Bridget answers “I have not finished the book, but wonder...”

Alyce asked this question about The Indigo Girl:

I have not finished the book, but wonder if a large segment of people would feel excluded reading a book in which slaves are property and Indians are a danger... I understand it's historical in the sense that slavery is a part of the American cultural fabric, but I feel like people of color might have little interest in this book. Which is sad. Can any people of color comment on this issue if they have read it?

Bridget I am listening to the book while doing my chores. I am not comfortable with a book that leads people to believe in a romantic relationship between a m…moreI am listening to the book while doing my chores. I am not comfortable with a book that leads people to believe in a romantic relationship between a male slave and white woman. That would have meant all kinds of death to him. And to lead us to believe she would have taught him to read or HE THE SLAVE would not have given her THE OWNER the secret she needed. Do you any white people understand the importance of that money? A rich owner is less likely to sale away your family. If held a secret that would keep your loved ones from being sold away wouldnt you share it regardless if you taught to read or not? (less)

flag

Jessie That is what made me uncomfortable about this book. Yes, some of it is an historical account, but the relationship between Eliza and Ben is pure ficti ...more
Nov 12, 2020 09:28AM · flag

Katharine Noble I read this book as a story about Eliza and her work -- not about the people enslaved on that plantation, because you are right, a white person cannot ...more
Oct 20, 2022 09:16PM · flag

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more