To answer questions about
The Midnight Library,
please sign up.
Blue Wren
This is not suitable for teens because they deserve better literature than this predictable guff.
May Flora
I'm a 17 yr old and I absolutely loved this book. I think it is such a good book to read in your late teens as it solidifies this idea of not worrying too much about trying to make the perfect choices. I'm at the age where I'm starting to make lots of big decisions about my life, so it was really nice to have this idea that there are so many things that I could end up doing with my life, but there is no possibility that is inherently better than another. I would say that it's probably a good book for people aged 16+, but it also completely depends on the person. If they are younger they may not fully understand everything that the book is saying, but in that sense it may be nice for them if they read it again a couple years later and suddenly pick up on little things that they missed the first time around. :)
Charlene Hardin
I think it depends on the teen, but generally, I would say it is. Teens may, or may not, fully grasp the weight of regrets felt around the mid-way point in life. Even so, the book offers decent insight into how we become the choices we make and the stories we tell ourselves. I may pass this along to my daughter when I'm done with it.
Karen Wallace
My very mature 13yr-old granddaughter is currently reading it and is enjoying it very much. Her English teacher has also read it and is looking forward to discussing it with her, as am I.
It's a fabulous book.
It's a fabulous book.
Greg
This could be classified as a YA novel, really. Oh, the angst of being 16 and not knowing where to go to college, who to date, solidify sexual preference(s) before you've lived a fake life, which people are real friends, confusing messages from parents, reconciling religious beliefs, finding the right mentors, etc.
Marianna Zelichenko
I would say a teen might actually relate to it more and enjoy it more, especially if it's an angsty teen :)
Maine Mom
Fascinating comments...such a range of views. I had thought it was much more of a YA novel than adult...almost reminded me of Madeline L'Engle... And (unlike Meg Murray) Nora seemed more of a contrivance to hang the various lives on than a fully-developed person.
Suzanne
Aimed at adults, but I think really good for a teen to read. The book is about choices we make and the impact we have on another. I would have liked to read this when I was a teen (I'm close in age to the protagonist now).
Bethann
This book feels very much like YA fiction. I feel it was mismarketed at adults.
Susan
Suicide is central to the story. As a parent, you might read the book first. Then decide if you your teen is ready to tackle the topics of severe depression and suicide. If you decide to move forward, perhaps read it together, and discuss it chapter by chapter. These are very sensitive topics, consider providing helpful resources about depression and suicide in addition to reading the book. This book has many emotional triggers.
Cocoa Boo
The book is more geared toward an adult audience. However, if the teen is mature and/or needs some comfort in dealing w/anxiety and depression, and that there is hope, then it's appropriate.
Tipsy Says
More of a teen book than adult. I think I would have enjoyed it as a 14/15 year old; as an adult it was obvious and full of clichés.
Anastasiia G Kovalenko, PhD
I would not recommend it to teens. It's more appropriate for adults. I personally find this book triggering and potentially harmful (but hey, I'm just a cautious psychologist!)
Minnesinger
This answer contains spoilers…
(view spoiler)
JenBsBooks
I know profanity is pretty common with teens ... but I also know it's something some parents would like to know about, if it's in a book or not. The F-word is very prevalent, in fact, at one point it's said about twenty times in a row ( pretty funny actually) but, just a heads up. I know, kids probably hear that every day at school ...
Trudy Somers
Aimed at adults, I don't think high school students would understand some of depth of regrets just as many of us might not have comprehended them until we look back when we are in our thirties. I loved this book, but feel it really focused on above 20.
Kiki Overreactress
Book is based on midlife happenings and full of thoughtfulness, which teens may not grasp up to optimum level. But this book heals everyone and tells that the grass is greener on the other side of the fence.
Nikita
suitable for any age above 12
Mirthe
I am a 15 year old girl and I have just read this book, I absolutely love it. I agree with the comments that it isn't for every teen and some people who struggle with things that the author wrote will like it more than others. We had to chose between a few books in class and I chose this one, along with 2 of my classmates who are also 15 so I think it is suitable for teens but it depends on the boy or girl itself. I personally really recommend this one. My mother language isn't English, so I'm sorry for mistakes in my writing.
Noor Chahal
📝I have to say as a 18 year old
This book sure set me off with the right attitude towards life. REALLY!
I have power in just being alive, so do YOU!
...so the only regret one can really have is giving that up when all SEEMS hopeless. Theres always a ray of hope...a chance, all depends on you!
-I AM ALIVE🧡
This book sure set me off with the right attitude towards life. REALLY!
I have power in just being alive, so do YOU!
...so the only regret one can really have is giving that up when all SEEMS hopeless. Theres always a ray of hope...a chance, all depends on you!
-I AM ALIVE🧡
Tracy Shea
I would be loathe to allow my teens to read this book. Without a trigger warning of suicide, I was completely gobs-macked by the theme. This is a very well-written fantasy about all of the do-overs you will have presented to you, when you swallow a fistful of pills. It scoffs at the finality and gravity of suicide.
Jeannette J.
Yes it is a suitable teen read.
