Nikki answers “I am very upset that this book is on a...”

Sandra Catchings asked this question about Night:

I am very upset that this book is on a list as appropriate for 14 year old 8th graders. Because it is , my son is being forced to read it by his school. My family is deeply effected by this book. My son is in emotional upheaval and very depressed. This book should not be listed as appropriate for this age group. It should be read at the high school level and up- and be lsited as so. How could a book like this end up ?

Nikki I agree. It is very emotional and difficult to think about. I wonder if there are other books that also allow students to tackle the horrors of this t…moreI agree. It is very emotional and difficult to think about. I wonder if there are other books that also allow students to tackle the horrors of this time in history but that also offer a redemptive hope, say The Hiding Place by Corie TenBoom. As an adult, I can understand Elie's rejection of God, his placing direct blame on God. For teens it may instead chip away at their faith and hope and understanding of one of life's most deepest questions: how can a good God allow such evil. Not sure my child's 8th grade teacher will be dissecting that one at school...but I know I sure will with my own kids at home. (also have an 8th grader reading this)(less)

flag

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more