Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Harry Potter, #7) Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows discussion


273 views
Lets write Lily Evan's and Severus Snape's Love Story

Comments Showing 1-50 of 166 (166 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3 4

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

I've always loved the little love story between Severus and Lily but J.K Rowling didn't really like explain it completely why don't we put our own twist on it! Let's write our own fan fiction about Snape and lily!!! Each person please write only 7 sentences or less. I'll start!

"Lily what are you doing, how is that possible, its so pretty, please teach me how you did that" (Lily is beginning to learn about her powers and little daisies are popping out of her palms)
"Petunia I really don't know what's happening, why is this happening to me... How is this even physically possible" I said.
Out of nowhere a young boy about our age comes wearing unusual robes that I've never seen anyone wear before. They seemed a little big for him. Petunia seemed really scared and then she started running back home. I was all alone with him i was completely shocked and i didn't know what to say.


Hina Oh my god. Please tell me this is not happening. *headdesk*

Er, Anita, could you take this to a group or just somewhere else so people like me don't have to view this on a Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows discussion page.


message 3: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 03, 2012 02:50PM) (new)

Hina wrote: "Oh my god. Please tell me this is not happening. *headdesk*

Er, Anita, could you take this to a group or just somewhere else so people like me don't have to view this on a Harry Potter and the Dea..."

I'm sorry may i ask whats wrong with this page that you don't want to "view it". To be quite honest I just recently made a goodreads account and I don't really know how to use this website, i'm still trying to get used to it, i don't know why you are being so rude. I just wanted to people to contribute and write our own fan fiction about lily and severus, its a really fun activity! :)


Hina Anita wrote: "Hina wrote: "Oh my god. Please tell me this is not happening. *headdesk*

Er, Anita, could you take this to a group or just somewhere else so people like me don't have to view this on a Harry Potte..."


I see, well it was never my intention to appear as rude. Let's just say I'm not exactly a fan of this and would very much prefer it if it was moved elsewhere so discussions about the book can be separated from those which aren't.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Just stop being a twit! There are so many things that are not about the DH On this! She can do this if she wants. You are not the GR Owner so you can get over it!


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Mariah (Military Brat) wrote: "Just stop being a twit! There are so many things that are not about the DH On this! She can do this if she wants. You are not the GR Owner so you can get over it!"

Thank you that was very nice :). I don't why she was making such a big deal out of this but that was very kind of you for helping me :) thanks again!


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

"No problem. I really want to do this story though so yeah. I'll do anything to help.


message 8: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 03, 2012 10:49PM) (new)

If you guys are done arguing, do you think we could please continue the story?
*
He grabbed a leaf from the nearby oak and showed it to me. His palm closed and when he opened it again, it was an exquisite, leafy green butterfly. It fluttered its way through the thick collection of flowers around us. I grinned and he nodded.
"Shall I explain?" He asked.
"Please do." I grinned, as did he. The smile looked odd on his face, almost as if he hadn't smiled in years, having nothing to smile about. Sympathy swelled inside me but, judging by the steely, strong look in his eyes, he just wanted a friend; someone non-judgmental.
"You," he said pointing his hand at me "are a witch." A stunned silence followed.
"A witch? This stuff I can do... is... magic?" He nodded. He gestured in the relative direction that Petunia had disappeared to "she's just jealous, you're special and she only wishes she was."
"But this is the kind of thing you read about, it's just not real..." I trailed off and looked at the grass.
"It is, and there's a school specially built for people- witches and wizards- like you and me."
"How much do you know?"
"Not heaps, but enough so that it's not shocking when I get my letter." I stared, confused at him.
"Letter?"
"Yeah, from Hogwarts, the wizarding school. We go there to learn and control our magic," he said. "They send out a letter to every young witch and wizard around and we go and learn." I really couldn't believe it. Me, a witch? A sudden thought strikes me.
"Is Petunia playing a trick on me?" His expression of total disbelief assured me that she most certainly was not.
"No. How else do you think you can do all this?" I had no answer. Shrugging my shoulders and letting the fact that i was a witch settle in, i sat down and picked at the wild flowers about the ancient oak.


