Steve Joyce
asked:
OK. I really enjoyed RFA but thoroughly disliked VALIS...I read it long ago and hated it so much so that I have vowed never to read it again. (I believe that VALIS is the only PKD novel for which I have ever had a negative reaction.) Anyway, my question is this: - are the two that dissimilar? If so, how so? ...or ... - have my tastes changed that much (obviously, feel free to speculate here)?
To answer questions about
Radio Free Albemuth,
please sign up.
Love of Hopeless Causes
If memory serves, they are all related to Phil's magic moment when he sees the fish pendant. "Valis" is the best synthesis. "Albemuth" is the closest to Phil's real life experience. "The Divine Invasion," is the easiest to read, and "Exegesis" is too far out for most.
The tone, plot, and POV are different. Yet they all attempt to make sense of the same week in Phil's existence. Valis is louder and trippier than Albemuth. Albemuth has the more adult (and Christian) perspective.
"The Shifting Realities of PKD," explains the forgetful god and the artifact and that makes the whole show run. This is also explained in "Exegesis" as well as the BIP theory or Black Iron Prison Planets. So if you liked "Albemuth" try "Divine Invasion." What a weird answer to type, but I believe this is all accurate.
The tone, plot, and POV are different. Yet they all attempt to make sense of the same week in Phil's existence. Valis is louder and trippier than Albemuth. Albemuth has the more adult (and Christian) perspective.
"The Shifting Realities of PKD," explains the forgetful god and the artifact and that makes the whole show run. This is also explained in "Exegesis" as well as the BIP theory or Black Iron Prison Planets. So if you liked "Albemuth" try "Divine Invasion." What a weird answer to type, but I believe this is all accurate.
J Benedetti
RFA = medium God, medium social & political commentary.
VALIS = all God, all the time, how do you like your God sir? with more God? have some more God sir.
VALIS = all God, all the time, how do you like your God sir? with more God? have some more God sir.
Jamie Flower
Radio Free Albemuth is more of a straight forward sci-fi dsytopian and lacks the schizophrenic narrator of Valis and all the weird meta stuff and cryptic ramblings with phrases phrases like "The Empire never ended" that Valis had.
Steve Joyce
I should add that I remember very little about VALIS...other than how I felt about it.
Jerry Brabenec
To me "Valis" is personal, positive and affirming, "Radio Free Albemuth" is about dystopian politics, and "Divine Invasion" is about theology and epistomology. RFA is most relevant to the current situation of the Trump administration.
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.
See Featured Authors Answering Questions
Learn more