Poll

If Stephenie Meyer re-writes all of the books from Edward's perspective, which one do you think will be your favorite?

New Moon from Edward's perspective
 
  22 votes, 32.4%

Midnight Sun
 
  19 votes, 27.9%

Breaking Dawn from Edward's perspective
 
  19 votes, 27.9%

Eclipse from Edward's perspective
 
  8 votes, 11.8%


Poll added by: Stephanie



Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kate (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:53AM) (new)

Kate I said New Moon, just because he's gone for most of it, and I want to know what he was doing!

... I want more from Jacob's perspective :)


message 2: by [deleted user] (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:53AM) (new)

I said new Moon because when he leaves we only get to see her reaction, and when he's gone and when he thinks she is dead I would love to read his thoughts and perspective!


message 3: by Immortal (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:53AM) (new)

Immortal Fiction Stephenie recently stated she couldn't imagine writing Edward's side of New Moon because it would be entirely too sad and painful to write. She spent about 8 months writing each book and she didin't think she could live in Edward's New Moon world for that long without being depressed and severly pained with him in writing that. I had thought more like reading his adventures in other countries tracking Victoria etc but even that he was distressed about "I wasn't even on the right continent" and then being so pained and numb as to abandon family and lay curled up and alone in the dark without even breathing for days or weeks at a time -- living as much in death as he could conjur up just to try not to feel her loss inside? I can see now why Stephenie would be afraid to go too far into that world emotionally to write that as expressively as she writes.

But I am hoping she might consider Midnight Sun extending beyond Twilight to encompass key points in the whole series, where his experiences and thoughts or those of others he picks up on might add more depth to his character and help readers understand his entire plight, history and pain more than many readers seem to. Most of us who have read even the first 12 chapters of MS know him about 20 times better than anyone ever could. I would pay her $20 for what she's written so far and $100 for the final version in ADVANCE if she would add a contributions or pre-orders button to her website to offset what's happened with MS!!!


message 4: by Immortal (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:53AM) (new)

Immortal Fiction I would LOVE for Stephenie to write a JACOB side for New Moon instead of an Edward side. They're both pretty open about their feelings by Eclipse and we thankfully get a "BOOK II JACOB" in Breaking Dawn which is awesome! So that would be a great project after MS for sure - maybe even BEFORE it since she wants to wait 2 years for MS!

But Bella calls him her "sun" wich is weird with Edward's book being called Midnight Sun. So shat should a JACOB view of New Moon be called?!


message 5: by Nelly (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:18AM) (new)

Nelly Lavaud I would want to know what happens after breaking dawn. What goes on with Renesmee and Jacob. How does life change for the Cullens, what new trials do they face? Just some quick things about the family. I feel like I've hadn't had enough.


message 6: by Melissa (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:53AM) (new)

Melissa New Moon because we saw the hell Bella went through while Edward was away, I'd like to see the hell he went through while he was away from her. Also how he felt when she tackled him in the street in Italy...LOL


message 7: by Stephanie (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:54AM) (new)

Stephanie Allen I really want to read Eclipse from Edward's view. While New Moon would be interesting, I think it would also be really heartbreaking to read. Eclipse would be interesting because I would like to see, from Edward's perspective, how he feels about the whole Jacob thing.


message 8: by Michelle (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:18AM) (new)

Michelle I voted for Midnight Sun, but really it was a toss up for me between that and Breaking Dawn. I would love to know what Edward is going through during Bella's transition...


back to top

Members can create polls
widget

4500

Twilight Series by Stephenie Meyer


Maggi 129 books
25 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Angela 6508 books
980 friends
voted for:
Eclipse from


Bella1 33 books
1 friend
voted for:
Eclipse from


Hannah 70 books
103 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Liz 580 books
11 friends
voted for:
Midnight Sun


Katy 261 books
14 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Joanne 38 books
109 friends
voted for:
Midnight Sun




Nicole 276 books
18 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


ⓑⓔ©©ⓐ 280 books
44 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Hannah 235 books
7 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Aimee 326 books
10 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Brooke 115 books
5 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Ashley 735 books
65 friends
voted for:
Eclipse from


Ms. Vicki 357 books
51 friends
voted for:
Midnight Sun


Angee 234 books
330 friends
voted for:
Eclipse from


Emily 1706 books
46 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Courtney 855 books
86 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Cat 12 books
2 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Scarlet 1401 books
71 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Luly 134 books
15 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Raquel 282 books
30 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Immortal 3858 books
149 friends
voted for:
Midnight Sun


Haley 1478 books
512 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Ayesha 1429 books
19 friends
voted for:
Eclipse from


Anna 2949 books
171 friends
voted for:
Breaking Daw


Cheryl 283 books
489 friends
voted for:
New Moon fro


Bayley 62 books
1 friend
voted for:
Midnight Sun


Stephanie 396 books
85 friends
voted for:
Midnight Sun


Megan 38 books
1 friend
voted for:
Breaking Daw


More...