message 9: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 04, 2012 04:39PM) (new)

"I don't know it's just all so new, i'm still trying to sink in the idea of being a which, I mean is it even possible."
"I know this is all new for you but once you get your letter of acceptance to Hogwarts you know that what i'm telling you is the truth."
"Okay till then please tell me some more about the "Wizarding world" I said doubtfully, i didn't think he would have an answer."
We spent the whole afternoon talking about the wizarding world he told me everything he knew, it was so interesting i couldn't break away from him it was all so fascinating. after that day we became great friends everyday about that same time we met and talked about everything, i always invited Petunia to come but she called us freaks and ran away.


message 10: by [deleted user] (new)

Mariah (Military Brat) wrote: ""No problem. I really want to do this story though so yeah. I'll do anything to help."
Thank you, your so kind! :) Please join the story and add your own twist on it! ;)


Elizabeth Day One day when I was talking to the boy (who was called Severus) I told him about this.
"Petunia says we're freaks. And I haven't gotten my letter yet. What if we're both just crazy?" I said.
"Don't worry. It will come any day now. She just wishes she were like us," said Severus.
We sat in silence for a moment.
"Severus, Petunia is always trying to avoid me. It seems like she hates me. What do I do?" I said.
"She's just jelous, don't worry about her," he said. "She wants to be special too. But she's just a Muggle."
"What did you just call my sister?" I said, jumping up, angry now.


Rebecca I am certainly not trying to be rude, and you are absolutely able to do anything you want here, but I kind of understand what Hina is saying. I am reading through discussions about the Harry Potter books and I find someone wanting to do a group fanfic instead of talking about the books. There are lots of places for fanfics, I just figured this site was to discuss the actual literature, not write or re-write what we thought should have been included in the book but was left out on purpose by the author. That is what sites like Pottermore and other actual fanfic sites are for. Again, I hope you arent offended because that is not my goal, I am just stating an opinion. Carry on :-)


message 13: by [deleted user] (new)

Rebecca wrote: "I am certainly not trying to be rude, and you are absolutely able to do anything you want here, but I kind of understand what Hina is saying. I am reading through discussions about the Harry Potter..."

This is really about the book though! You see, in DH they talk about Lilly's and Severus' past! Sorry for the exclamation. I'm just trying to make a point


Rebecca Mariah (Military Brat) wrote: "Just stop being a twit! There are so many things that are not about the DH On this! She can do this if she wants. You are not the GR Owner so you can get over it!"

Just a thought, but this page is a discussion ABOUT the Deathly Hallows. So anything that is written here should pertain to the book. There are so many areas of the GR site, including a 'group' option that allows people interested in doing things like this or starting book clubs or stipulating the parameters of their discussions to do their own thing. This particular section is for discussions about the books, what was liked/disliked, character comparison, etc. I agree with Hina that this may not be the best or most appropriate place for a developing fanfic. Some people hate fanfics, preferring to keep the integrity of the original story intact, and don't want to get conflicting information about what actually happened in the book and what people think should have happened so they write about it as though that is what actually happened. It is effing confusing. Also name calling and being rude to someone- not the most effective way to display any level of maturity.


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

I know. I'm sorry. It's just I have issues with people bagging on others fr somethig fun they want to do.


Rebecca Absolutely! Some people really love fanfic and they should be able to do it if they want to, and there certainly aren't any rules against doing it on the discussion page.


message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

Elizabeth wrote: "One day when I was talking to the boy (who was called Severus) I told him about this.
"Petunia says we're freaks. And I haven't gotten my letter yet. What if we're both just crazy?" I said.
"..."


I've never heard that word but it sounded rude and i just wanted to leave. Severus looked confused, he ran after me and explained that a muggle is a non magical and lacks magical ability. After i understood we continued talking the next day i received my letter, I ran to the pond waiting for Severus.


message 18: by [deleted user] (new)

Rebecca wrote: "Mariah (Military Brat) wrote: "Just stop being a twit! There are so many things that are not about the DH On this! She can do this if she wants. You are not the GR Owner so you can get over it!"

