What did happen?

[Anna]

Today I added a book to my "medie-tie-in" shelf and noticed that 3 books from that shelf are gone: http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13...
http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13...
http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13...

I thought maybe I have deleted them from that shelf but no they are gone from my books.

I added them last year and I believe for one of them I wrote review.

Now I found these books in question and to my surprise they have been created/added recently this year. So it is not possible that I deleted them from my books (and forgot) or that some of my friends had fun with my account.

From John Barrowman and Gareth David-Lloyd profiles ( they read some of Torchwood books) are gone many books too.

I'm confused. What did happen?

[vicki_girl]

Those are all radio dramas. These are a bit of a gray area for Goodreads. Official policy is that these are allowed as books. However, some librarians don't know this and will delete them, thinking they are like movies and DVDs, which are not allowed. Tha's probably what happened in this case. Then later someone readded them.

I would add a librarian note to these type of items. You can state that they should not be deleted, and if someone has questions they can post here in the librarians group.

[Anna]

Thank you!