Cory
Instead of jumping on the bandwagon of negative opinions, I'll just say: Yes. It is suitable for a teen. There are adult themes and language, but nothing graphic or gratuitous in the story. It is a broadly inspirational piece of general interest fiction that kept my interest to the end. It's a bestseller because its appeal is broad, not because it's a life altering work of literary mastery.
Sheridan
I personally think this book would have been amazing for me as a teenager - especially when grappling what to do with your life!
Helen Pakpahan
I think its more for teens than adults...its too simplistic for adults... and the message of choose live/choose potential is a good message for any other thinking/depressed teenager
Tami
My answer is No - the premise of the book is wonderful and the book does have many positive attributes and is a thoughtful read for adults BUT I don't think it is suitable for young adults. Travelling through attempted suicide to gain enlightenment. Let young adults take a different route.
Tobias
I really feel this is aimed at adults with life experience and may have had to confront some of the issues written about here.
Elliot Benson
Be careful - major trigger warning for suicide. Kind of like a self-help fiction novel, but geared towards people who have already recovered.
Amelia.Caldwell
I'm 17 years old and I personally think this is suitable for anyone 16 and up it does talk about suicide but parents seem to act like we haven't already heard of the name we know it's a trigger warning and responsible teens should know what good and bad for them like anyone of us does a parent shouldn't say no let the teen found it out if they like it we have already started, making our decisions so guide us but don't force us.
Evie
Absolutely not! The themes of suicide and depression are not handled well in this book.
Denise Hale
It is not unsuitable for teens if they want to read it. The central character is in mid-thirties so I don't think the author aimed it as a YA novel, it starts with a suicide but unfortunately, nowadays many teens will of someone their age who has committed (or tried to) suicide before they reach their twenties.
Meghan
I see it being a high school summer read for years. Especially since I think Oprah liked it. Anything Oprah seems to become a HS summer read.
Deb
Definitely YA. Not for mature adults.
Petrovska Svetlana
Let’s just the adults enjoy questioning about choices and regrets.. teens deserve more other fantasy adventures.
Zohra
It's for both, because it's never too late to learn to pursue your passions, avoid regrets, and enjoy life!
marissa di vita
definitely great for teens. i’m 17 and i absolutely love it
John
Yes, suitable for teens. Nothing graphic. Yes, suicide is the main theme, but take a look at the large amount of YA fiction out there that also centers on this issue.
kimber
im a 14 yr old, read this book at 13, and absoulutely loved it. i think its a great book for any teen/adult, but i'd say its best for ages 15+ only because of the heavier topics! hope you like the book tho!
Gloria Marin
Yes, I absolutely would recommend for young adults, teens 16+ definitely. I loved it. This isn't my usual genre I was reading for a book club. But I loved it and I am getting ready to start another book from this author.
I'm so surprised at some of these comments so focused on the suicide aspect of the book when in the long run the book was more about the opposite. it was about life and living. I think our teens are exposed to far worst on a daily in and out of school. This book is far less offensive than some of the drivel ridden books that schools have on their reading lists. being overly triggered is a big problem these days.
I'm so surprised at some of these comments so focused on the suicide aspect of the book when in the long run the book was more about the opposite. it was about life and living. I think our teens are exposed to far worst on a daily in and out of school. This book is far less offensive than some of the drivel ridden books that schools have on their reading lists. being overly triggered is a big problem these days.
Roberto Palacios
It feels like a teen book, but I could take some excellent lessons as an adult. One of these, your future starts every day that you live and you could change if you want.
Maria
As a 17 year old I enjoyed it.
Petret99
A confused teen may relate to this book but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
Alicia Jacobson
Interesting validations here. I am sending this to my 16 niece, as she needs to understand the power of choices. No sexual content (except inferences.) No language issues. Perfect for YA.
Mena
no even as a teen it handles mental health in such a simplified way it's...offensive :|
Louis Dore-Savard
My 14-yr-old daughter loved it.
hacksdancin
Yeah... I'd think a YA would get something from this book. It's not a great literary treasure, but it'd be a good one for someone who's wondering about the trajectory of their life.
Pooja Dave
I think I would have benefitted from this being classified as a YA novel
David Allott
This book is the equivalent of email spam - taking advantage of a global event, a click-bait theme, and mass distribution in the hope it resonates with someone enough that they 'click on the link'. By then it's too late and you wish more than anything you hadn't clicked. Teens would get better advice inside a fortune cookie.
Poppy
Bad book and whoever this teen is, they deserve better than this overhyped junk
larnie
I'm a teen and reading it so it's up to them or their parent really.
Jill
This seemed like a young adult book when I started reading it, and I agree with Blue Wren--if you're going to read, choose better literature.
Kaitlyn McCort
Yes, it is suitable for teens but I would not personally classify this as directed toward teens. Teens deal with the issues of depression and suicide sometimes more frequently than older people, but I wouldn't keep this book from anyone. It really open the mind toward mental health and how it operates.
Nodi Sarker
This answer contains spoilers…
(view spoiler)
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.
See Featured Authors Answering Questions
Learn more