J..."


I'm really sorry i don't mean to be rude or anything but i have seen many pages like mine that people write fan fictions on different things such as Harry and Ginny's wedding i don't understand why some people just want mine to be deleted or put somewhere else they don't write anything anyone else's fan fiction discussion page . as i mentioned before i'm not really familiar with this website and this was just a spur of a moment thing and i thought it would be a fun activity. If you and Hina or anyone else doesn't wish to write this fan fiction it's fine just don't click on it. Please if anyone wants write anything go ahead, its just a little irritating that we are arguing on this page if you don't like it please don't click on this page.I'm sorry if i sound rude, because that is not my intention. I''m sorry.


Allie Hello there Anita!
I am new here too, I've only been using this website for a month or so. I've recently discovered a love for Severus and Lily fics too, especially the interesting ones. I found a few I could link you, if you haven't already found any others.
Oh, and don't let others hate. I understand that people want to come here strictly to discuss the book, but there is no need to hate.
=)


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

Allie wrote: "Hello there Anita!
I am new here too, I've only been using this website for a month or so. I've recently discovered a love for Severus and Lily fics too, especially the interesting ones. I foun..."


Thank you that would really be nice! I haven't come across any of lily and Severus fan fiction. i just wanted to like create a page where everyone would write there own twist and write on Severus and Lily. I've seen many pages like the one i made where people just write a story and stuff i just wanted to write lily severus's story. It would be really kind of you if you sent me the links i have no idea where they are thank you so much! :).


Allie Anita wrote: "Allie wrote: "Hello there Anita!
I am new here too, I've only been using this website for a month or so. I've recently discovered a love for Severus and Lily fics too, especially the interesting..."


This one is called Ananke, and so far it is my favorite. There is theme in the fandom of Sev getting a second chance and being able to go back, but this one is very different =)

http://m.fanfiction.net/s/4400517/1/
If the link doesn't work I could get it to you another way. I also like this one, its called The Road Not Taken

http://m.fanfiction.net/s/3939197/1/
Have fun!


message 22: by [deleted user] (new)

Rebecca wrote: "Wow. First of all, I'm not your 'darling'. You want to talk patronizing? There you go. I have as much right to my own opinion as you do, and guess what I can post it anywhere I want. I wasn't offen..."

Hi Rebecca, My name is Anita and I am the one who started this discussion about Lily and Severus's story. I just wanted to say that I made this little thing just for fun.... I understand you and Hina
don't like this sort of thing, but you don't need to click on it, you can ignore it, its just a page like any other page. As i mentioned before i have seen so many pages like mine but you guys like ignored it and you didn't write anything please do the same with this one. I know you have the right to do whatever you want and express your opinions its just a random thing i thought of and i thought it would be like fun, if you don't like it you don't have to click on it. I'm sorry if you think i'm being rude but that is not my intention. I bet about 90 percent of the people on goodreads also write their own stories, including me but i just wanted write one fan fiction about my favorite characters and asked anyone who likes them to also write their own twist.


message 23: by [deleted user] (new)

Starhyphen wrote: "Rebecca wrote: "Mariah (Military Brat) wrote: "Just stop being a twit! There are so many things that are not about the DH On this! She can do this if she wants. You are not the GR Owner so you can ..."
Thank you Starthypenyour so nice!!! :) I would love to continue writing, this fan fiction and thank you for participating and helping me out and writing your own twist.
P.S your writing is amazing!!! thanks again!


message 24: by [deleted user] (new)

Allie wrote: "Anita wrote: "Allie wrote: "Hello there Anita!
I am new here too, I've only been using this website for a month or so. I've recently discovered a love for Severus and Lily fics too, especially t..."

thank you I can't wait to read them!!! :)


message 25: by Gabby (new) - rated it 1 star

Gabby Have any of you written any books? Or are currently writing one?
Because you should. I don't like much Fan-fiction, but this one is just adorable!


message 26: by [deleted user] (new)

Gabby wrote: "Have any of you written any books? Or are currently writing one?
Because you should. I don't like much Fan-fiction, but this one is just adorable!"

