If You Tell: A True Story of Murder, Family Secrets, and the Unbreakable Bond of Sisterhood
Rate it:
Open Preview
49%
Flag icon
“She feels so bad.”
49%
Flag icon
The girls noticed she’d shed a torrent of tears for dead pets, but never for another person.
49%
Flag icon
told Nikki and Sami that she didn’t want them talking behind her back.
49%
Flag icon
“Sami, your sister is a bad influence.”
49%
Flag icon
After Kathy died and Shane disappeared, they stopped altogether.
50%
Flag icon
my sister just not being there.
50%
Flag icon
think she was being groomed by my mom not to be here anymore.”
50%
Flag icon
None of Sami’s friends even knew Nikk...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
50%
Flag icon
Shelly turned to Nikki. “You need to stay outside and make yourself scarce.” Nikki promised she would.
50%
Flag icon
Lara Watson figured her grandson Shane was being a typical teenager whenever she reached out to talk to him.
50%
Flag icon
In fact, whenever Lara sent a check for Christmas or his birthday, it got cashed immediately—endorsed by Shane.
50%
Flag icon
Except he never did.
50%
Flag icon
Hannah AdvicefromaPsychologyStudent
Lara
50%
Flag icon
He never called anyone except Shelly.
51%
Flag icon
Yes, she was lonely and almost didn’t dare to hope for a future that involved happiness and love and freedom.
51%
Flag icon
To show up on campus looking like that would chip away at whatever personal pride she’d been able to grow by being away from Monohon Landing during the day.
51%
Flag icon
It was the same place she’d made Kathy sleep.
51%
Flag icon
She had no car, and no money for bus fare.
51%
Flag icon
see—to do anything with the space.
51%
Flag icon
“Is that all you did today? You lazy bitch!”
51%
Flag icon
Tears would come, and both of her parents would push it even harder.
51%
Flag icon
‘You should have told me you needed a car! I had no idea that was your problem.’”
Hannah AdvicefromaPsychologyStudent
Gaslighting
51%
Flag icon
“I just told Mom to fuck off!” she yelled, but kept running, this time out the other door and into the woods, where she slept that night.
51%
Flag icon
Shelly gave her daughter some clothes, fifty dollars in cash, and drove her to the Greyhound bus station in Olympia.
52%
Flag icon
Sami understood the reasons behind Nikki’s absence, of course.
52%
Flag icon
Nikki was beautiful, and kind, and she always made time for Tori.
52%
Flag icon
Early the next morning, she woke to her mom punching and slapping her in the face.
52%
Flag icon
to cry. “You
52%
Flag icon
“She just left this. She didn’t stay.”
52%
Flag icon
Sami never brought Nikki up either. She didn’t dare. She didn’t want her family to know that she was still in touch with her sister.
52%
Flag icon
tent adjacent
52%
Flag icon
Nikki remained justifiably bitter about the punishments her stepdad had forced on her, but mostly she now saw him as pathetic, a loser.
52%
Flag icon
Her mother would treat Nikki as though the exile to Canada and
52%
Flag icon
conversation that no one wanted to have.
52%
Flag icon
Yet by her senior year, Sami was taking a “fuck it” approach to life. She’d grown tired of covering up what her mom had been doing to her and her older sister.
53%
Flag icon
Sami was called in front of the school counselor.
53%
Flag icon
I guess I didn’t want them to make my mother mad.”
53%
Flag icon
Then Sami would be sent back outside to sleep on the porch.
53%
Flag icon
running to Kaley’s house. She’d had it. She wasn’t going to take it anymore.
53%
Flag icon
but she let herself into the Hansons’ garage.
53%
Flag icon
But Dave attributed those graduation-day bruises to Sami’s own side of the scorecard, saying that she’d been a daredevil and risk-taker and had injured herself in a fall.
53%
Flag icon
1997,
53%
Flag icon
enrollment period for Evergreen State College.
53%
Flag icon
She even mused about seeing what kind of work she could get in Hollywood.
53%
Flag icon
Sami let in on her plan were her friends Lauren and Leah—
54%
Flag icon
Sami wanted to give Tori a vague heads-up.
54%
Flag icon
“If I don’t come back later today,” she told her sister, “I will leave a little note for you—just for you—under my pillow.”
54%
Flag icon
then eight.
Hannah AdvicefromaPsychologyStudent
Tori was only 8
54%
Flag icon
“Mom, Lauren ran out of gas and I need to go pick her up,”
54%
Flag icon
you. I started thinking about hurt and life and how much I hurt and how much hurt I cause.
1 11 16