Poll

So, if you had to choose a favorite apocalyptic book, what would it be? (I know, I know, just one?)

Disclaimer: I realize this list is WAY too short, simply based on some comments in discussions; it's really more of a platform to introduce that Oh-So-Intriguing "Other" field. No doubt that's where we'll get some interesting replies. Please COMMENT to add details!

Other (please comment!)
 
  25 votes, 35.7%

 
  21 votes, 30.0%

 
  13 votes, 18.6%

 
  4 votes, 5.7%

 
  4 votes, 5.7%

 
  3 votes, 4.3%


Poll added by: Gertie



Comments Showing 1-31 of 31 (31 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Gertie (last edited Jul 11, 2010 12:12PM) (new)

Gertie Just FYI, after some time has passed on this poll, I'll compile a new list based on our responses. Perhaps we'll get some good ideas on what to read next!


message 2: by Gertie (new)

Gertie I'll always have a special place in my heart for Swan Song by Robert R. McCammon.


message 3: by MegaDude (new)

MegaDude This will be an interesting poll, as it will be as much of an indication of what kinds of apocalypses people like to read about as their favorite book.

My favorite PA stories involve a plague scenario where the population is decimated, but the physical resources (food, equipment) are pretty much left untouched.

So to me, The Stand is the greatest book of all time.


message 4: by Katie (new)

Katie out of those choices, the road. i prefer a nuclear apocalypse type of scenario for books. :)


but off the poll, my favorite is probably either the last ship or dies the fire.


message 5: by Victoria (new)

Victoria Would have voted for Alas Babylon, but Where Late the Sweet Birds Sang, not quite JUST a post-apocalyptic read, still remains my favorite. Or Parable of the Sower by Octavia Butler. I suppose one could call both of these dystopias, rather than p-a books. If so, then log my choice for Alas Babylon. I have yet to read some of the newer entries.


message 6: by Kirk (new)

Kirk World War Z is my favorite, but I haven't read all of the choices yet.


message 7: by Cheryl (last edited Jul 11, 2010 04:51PM) (new)

Cheryl Earth Abides, by George R. Stewart

The best post apocalyptic novel of all time. Bar none. Without a doubt in my mind.

Released in 1949, a book written about a community of survivors. No superhero. No saviors.

If I survived a apocalyptic event I am confident that George Stewart's account of survival and society is what I would experience.

Originally published in 1949, "Earth Abides" won the International Fantasy Award in 1951, is included in "Science Fiction: The 100 Best Books" by David Pringle (both editions), was included in Locus Magazine's "All Time Best Science Fiction Novels" in 1987, and was a Prometheus Hall of Fame Finalist in 1990.


message 8: by Fear (last edited Jul 11, 2010 04:51PM) (new)

Fear Death My personal favorite 'off list' book has to be Dark Advent by Brian Hodge. An often over looked work, it's far closer to The Stand than Swan Song. (don't get me wrong Swan Song and Dark Advent are tied for 2nd place)

I just may read too much PA. I've read all the books mentioned so far but Parable of the Sower. (even Bar None)


message 9: by Kaye (new)

Kaye I agree. Earth Abides is amazing, with infinite re-readability and a poignant but believable ending.


message 10: by Mosker (new)

Mosker Oryx & Crake


message 11: by Laura (new)

Laura Canticle gets my vote mostly for its 'first in line' status (for me).


message 12: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth "Good Omens" is my favorite. I know, it's a bit different. If I had to choose one from the list it would be "The Road."


message 13: by Michele (new)

Michele There ARE a lot, and many of them are highly original in their choice of calamity and interpretation of "what happens after." But for sheer epicness, I think The Stand has them all beat :)


message 14: by Michele (new)

Michele Jennifer wrote: "I really loved "The Stand" by Stephen King and that was what I voted for, although I was tempted to click 'other' too, simply because I've just finished reading "I Am Legend" By Richard Matheson..."

