Defiance (The Spiral Wars, #4)
Rate it:
Open Preview
12%
Flag icon
moreso
15%
Flag icon
moreso
David P. Duffy
Again and again, indicator of a writer's "tic."
25%
Flag icon
old-fashioned
David P. Duffy
Seems PC, and frankly, insulting. It is contemptible in fact, and seriously diminishes the author.
25%
Flag icon
of course
26%
Flag icon
Needless to say,
David P. Duffy
If "Needless to say…," why is author saying it?
27%
Flag icon
of course
David P. Duffy
Again, author shows laziness and sloppiness in writing.
27%
Flag icon
vacuum to poison gas.
David P. Duffy
Author makes no mention of one aspect of operating underwater-pressure.
32%
Flag icon
“Hello Lieutenant Jalawi, this is Lieutenant Lassa on Coms. Please hold a moment, the LC is busy on an operational concern… LC? LC, I have Lieutenant Jalawi on coms.”
David P. Duffy
"'Hello…?'" This dialogue is very bogus.
32%
Flag icon
“Hello Lieutenant Jalawi, this is the LC. The Captain’s getting a little sleep, you’re now on record and will be replayed to him and Commander Shahaim when they wake up. Please go ahead.”
David P. Duffy
Again bogus dialogue, fully unrealistic.
32%
Flag icon
“I copy that LC. Well, we’re making good progress with the laser. It works fine, but the overheating is just as we were warned… it’s not so bad in the cold water, but we’re not using it for longer than two seconds at a time.
David P. Duffy
Is he making a status report on ongoing recovery operations, in a high threat/hostile environment, or sending a letter home from summer camp? Author really falls below the mark here and in other spots. It's as if he is overtired, rushing to get pages done, or just going through the motions.
32%
Flag icon
but
32%
Flag icon
luckily
32%
Flag icon
but
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
32%
Flag icon
but
32%
Flag icon
but
32%
Flag icon
I guess
32%
Flag icon
I guess
32%
Flag icon
No doubt Styx would know immediately that the Captain was having a conversation he didn’t want her listening to.
David P. Duffy
Given Styx's proven proficiency with microbots, electronic surveillance, sigint, etc., isn't it unrealistic to suppose she hasn't found a means to listen in?
33%
Flag icon
“I’m fairly sure I saw an assassin bug.
David P. Duffy
That's no surprise.
37%
Flag icon
“Ordinance
David P. Duffy
Ordnance
38%
Flag icon
“Where’s my inflight meal?” Jalawi complained. “I wanna refund.” Regan cut him off, grinning madly.
David P. Duffy
This is much more realistic dialogue. Black humor, dry wit, is ever present with those engaged in close combat. It's not about keeping fear in check so much, as controlling, channeling anger and the adrenaline rush.
41%
Flag icon
Erik had jumped away from Cephilae after stabbing Aristan in the back, suspecting that such action would likely get Lisbeth killed. Thus her true reason for concern. Concern at what it meant for all of them, in his present mental state… whatever that was. But mostly, concern just for him.
David P. Duffy
Nonsense.
41%
Flag icon
Medbay sometimes didn’t tell the bridge how many injuries had been caused by the latest manoeuvres, in case the bridge got cold feet and didn’t dodge so hard the next time.
David P. Duffy
More nonsense.
41%
Flag icon
It was the size of a medicine ball, but looked rather more like a tennis ball, with curving grooves that snaked their way around its surface.
David P. Duffy
Lazy and sloppy manner of description. Using contemporary items to describe an item in a far future.
42%
Flag icon
Kaspowitz told the younger man, somewhat patronisingly.
David P. Duffy
This whole line of "attitudinal insubordination," or at least insolence, that is exhibited towards the captain by his executive officers, bridge officers, and marine contingent C.O., is rapidly eroding the storyline. No warship's C.O., or in fact, ANY C.O., would be accepting of this breakdown of command authority. Mr. Shepherd, is fully off base.
44%
Flag icon
punching bag,
David P. Duffy
Heavy bag
44%
Flag icon
“It’s your fault she’s even out here,” he snarled, with genuine fury. “God help you if she’s dead.”
David P. Duffy
This is another plot line that doesn't come across as reasonable. It's too contrived and unsupported by the relationship established in the first three (3) books.
45%
Flag icon
“Fine. But
David P. Duffy
Author has addressed to a degree, the undermining of the command cohesiveness. Only to a degree, as Major Trace still seems to think she knows all, and knows better. Her superb abilities has caused a hubris, that is in fact, more dangerous than the captain's flaws.
45%
Flag icon
“Some of us accept that,” she said with steel in her voice. “Others refuse.”
David P. Duffy
Hubris.
46%
Flag icon
If it was worse than he said, Suelo would probably be lying anyway, as medical staff would often do with bridge queries.
David P. Duffy
Heck of a way to run a warship.
47%
Flag icon
“Hello Major,
47%
Flag icon
“Hello Captain,
54%
Flag icon
“Hello Captain,”
David P. Duffy
Might as well just use "AHOY," and be done with it.
55%
Flag icon
“Hello UFS Phoenix,”
55%
Flag icon
“Hello parren warship Stassis,
56%
Flag icon
“I have a feeling
57%
Flag icon
“I have a feeling
57%
Flag icon
“Hello Major,
67%
Flag icon
“I know. Would you like to play a game anyway?”
David P. Duffy
Sound familiar?
68%
Flag icon
moreso
70%
Flag icon
steady pop! pop! pop!
71%
Flag icon
There’s no way we can defend this place from the deepynines, even if we were united. Disunited we’ve got no chance.
David P. Duffy
That is nonsensical - can't win united, can't win divided. Author has captain speaking gibberish.
71%
Flag icon
adjusting the cowl and veil where they’d come loose of their hidden velcro…
David P. Duffy
Geez, who would figure an alien race, millennia older than humans, would be using "…velcro…"?
72%
Flag icon
“Hello
72%
Flag icon
“Hello
72%
Flag icon
but Major Thakur just killed the Domesh leader in a catharan,
David P. Duffy
One would think EVERYONE AMONGST THE "PHOENIX" COMMAND AND CREW KNOW THAT. Why repeat the obvious and make it seem like new info?
72%
Flag icon
“Hello
73%
Flag icon
“The deepynines are chasing you and the data-core primarily, so we’ll send you both down to the surface with the reconnaissance team.
David P. Duffy
Was this "Styx's" objective all along? Get off the "Phoenix," with the data core, down to the moon?
73%
Flag icon
Erik could not help but feel a little pleased that Styx liked his idea…
David P. Duffy
Dangerously childish.
75%
Flag icon
“Hello
« Prev 1