Catnip :3
Catnip :3 asked:

WORST book of the trilogy! I like Jake, he is fun, but a Twilight saga book without Edward is NOT a twilight saga book! I so missed Edward and was SO SO SO sad about Bella and kind of Mad at Edward for his stupidity he wasn't good for Bells! Agree?

To answer questions about New Moon, please sign up.
Ella I kind of agree. Even though Edward left Bella so that he wouldn't be putting her in "danger" and because he wanted her to live a "normal" life, he should have known that it was just going to make her depressed. Also, you can't just tell someone your a vampire and that you love someone and then just leave them. But yet again, if Edward never left, then we would have never seen Jacob as a big character and he probably wouldn't have been as present in the other books. We also got to see Bella fall in love with Jacob (kind of in a friend way, kind of more) and we learned that he was a shape-shifting wolf.
Ella
This answer contains spoilers… (view spoiler)
Julia Marks Edward didn't want to go. He left for Bella's safety.
Fairy Trilogy? Its a saga
Kaitlynn Mino Actually I thought that it was a good book I mean if new moon didn't really have that kind of theme then Bella woundn't know about Jacob being a shapeshifter.
Harley It had its up and downs
madelaine underhill I agree and I feel the same way
Image for New Moon
Rate this book
Clear rating

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more