And was it not exponentially better than the movie??


message 15: by William (new)

William Of the listed ones I would vote for The Road. Unlisted, On the Beach and Lucifer's Hammer have to be included.


message 16: by Mark (new)

Mark Rayner Cat's Cradle, no question! (Though people may also want to check out The Amadeus Net.) ;)


message 17: by Dan (new)

Dan The thing I love about Stephen King is how he will describe the event "the super flu", "the dome", etc from several characters perspectives. It really allows you to get a feel for the event and how it affects everyone.
For me I'm drawn to the hows and whys of the event and King satisfies that.


message 18: by Bryan (new)

Bryan Ochalla Of the apocalypse books I've read, I'd have to say Lucifer's Hammer and Swan Song have been my favorites. I've yet to read quite a few of the 'classics,' though, so take my suggestions with a large grain of salt ;)


message 19: by Nathan (new)

Nathan I said other, I choose I Am Legend. It's been my favorite. I've only read The Road, The Stand, Cell, and I Am Legend, as far as apocalyptic books go.


message 20: by Andrew (new)

Andrew I chose other as well. The Earth Abides remains my favorite with Alas Babylon a close second.


message 21: by Nancy (new)

Nancy I recently read Malevil, which was up there, mainly because it was recent, there were no mutants, and people still strove for some sort of civilization. Also, it showed how quickly people can be co-erced into following the wrong sort of person. It was a bit weird that no person or animal was harmed, and there was a solcialist overtone, but definitely a good read.


message 22: by Sean (new)

Sean Benton My first Post-Apoc film I'd ever seen was the Postman, and while most would say that it was a travesty of film-making, the memory of it held on for ten years when I'd recollect it and revive it in its literary form. I believe the book is even better than the film, for the depth (which somehow couldn't be squeezed into 3+ hours? - please!), and emotion. It is by far my favorite post-apoc book. Given, I've not read TOO many, I have dabbled here and there. The Road, while I gave it a shot, could not satisfy my need for complete sentences and therefore failed miserably (the movie was satisfactory however)


message 23: by Gertie (new)

Gertie "my need for complete sentences..."

Haha! I had issues with that as well Sean. I also didn't care for contractions without apostrophes, ie. dont instead of don't. It really killed the flow, although I suppose it was intended to have the opposite effect. :-P


message 24: by Tod (last edited Sep 07, 2010 06:08AM) (new)

Tod Riddley Walker by Russell Hoban. I like a book that makes me work for it ;-)

But not one (like The Road) that makes me do all the writing myself.


message 25: by Sheila (new)

Sheila I will have to pick On the Beach as my "other" choice, mainly because it was the first book of the genre that really got me hooked on this whole PA thing.


message 26: by Carol (new)

Carol Brannigan There are so many good ones but I'm gonna have to put The Passage by Justin Cronin on the top. It was just so well done.


message 27: by stormhawk (new)

stormhawk This list is pretty much post apocalyptic than apocalyptic, if you want to be technical about it ... my favorite apocalyptic book is Fail Safe, but for the purposes of the poll I chose Canticle for Leibowitz.


message 28: by Eve (new)

Eve Swan Song is my first choice.


message 29: by Torch (new)

Torch One Second After is so far my favorite PA book.


message 30: by Torch (new)

Torch Sean wrote: "My first Post-Apoc film I'd ever seen was the Postman, and while most would say that it was a travesty of film-making, the memory of it held on for ten years when I'd recollect it and revive it in ..."

The book is even better than the film!


message 31: by Gertie (new)

Gertie Poll is now closed... will be putting up version 2.0 shortly!


back to top

Members can create polls
widget


Barry 102 books
0 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Redroc 351 books
36 friends
voted for:
The Road


Carol 1442 books
43 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Michael 992 books
26 friends
voted for:
Emergence


Katie 1151 books
49 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Neisha Campbell 1024 books
65 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Eve 891 books
77 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Torch 1327 books
9 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Ian 239 books
2267 friends
voted for:
The Stand


Catherine 1803 books
292 friends
voted for:
The Road


Hilary 2909 books
110 friends
voted for:
The Road


Fear 42 books
2 friends
voted for:
The Stand


Terry 128 books
1 friend
voted for:
The Stand


Amber 915 books
17 friends
voted for:
The Stand


Jesse 208 books
0 friends
voted for:
The Stand


B. 1428 books
24 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Bryan 216 books
1 friend
voted for:
The Stand


Iamthez 3771 books
114 friends
voted for:
The Road


Victoria 1123 books
20 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


VV 694 books
47 friends
voted for:
The Road


Mandie 3306 books
32 friends
voted for:
A Canticle f


Ric 191 books
1 friend
voted for:
Other (pleas


Matthew 464 books
38 friends
voted for:
Alas, Babylo


Dan 276 books
16 friends
voted for:
The Stand


Brooke 1229 books
13 friends
voted for:
The Road


Robert 3295 books
81 friends
voted for:
The Stand


V.J. 414 books
249 friends
voted for:
A Canticle f


Elizabeth 130 books
6 friends
voted for:
Other (pleas


Katie 421 books
3 friends
voted for:
The Road


Bob 1891 books
5 friends
voted for:
The Stand


More...