Supriya Joshi
asked
Madeline Miller:
This question contains spoilers…
(view spoiler)[I just finished the brilliant Song of Achilles (After finishing Circe) and loved every bit of it! Considering how "Achilles Heel" is such a predominantly used phrase to indicate a point of weakness, I was wondering whether not making Achilles invulnerable apart from on his heel was a conscious decision? Or did you just choose to go with alternate legends that do not say that he was dipped in river styx as a kid? (hide spoiler)]
Madeline Miller
Thank you so much! And yes, I didn't go with the heel legend because I was using the Iliad as my primary source of inspiration, and it isn't mentioned there at all. In Homer, Achilles is simply an extraordinary warrior, not invulnerable. Our first surviving reference to the heel story is actually quite late. But it seemed like exactly the sort of legend that would grow up around a person like Achilles--someone so gifted that we can only describe them in magical terms. Especially when he's beating you in battle every day! I can just see the Trojans telling each other that of course they can't beat him, haven't you heard? He's invulnerable...
On a completely different note, I once had an orthopedic surgeon tell me that wounds to the heel are quite dangerous, particularly in the time before modern medicine. They are prone to bad infections (being close to the dirty ground), and it would have been quite easy for a warrior to die of one.
On a completely different note, I once had an orthopedic surgeon tell me that wounds to the heel are quite dangerous, particularly in the time before modern medicine. They are prone to bad infections (being close to the dirty ground), and it would have been quite easy for a warrior to die of one.
More Answered Questions
lfreaton
asked
Madeline Miller:
Thank you for being a writer in my day and age. I literally gobbled up/read Circe then Song of Achilles in a week. These stories' are worlds, perhaps divinely inspired, helping this reader transcend today just enough to be remembered to life, itself: magic and mystery, virtue and its pains in discovery and, above all, love. What other classics did you rely on to write?
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.
See Featured Authors Answering Questions
Learn more




