Jace were devastated with the answer to ask furthermore.
Them being siblings are similar to us being sibling, considering we are all Adam's descendants....


Lilian LOVERS F*** THAT!!!!!!=D


message 21: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Hannah wrote: "lovers forever and for always!!!!"

YES!!! =) I'm with you!


Chelsea LOVERS!!!


message 23: by Taylor (new) - added it

Taylor Nika wrote: "Hannah wrote: "lovers forever and for always!!!!"

YES!!! =) I'm with you!"


agreed


message 24: by Jenn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenn Tenielle wrote: "Is NOBODY else creeped out by them making out while they thought they were siblings? It's way too.. weird for me.. Def think they are a cute couple and all, but it's still pretty gross that they we..."
yeah so either way she would have made out with her brother which is creepy but we all knew, at least i did, that Cassandra Clare wasn't going to have them, Clary and Jace, be actual siblings it was with all that forshadowing if you looked in the right places by the way lovers


Nurlely I do not think there are authors who support incest. It will be gross and loathsome. Although it was predictable that Jace and Clary are not siblings, the storyline is so beautiful to make me read more about them.


Daisy sanchez lovers. brother and sister no way


Daniela-Goddess of Reading Tenielle wrote: "Is NOBODY else creeped out by them making out while they thought they were siblings? It's way too.. weird for me.. Def think they are a cute couple and all, but it's still pretty gross that they we..."

I find that distrubing as well....gross...When I read that...I thought how could they be siblings and still make out??? I mean hello people..this is a new generation :P


message 28: by [deleted user] (new)

Tenielle wrote: "Is NOBODY else creeped out by them making out while they thought they were siblings? It's way too.. weird for me.. Def think they are a cute couple and all, but it's still pretty gross that they we..."

I totally agree with you.


back to top