If You Tell: A True Story of Murder, Family Secrets, and the Unbreakable Bond of Sisterhood
Rate it:
Open Preview
Kindle Notes & Highlights
2%
Flag icon
the past but an invisible badge of courage. What happened to Nikki made her stronger. It made
ruthie
Traumaca xo that
3%
Flag icon
it’s the little things—duct tape, pain relievers, the sound of a weed eater—that propel her back to a time and place where their mother did things they swore they’d hold secret forever.
7%
Flag icon
“I don’t understand Shelly’s constant need to try to ruin people’s lives.”
7%
Flag icon
Chuck was mostly quiet—timid, even. Lara would have him sit on her lap while she read to him and listened to him pretend to read to her. Whenever he tried to speak, Shelly was right there answering for him. School was difficult for him too.
10%
Flag icon
“Shelly is only nice to me when there are other people around.”
ruthie
MY mlther
14%
Flag icon
While her accusations hadn’t ruined him, they’d left a scar.
17%
Flag icon
“My mom could be sweet when she wanted to be,” Sami said.
ruthie
Convenience
17%
Flag icon
Shelly told Nikki she was ugly and worthless, and she needed time to think about why she was such a rotten girl. She was told that she’d be there awhile. “As long as it takes,” Shelly said. Nikki later recalled it might have been for the entire summer.
18%
Flag icon
Still, Shelly wasn’t completely averse to taking her girls to the doctor whenever they needed medical attention.
ruthie
My dad
20%
Flag icon
boom. I loved my mother because I didn’t know I had a choice. I had to love her.”
ruthie
I loce mt mama
21%
Flag icon
castigations.
27%
Flag icon
Going against their mother’s demands meant being stripped naked and forced to wallow or maybe get beaten with an electric cord.
ruthie
Feel this
35%
Flag icon
Her mom’s lie was audacious. Kathy needed medical attention. Not a stint in a dank outbuilding.
ruthie
The motr is insane like your hild is dyin and shhs not dlingsnhin abkut it
40%
Flag icon
She’d lost a lot of weight, and the sight of her made Nikki nearly gag. She was black and blue, and her skin hung in soft red folds.
ruthie
I ge it
40%
Flag icon
“Obviously I wasn’t a doctor, but I think anyone would probably know that there was no way that salt was going to do anything good for Kathy,”
ruthie
St maeks bloafijng worse
40%
Flag icon
After that was done, Shelly gave Kathy some pills and told her to take those too. Then they locked
ruthie
I eojl die
41%
Flag icon
Hideous bruising marked her body, and her skin hung in folds from extreme weight loss. She’d lost more than a hundred pounds since she’d moved in with the Knoteks.
43%
Flag icon
Kathy’s death had been an accident. Natural causes. No one’s fault. He was going to have to get rid of her body.
ruthie
Difficukt to nlt be halpy shes deadbc she was terrinlr
48%
Flag icon
She loved her sisters more than anything, though she also wondered why her mother saw her so differently, treated her with such hatred.
ruthie
Ilovr my sister mire thn anyhthung
49%
Flag icon
She vomited and had diarrhea for more than a week. If she had hoped to make a statement living a real-life nightmare, no one picked up on
ruthie
ME tofay
52%
Flag icon
Yet by her senior year, Sami was taking a “fuck it” approach to life. She’d grown tired of covering up what her mom had been doing to her and her older sister. She’d learned from Nikki’s experience that not rocking the boat didn’t stop bad things from happening. It only allowed them to continue.
ruthie
YEpppp hiding your secrets keepingyou si k
53%
Flag icon
“We’re going to make arrangements to have your sister removed from the home,” the counselor said. “We are going to call your mom now.”
ruthie
Yes thbank goodness
55%
Flag icon
The state came in to investigate. Each time, Nikki and Lara would be dumbfounded as to why anyone would complain. The staff, patients, and their families all liked her.
ruthie
Stockhm syndrome
57%
Flag icon
There was a debt of $36,000 associated with her Social Security number. It wasn’t her name on the account, however.
ruthie
My dad
59%
Flag icon
need to see how you’re developing,” she said. “All moms do this.”
ruthie
Ewww no thrg dont
59%
Flag icon
Sometimes Shelly would tell Tori to remove her panties too, so she could examine her vagina.
ruthie
Assait
63%
Flag icon
Why would he disobey Mom? He knows what will happen to him. It made her so angry that he had done that.
ruthie
Im afrwid pfher
64%
Flag icon
and defensive. MK told me she did not want to ‘be put in a corner again.’”
