Noise: A Flaw in Human Judgment
Rate it:
Read between July 31 - August 28, 2024
49%
Flag icon
cognitive reflection test (CRT),
50%
Flag icon
attempt to measure how likely people are to override the first (and wrong) answer that comes to mind
50%
Flag icon
The CRT is seen by many as one instrument to measure a broader concept: the propensity to use reflective versus impulsive thought processes. Simply put, some people like to engage in careful
50%
Flag icon
CRT can be seen as a measure of people’s propensity to rely on slow, System 2 thinking rather than on fast, System 1 thinking.
50%
Flag icon
People with a high need for cognition tend to be less susceptible to known cognitive biases.
50%
Flag icon
Adult Decision Making
50%
Flag icon
Competence scale, which measures how prone people are to make typical errors in judgment like overconfidence or inconsistency in risk perceptions.
50%
Flag icon
Halpern Critical Thinking ...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
50%
Flag icon
seem to make better judgments in life:
50%
Flag icon
the need for cognition was reliably associated with higher performance.
50%
Flag icon
“actively open-minded thinking.” To be actively open-minded is to actively search for information that contradicts your preexisting hypotheses.
50%
Flag icon
“Allowing oneself to be convinced by an opposing argument is a sign of good character.”
50%
Flag icon
humility of those who are constantly aware that their judgment is a work in progress and who yearn to be corrected.
50%
Flag icon
two general principles emerge from this brief review.
50%
Flag icon
First, it is wise to recognize the difference between domains in which expertise can be confirmed by comparison with true values
50%
Flag icon
some judges are going to be better than their equally qualified and experienced peers.
50%
Flag icon
People often tend to trust and like leaders who are firm and clear and who seem to know, immediately and deep in their bones, what is right.
50%
Flag icon
How people think is also important.
50%
Flag icon
two approaches to debiasing measurements
51%
Flag icon
Ex post, or corrective, debiasing
51%
Flag icon
(the planning fallacy)
51%
Flag icon
The Green Book recommends applying generic adjustment percentages for each type of project.
51%
Flag icon
Ex ante
51%
Flag icon
broad cate...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
51%
Flag icon
modify the environment in which the judgment or deci...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
51%
Flag icon
nudges, as they a...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
51%
Flag icon
Other nudges work on different aspects of choice architecture.
51%
Flag icon
A different type of ex ante debiasing involves training decision makers to recognize their biases and to overcome them.
51%
Flag icon
boosting;
51%
Flag icon
for example, by teaching them statist...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
51%
Flag icon
teaching people to avoid biases is hard.
51%
Flag icon
bias that we have seen in one place is likely to materialize in other places.
51%
Flag icon
nontraditional teaching methods
51%
Flag icon
approaches have one thing in common: they target a specific bias, which they assume is present.
51%
Flag icon
This often-reasonable assumption is sometimes wrong.
51%
Flag icon
forecast by analogy
51%
Flag icon
loss aversion,
51%
Flag icon
status quo bias,
51%
Flag icon
In any situation of some complexity, multiple psychological biases may be at work, conspiring to add error in the same direction or offsetting one another, with unpredictable consequences.
51%
Flag icon
planning fallacy is a sufficiently robust finding to warrant debiasing interventions against overconfident planning.
51%
Flag icon
direction of error is not known in advance.
51%
Flag icon
effect of psychological biases...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
51%
Flag icon
resulting in syst...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
51%
Flag icon
We suggest
51%
Flag icon
real time.
51%
Flag icon
bias blind spot.
51%
Flag icon
imagine a decision observer,
51%
Flag icon
not an easy role to play,
51%
Flag icon
some organizations it is not realistic.
51%
Flag icon
do not recommend that you make yourself a self-appointed decision observer.
1 14 26