Jillian
asked
Elizabeth Wein:
This question contains spoilers…
(view spoiler)[Maddie says to Rose, "Julie would have died there. I read what you wrote. She'd never have made it. She'd have died there." Having Maddie say that makes the reader feel like Rose is a replacement for Julie, which she really isn't. Maddie's friendships with Julie and Rose are separate entities. What was your thought process behind Maddie's friendships with Julie and Rose and the meaning of that line? (hide spoiler)]
Elizabeth Wein
This answer contains spoilers…
(view spoiler)[hmm, I personally don't feel Maddie could ever find a replacement for Julie, so this is probably open to individual interpretation. As you rightly point out, Maddie's friendships with Julie and Rose are very different. I don't feel that Maddie ever thinks of Rose as a potential replacement for Julie - Maddie is a person who makes friends easily, and she and Rose get along well (she's also quite a bit older than Rose, and probably feels like she's mentoring her).
With that line in particular, though, I felt that Maddie had to acknowledge the parallels between Julie and Rose. They both experienced and suffered under the Nazi regime in a much more intimate way than probably anybody else Maddie knows. Maddie also knows that Julie narrowly missed being subjected to suffering similar to and probably worse than Rose's, and now - on the day the war ends - when Maddie has just read Rose's journal and has a more detailed knowledge of what would have happened to Julie - I think it's inevitable Julie would be on Maddie's mind. I felt that as the author of CNV, it was impossible not to show that Maddie was thinking of Julie. But I didn't mean to imply that Rose is a replacement for Julie.
(Because - you are so right - she isn't.) (hide spoiler)]
With that line in particular, though, I felt that Maddie had to acknowledge the parallels between Julie and Rose. They both experienced and suffered under the Nazi regime in a much more intimate way than probably anybody else Maddie knows. Maddie also knows that Julie narrowly missed being subjected to suffering similar to and probably worse than Rose's, and now - on the day the war ends - when Maddie has just read Rose's journal and has a more detailed knowledge of what would have happened to Julie - I think it's inevitable Julie would be on Maddie's mind. I felt that as the author of CNV, it was impossible not to show that Maddie was thinking of Julie. But I didn't mean to imply that Rose is a replacement for Julie.
(Because - you are so right - she isn't.) (hide spoiler)]
More Answered Questions
Isabelle Kaplan
asked
Elizabeth Wein:
How old do you think children would be abe to tackle this story?
Erica M.
asked
Elizabeth Wein:
This question contains spoilers…
(view spoiler)[
I don't have a question, I just want to say that I always remember Verity's birthday, and today (12. Aug. 22) would have been her 100th! And thank you for writing all the bonus content in the 10th-anniversary edition of CNV, I loved it. (?)
(hide spoiler)]
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.
See Featured Authors Answering Questions
Learn more