I do write my own books but at times i just stop, and then i think of a new one so i have like a whole bunch of unfinished stories on my laptop hahaha. but i love Lily and Severus, please join in and go ahead and write your own twist on what we have so far just ignore the haters and write what you want to come next and we will continue from their and take turns... if you want


message 27: by Gabby (new) - rated it 1 star

Gabby Anita wrote: "Gabby wrote: "Have any of you written any books? Or are currently writing one?
Because you should. I don't like much Fan-fiction, but this one is just adorable!"
I do write my own books but at tim..."


Okay, thank you! And you should finish your books! I know what you mean when you say 'you don't finish them' because i do the same, but for the last couple of years, (Yeah. I said years. i didn't feel comfortable with my writing and stopped for abotu a year. but once i saw a lot of others' writing i decided to continue!) i have stuck to one book, and always have some pen and paper i can use if i have ideas for other stories!

-So, what i'm saying, is that you have an excellent talent and you should finish those stories! I'd read them :)


message 28: by [deleted user] (new)

Anita wrote: "Gabby wrote: "Have any of you written any books? Or are currently writing one?
Because you should. I don't like much Fan-fiction, but this one is just adorable!"
I do write my own books but at tim..."


Haha, I have the same problem with not finishing stories! There's tonnes blocking up my hard drive!


message 29: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 07, 2012 09:55PM) (new)

Oh yeah and I think I need to make something right.
Rebecca?
I'm sorry about what I said, I didn't actually mean it as a personal attack. I guess when on a computer, things are a lot easier to say! Anyway I hope you can accept my apology!
:)
P.S. I call everyone darling, not in a patronizing way. Didn't realize it could be interpreted like you say.


message 30: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 07, 2012 10:20PM) (new)

Starhyphen wrote: "Anita wrote: "Gabby wrote: "Have any of you written any books? Or are currently writing one?
Because you should. I don't like much Fan-fiction, but this one is just adorable!"
I do write my own bo..."

hahaha most of my computer is filled with unfinished stories on my desktop too!


Rebecca I understand that and appreciate your apology, I probably jumped on you more aggressively than I meant to. I'm sorry for that. I get a little jumped up sometimes when I get talking about some of my favorite books and have noticed that an earnest conversation can quickly turn nasty if not careful.


Rebecca Wow, just re-read my comments, I got a lot jumped up. Sorry everyone, I didn't mean to be disrespectful about fanfics in general and I hope that I didn't offend anyone too badly. Writing is writing is writing, no matter what form. Just because I don't enjoy reading a type of writing does not mean that it isn't a valid form of creativity.


message 33: by [deleted user] (new)

Totally! Even?


Rebecca :-) You got it :-)


message 35: by [deleted user] (new)

I'm glad:)
This is probably a stupid question, but are you gonna add something to the story? xD


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

*
"Sev!" I called to the boy in the black robes. He turned, flourishing a parchment enevelope identical to mine, as I raced to him.
"Yours arrived too!" I gasped excitedly as i came to a stop. I was almost shaking with excitement.
"My parents don't even know!" He smiled that odd, unusual smile and rolled his eyes.
"Well, are you going to open it?"
"Together?"
"Together." We poised our hands at the opening to the enevelopes. Slowly, carefully, I picked at the coat of arms stamp sealing it, as did Severus. At the same time, we both peeled the tops back and pulled out the thick parchment contents. We plopped onto the ground and explored our acceptance letters and lists.
"An owl, a cat or a toad?" I asked Severus. "What would I need them for?"
"Well, the owls are for posting letters... and i honestly don't know what the toad's for, the cat... i guess, a familiar face?" I imagined trying to get our disdainful cat, Rouge, into a carry cage and bringing him to a school of 'witchcraft and wizardry'. I'd pay for that big time, and Petunia would've killed me.
"An owl sounds cool," I said. But Severus wasn't looking at his letter, rather looking, pale-faced and worried, at a dark shape that was approaching us.