67%
Flag icon
This one night, us kids heard all kinds of things, so we peeked in Kathy’s room and saw Dad doing something to Kathy, ’cause [a] lot of white foaming stuff was coming out of Kathy’s mouth. I think Mom poisoned her. Or caused Kathy so much brain damage from hitting her in the head. But Kathy wasn’t moving. I think she was dead. We had to run back away from the room ’cause we are not allowed to be downstairs and we didn’t want Mom to know what we saw. She would beat us or do bad things to us if she knew what we saw.”
ruthie
They are deplosravld psfejts
67%
Flag icon
I hope Dad doesn’t commit suicide because of me.”
ruthie
Thats jow i feel w my dad
73%
Flag icon
“You need it. All girls do.”
ruthie
Manchauzens ?
76%
Flag icon
Normal is relative, and normal didn’t have much staying power at Monohon Landing Road.
78%
Flag icon
She asked her mother about his significant weight loss.
78%
Flag icon
“He needed to lose weight, Sami. He was fat. He’s eating healthy. No more junk food. He’s in the best shape he’s ever been. He has muscles where he never knew he
ruthie
Lowkey trigerinf as im suffern from.anorexia like wowie ofc thi is so jarrin for me
81%
Flag icon
On a separate occasion, Tori heard her mother telling Ron to be a man and jump. She went to look and could see Ron, wearing only underwear, climb to the rail and
ruthie
SUch a abusve household
81%
Flag icon
Shelly probably didn’t know that bleach was bad either, he said.
82%
Flag icon
But those feet. They were so swollen he could barely move
ruthie
Me woth neuropthy
83%
Flag icon
but she didn’t want to carry the burden of defying their mother. Her mother had spent years telling
ruthie
Oof this sounds like menta abue like id use my disorder to find awa to contrl it id feel ao unsafe
83%
Flag icon
What if Nikki didn’t like her? Nikki had been such a huge influence in Tori’s life—taking care of her, playing with her. And then poof! She was suddenly
84%
Flag icon
After all of that was done, she made the call to Dave.
ruthie
DId shelly stge hissdeathas an accident withthe campin
84%
Flag icon
“There’s no way she caused any abuse on Ron or Kathy. She just didn’t call when Ron passed on. It was just out of fear of what happened in the past. And like I say, my wife worries about everything and she was just looking after her family again. She’s just being the protector that she always is. I don’t see where she had done anything wrong at all.”
ruthie
WOw he was ao maaipulated by her yk beieve she as good
85%
Flag icon
“She did it before. She did it to all of us. She did it to Kathy.”
87%
Flag icon
“Okay, Nikki,” Sami reasoned, “but Mom wouldn’t really hurt us. Shane was our brother.”
88%
Flag icon
She disappeared and returned with a couple of tablets. “Take these.”
ruthie
Plwcebos or just pushing or shovib emds ro shut them uo
88%
Flag icon
After all they’d talked about, after every detail Sami knew to be true, she probably had the better grasp of what Shelly could, would, and had done. Nikki had confided in Sami that she thought at one time her parents had plotted to
ruthie
Like lowwkey manchaasuenn disease im guessingin order to make the kids beliee tyar too sk an need sherri in order to suivive as thkug they dont know ho to take cae offt emselves
90%
Flag icon
they send me back home, what will my mom do to me? she
ruthie
Giss the fear
91%
Flag icon
“Your mom is now putting stuff into your mind and accusing everyone else for talking about her. The authorities said DO NOT FALL for it.”
91%
Flag icon
We all have to remember that mother is pretty smart, and she manages to weasel her way out of
ruthie
YEs she does ann dhs trrifyin becaueofthi
96%
Flag icon
“Killing someone is something you never get over,” he said. “Not even for a second. It’s always there.”
ruthie
I mean ik wwuld hope not if you dd youre iknsmae
99%
Flag icon
Victims of abuse can still love the monster. This ambivalent loyalty might just be the predator’s ultimate form of damage.
ruthie
Ztockjmsyndrme