Jennifer McWilliams I agree with the other answers, it is nothing at all like If I Stay. I don't agree with the others in saying it isn't as good as If I Stay. I am closing in on the end of the book and I am really having trouble putting it down. Maybe it is just that this is a much longer book than If I stay. I am very much enjoying reading about Allyson's adventures.
Alexes Lindquist No, this book is nothing like If I Stay because well If I Stay was more of a great book you cant put down. But this book is more of the I can put it down and not pick it back up again for a while. Its not really a page turner like If I Stay was.
Laurie Morfe Ditto Ashley. I liked If I Stay but this book isn't pulling me in. I'm 30% through it and I'm finding it to be completely cheesy and boring. I rarely stop reading books and feel like once I start it, I NEED to finish it but this might be a book I put down and not pick up again.
Ashley In my opinion, it is nothing like If I Stay. The book was "okay", but I think If I Stay was way better! Just One Day and Just One Year was a little boring at times. It never really tells you what happens between them in the end of the books.