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

It was a face I recognized but not in that form, he looked quite similar to Severus I think it was his dad. Severus was petrified and frozen but I didn't understand why.
I stood up and smiled and introduced myself
"Hello my name is Lily Even's, it's a pleasure to meet you, you must be Severus's dad"
His face was like stone had no emotion except in his eyes, you can tell he was furious but of what i had no idea.
A second later his voice was yelling
"SEVERUS SNAPE IS THIS WHERE YOU SPEND ALL YOUR TIME TALKING TO A DIRTY MUGGLE, I THOUGHT I RAISED YOU WELL."
I froze i was unable to speak, i was shocked
when Severus was trying to reply his dad yelled "WE ARE GOING HOME RIGHT NOW AND YOU ARE NEVER TO SPEAK TO HER AGAIN"


message 38: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 08, 2012 08:50PM) (new)

I stepped back from the raging man and all I could see was red. Severus was cowering as his father attempted to drag him away, growling and threatening. Tears built up in my eyes and my cheeks grew hot.
"STOP!"
Mr Snape froze and glared at me. Staring daggers, he came right up close, I could smell the dense scent of liquor on his putrid breath.
"Don't you tell me what to do you-" some kind of force pushed him back and he collapsed in a scowling heap. It was a moment before I realized the odd feeling of energy surging within me. Stronger than the daisies. The unbalanced man pulled out a carved wooden stick from his back pocket. It was a wand, dark and chipped.
"You hideous Mudblood!" he yelled before aiming the wand at me, some incantation playing on his lips.
"Father, no!" Severus ran at the man, bowling him over.
"Run, Lily! Go!" He screamed at me. Without a second thought, I did. I ran. I ran all the way down the road, past the shops and gardens before I stopped outside my house and raced in.
"Lily!" My mother gasped as i flew into the living room. She was making something for Petunia, who was having fabric pinned to her. I held up the thick enevelope, not wanting to talk about Severus, whom my mother is unaware exists, let alone his father's assault. My mother dropped the box of pins she was holding and grabbed the letter, her expression unreadable. Petunia stood scowling at me atop her stool.
"Mother?" I asked. But she was beyond listening, ogling at the letter in wonder. She suddenly raced upstairs. Petunia and I could hear the cupboard open and close, then there was a shuffling of papers.
"You're a freak," Petunia whispered suddenly. I was in a moment of shocked silence. Mother padded back down the staircase right then with an identical enevelope. Though it looked older and the writing was black rather than emerald, in a different hand.
She was positively beaming.
"Lily, your great-grandmother..."


message 39: by Gabby (new) - rated it 1 star

Gabby (Just pointing out, Lily is human/witch and she'd have some magical blood in her if her great-grandmother was a witch, too. Wouldn't she?)

Her eyes were full of tears, she was beaming. "Oh! I'm so proud of you!" She came up and hugged me. I ignored Petunia who was still scowling in the corner.


message 41: by Gabby (new) - rated it 1 star

Gabby (I guess so, go for it :)


Isabella (All Da Ladies Luv Leo) Thomas Then I packed my things in a suitcase and went into Diagon Ally.
At the wand shop I saw Severus.
"Hey you're okay! I was so worried about you and-"
I stopped when i saw his face. It was very bruised and scratched.
"Oh my goodnes! What happened?!"


Isabella (All Da Ladies Luv Leo) Thomas Then I packed my things in a suitcase and went into Diagon Ally.
At the wand shop I saw Severus.
"Hey you're okay! I was so worried about you and-"
I stopped when i saw his face. It was very bruised and scratched.
"Oh my goodnes! What happened?!"


message 44: by [deleted user] (new)

Gabby wrote: "(Just pointing out, Lily is human/witch and she'd have some magical blood in her if her great-grandmother was a witch, too. Wouldn't she?)

