Babette
Babette asked:

I am deeply affected/changed by this book. What a writer, at the peak of his powers it seems. One question: what is the reasoning for beating children as it relates to black children at risk for violence in the wider world?

To answer questions about Between the World and Me, please sign up.
Colleen It's an old notion that it will teach them to act in line, respecting authority and instilling a level of fear, which is supposed to keep them safe.
Pramila It shows helplessness arising from the intense desire to protect in a situation where no protection is available outside of the family.
Karen Andrews Another aspect of this is that parents believed that their children would likely encounter beatings as they grew up, so getting beaten by a parent first would harden them, teach them that they could survive a beating. It was a method for desensitizing a child to what may come later. It also was meant to instill a fear of wandering away from a parent, which could leave them vulnerable to an attack or kidnapping by a stranger.
Karen M. Coates mentions this in the book. If I recall correctly, he relates it to the fear of losing children to street violence, and a sense of wanting to control what little they can in raising their children. There is a passage in the book where he describes a parent as saying they would rather beat their child themselves than let their child be hurt by a passing car. Read the book for more detail.
Image for Between the World and Me
Rate this book
Clear rating

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more