Poll

What book do you want to read for March?
Theme is animals.
Theme is animals.
470 total votes
Poll added by: Alan
Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Maddy
(last edited Feb 19, 2023 01:34PM)
(new)
Feb 19, 2023 01:33PM

reply
|
flag



scene that has, to me, severe animal cruelty and abuse. I was so angry and disgusted I wept for the poor animal and wanted to do everything to the woman that she did to her pet cat. I might be more sensitive about this, because I have pets, but animals are basically innocent and have no idea why they are in pain.
I don't feel this strongly about violence or torture towards people in books or movies. I thought I'd mention it, so nobody runs into it blindly like I did. I don't know if the fact that I have pet cats made me more sensitive, but it was horrible to read. If you need to skip it it won't change your reading experience in my opinion. Has anyone else read this book that has an opinion about that part of the book? Am I overreacting or on the nose about the scene?

scene that has, to me, severe animal cruelty and abuse. I was so angry and disgusted I wept for the poor animal and wanted to do everything to the woman that she did ..."
Thank you so much for the heads up! I don’t think you overreacted and honestly don’t think that’s a thing. Your reaction is yours and true, whatever it is. I for one appreciate the heads up because I can’t handle animal abuse.

scene that has, to me, severe animal cruelty and abuse. I was so angry and disgusted I wept for the poor animal and wanted to do everything to the woman that she did ..."
Thanks for the info. I was wondering if Nightbitch is just a story about transformation or if there are any actual animals that play a central role in the story, and I guess your comment helped answer that question, but... yikes.

It's a very good book, IMO, and I liked going into it feeling that I already knew the main characters and it was a chance to get to know them and their neighbors even better!

scene that has, to me, severe animal cruelty and abuse. I was so angry and disgusted I wept for the poor animal and wanted to do everything to the woma..."
Thank you for saying so, it was really a shock, because there were no warnings about it anywhere that I read about it. The book description didn't either or I probably wouldn't have read it.
It's a really strange book, because it's ambiguous whether or not there were real physical changes or only psychological. The end was upbeat for the most part I think. I just could not handle the extreme violence and suffering of the poor family cat. I rarely cry over a movie or book, but torturing and killing an innocent creature that loves and trusts you was just far too awful.


What an excellent tip, Ruth. Thank you. I think I will squeeze it in this month to be better prepared.

Badseedgirl wrote: "I've already read What Moves the Dead and to be honest Nightbitch just does not appeal to me. So although I voted, I'll probably skip March group read. I did add [bo..."
I'm adding ANIMAL KINGDOM to my TBR as well!
I'm adding ANIMAL KINGDOM to my TBR as well!



Hey Liz, I'm glad to share what I learned from my reading experience with WMTD. And The Fall of the House of Usher is a classic - only a 60-ish page book on my Kindle, so it was easy to prioritize and read in advance of T. Kingfisher's book. It was one of those situations after I read House of Usher that I wanted to know a bit more and get some details... then along comes WMTD and voila! My wish was fulfilled. Hope you enjoy both!

T. Kingfisher is a very good storyteller and I think does a nice job with character development; I'm a big fan of What Moves the Dead. But I, like you, voted for The Haunting of Caldgrave House because I thought it was such a novel concept and one of the noms that best fit the theme of a horror book that features a regular animal. I added it to my TBR and look forward to reading on my own... hoping this Amy Cross book will work better for me than the previous one I read: The Ghost of Shapley Hall (2 stars).

We could do a buddy read if you would like.
Badseedgirl wrote: "Kimberly wrote: "Badseedgirl wrote: "I've already read What Moves the Dead and to be honest Nightbitch just does not appeal to me. So although I voted, I'll probably..."
That would be fun!
That would be fun!

scene that has, to me, severe animal cruelty and abuse. I was so angry and disgusted I wept for the poor animal and wanted to do everyth..."
I’m with you for sure! I can’t handle it!

I don't think I've read anything by Amy Cross before. But even if the book doesn't win, I'll go and read the sample and decide from there if I still want to read it. The premise definitely sounds like it could be a good one, but I've been duped by a good premise before.
It's looking like our winners are running away from the pack, so unless something drastically changes, I would be up for a Buddy Read of Amy Cross next month.

Yes, please and thank you!