Her eyes were full of tears, she was beaming. "Oh! I'm so..."


(Just changing the story a little:) Don't use that part if you don't want xD)


message 45: by Gabby (new) - rated it 1 star

Gabby Starhyphen wrote: "Gabby wrote: "(Just pointing out, Lily is human/witch and she'd have some magical blood in her if her great-grandmother was a witch, too. Wouldn't she?)

Her eyes were full of tears, she was beamin..."


Nah, that's okay. We'll keep it.


message 46: by Gabby (new) - rated it 1 star

Gabby Severus managed a weak smile, "I'm okay."
I was furious, "No! Your not okay! Your dad did this to you?" He looked down at his feet. I couldn't believe a father would act this way to his son.


Isabella (All Da Ladies Luv Leo) Thomas "Yes" he said sheepishly. "But I'm healing, I used a spell"
I was definitly furious so i walked out the door with Severus and demanded an explication


Isabella (All Da Ladies Luv Leo) Thomas "Yes" he said sheepishly. "But I'm healing, I used a spell"
I was definitly furious so i walked out the door with Severus and demanded an explication


message 49: by [deleted user] (new)

"Okay okay Lily just give me a second I can't stand to see you mad at me for this reason it doesn't matter"
"Severus please tell me what happened. Did your dad do this?"
"yes he said with a shrug, its okay theres nothing wrong i'll be fine"
"are you kidding have you seen your face severus, you should tell the police or something"
"The police those muggle investigators and tell them what"
"I don't know but you can't just let him beat you"
"Lily he's my father what do you expect me to do"
"Why did he beat you?"
"um...."
"Severus was it because of me, but why would he beat you because of me what did i do?"


message 50: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 13, 2012 01:23PM) (new)

A torn look shadowed his bruised face. He took a deep breath.
"Yes," he said, hiding his eyes. "It was because of you." My shoulders slumped and I brushed my red hair from my eyes.
"Does that mean..." I started, he looked up. "Does that mean we can't be friends?" I finished in a shaky voice. His expression abruptly changed from fearful sadness to raw determination.
"No," he said with such assertiveness that a lion wouldn't have dared disagree. "I can choose my friends..." the last part was a muttered afterthought, almost internal conflict. He shook his head and changed the subject.
"Have you got your books?"
"Yeah, all but the... er, Dark Defence?" I say uncertainly. He smiles that small, rare smile.
"Defence against the Dark Arts." His eyes lit up at the very mention of the subject. What are the Dark Arts? I asked myself.
We headed to a store entitled 'Flourish and Blotts'. It was an odd name but it had so many books on so many subjects that I'd never even heard of that I forgot about the name in a matter of seconds. I picked up a book about something called Transfiguration, called 'From Pencil to Python' by Julio Laquedar. An old man with a large, toothy grin beamed from the cover. I was startled to find that the man often waved and changed expressions. At one point he actually LEFT the cover!
"Have you seen this-?" I looked around for Severus but he was gone.
"Sev?"
"Over here!" I heard from the back of the shop. I started down the long wooden isles toward the back of the shop. The rows got steadily darker and more ominous as I neared Severus. The skeeves crawled up my spine, an unwanted, tingly presence. There were mumbling rasps coming from no visible mouths, I had only to assume it was the books themselves that were talking. I shivered but was reassured when I caught up to Severus. He was steadily uttering soothing words to a very red, very irate looking book. It growled and snarled but he soothed it eventually.
"How did you know to do that?" I asked in amazement.
"Well... most unhappy things just need some kind of... happiness..." He said somberly. His statement suggested something beyond merely words. He brightened and said;
"It was also on the back cover." I laughed but couldn't shake off the feeling that there was some unspoken meaning behind his words.
We purchased our books and went to a place called 'Florean Fortescue's Ice-Cream Parlour' and licked away at exotically topped, bulging ice-creams.


« previous 1 3 4
back to top