Poll

AUGUST SCIENCE FICTION: This poll decides which 2 books move on to the run-off poll for the August SF Book of the Month.

 
  27 votes, 32.1%

 
  18 votes, 21.4%

 
  13 votes, 15.5%

 
  11 votes, 13.1%

 
  10 votes, 11.9%

 
  5 votes, 6.0%


Poll added by: Candiss



Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Candiss (new)

Candiss I set the poll to expire on the 28th, so it will actually be open through 11:59pm May 27th, closing right at Midnight on the 28th.


message 2: by mark (new)

mark monday Chasm City is #2 in a series!


message 3: by Candiss (new)

Candiss mark wrote: "Chasm City is #2 in a series!"

Whoa...When you go to the Goodreads page for the book, it doesn't show that. But here it does! When the book was nominated, I didn't think anything of it, as the book's page makes it seem a-ok for our purposes. (It doesn't say #2 next to the title on the book's page, which is the usual indicator.) Blast it!

However, I think we're good to leave it in the noms. According to reviewer Michael here on Goodreads:

"First things first: Chasm City is NOT Revelation Space number two, unless the information on Alastair Reynolds’ personal website is wrong. That seems unlikely. Chasm City is stand-alone and can be read at any time."

source: Michael's review - http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

So it seems that if anything, it is a loose series, like Discworld or New Crobuzan, and it will still work for our purposes. If anyone else has info or input, let us know here.


message 4: by Phoenixfalls (new)

Phoenixfalls As far as I know, it's a stand-alone in the Revelation Space universe, but not directly linked to the main trilogy. It just says #2 because that's where it fits chronologically. (Though that chronology is probably even out of date, given how many books have now been written in that universe. . .)

It should be totally fine to read by itself. It's actually where I usually recommend people start with Reynolds. . . :)


message 5: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Xu Nice, my book is in the lead so far, winning.


message 6: by Ken (new)

Ken oh man... I was hoping for Sheep, maybe a close one the call, but it looks like Foreigner will be the one its way out in the lead.


message 7: by mark (new)

mark monday ah...thank you for the clarification, candiss & phoenix!


back to top

Members can create polls
widget


Jenny 2190 books
111 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Diane 1993 books
36 friends
voted for:
Idlewild by


Naydene 1468 books
63 friends
voted for:
Idlewild by


Suzanne 6453 books
452 friends
voted for:
Idlewild by


Jaclyn 663 books
117 friends
voted for:
Holy Fire by


Chris 2135 books
11 friends
voted for:
Idlewild by


Marvis 1023 books
10 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


whimsicalmeerkat 3293 books
83 friends
voted for:
The Sheep Lo


Shannon 571 books
20 friends
voted for:
Soft Apocaly


Mach 262 books
67 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Ann 276 books
981 friends
voted for:
Holy Fire by


Rachel 648 books
32 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Clark 484 books
195 friends
voted for:
The Sheep Lo


Stuart 1547 books
4236 friends
voted for:
The Sheep Lo


Hélène 6009 books
45 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Paul 4503 books
588 friends
voted for:
Idlewild by


Rebecca 369 books
15 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Ed 1423 books
151 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Jim 752 books
31 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Red 990 books
91 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Drew 3381 books
60 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Glen 1370 books
1 friend
voted for:
Chasm City b


Phil 386 books
4 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Trinity 4922 books
129 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Richelle 1450 books
37 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Phoenixfalls 851 books
50 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Philip 1404 books
472 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Dirk 3112 books
776 friends
voted for:
Chasm City b


Sandra 2518 books
147 friends
voted for:
Foreigner by


Julie 3167 books
44 friends
voted for:
The Sheep Lo


More...