A History of Religious Ideas, Volume 1: From the Stone Age to the Eleusinian Mysteries
Rate it:
Open Preview
Kindle Notes & Highlights
11%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Enki errs by violating his own law.
11%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Does Fate itself represent a god in this mythological construct? If not, does the existence of a Fate binding the gods imply another, greater entity?
11%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Thant’s how I always thought it should go. It would be much easier that way.
11%
Flag icon
Noah S.
I cannot find any clue as to what is a Lagma god.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Or, that humans were created with a divine element.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
They mirror the creation of the universe?
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Not the creation of the universe, but its recreation, apparently by mortal agents; allowing us to mirror the divine.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Essentially a sacred prostitute.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Literally "Image of the World." It refers to the creation of a miniature cosmos as a representation of the larger cosmos.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
The idea that concepts exist in ... well, somewhere, before they become actualized in the world, and the corollary that the ideal versions are more perfect than earthly incarnations.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Making Plato, ironically, not the first Platonist
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
It was the end of the world
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Are Dilmun and "The Mouth of the Rivers" different places?
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Do they need a common source separate from one a another?
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Thank you
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
You know, I somehow managed never to associate the pre-creation waters of chaos with the waters of the flood. Seems kind of obvious now.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Are the sins of man and the decrepitude of the world separate things? If one sees mankind and the earth inhabited by mankind as a single entity than the decrepitude of the latter should be reflected in the conduct of the former.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Like a person
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
It is actually the same theme underlying zombie movies and other post-apocalyptic stories of the early 21st century.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
What is meant by "actuality" and why does it appear in quotation marks?
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Because being all-powerful required encompassing both genders, or because being all-powerful required her to be at least part Dude?
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
It was not even Dumuzi's own ambition that led to his downfall, but that of his wife.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Is the association of nudity and helplessness universal among humans?
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
There was a definite echo of Christ’s “harrowing of hell” right up to the part where, instead of becoming a sacrifice to redeem humanity, she seeks out a mortal to guarantee her own redemption. Actually, maybe the echo persists. Maybe Christ’s story is a defendant of this reimagined to put us at the center of the cosmological drama.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Oh, apparently Dumuzi did beckon his own destruction.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
The myth creates a god who periodically dies and is periodically reborn. In this version he is coupled with a sister who dies upon his birth and is herself reborn upon Damuzi's death. It is like a combined Baldr & Persephone super-duo.
12%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Like Orpheus.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
A reason separate and apart from his necessary role in the drama of the seasons.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
In Jerusalem?
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Both the king and the world could die, but could also return. They apparently did so together in a single festival marking the end of one year and the beginning of the next.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
A mystery related to the discovery of agriculture? It could be modeled on the death of the crops at harvest and their rebirth in the spring.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
The human king could partake in a cyclical mode of life normally available only to the gods. Presumably, Damuzi's own human origins served as a sort of precedence for this transcendence. The creation of humans from divine elements (Enki's breath, the blood of Lagma gods, etc.) could also be considered a precedent for the human king's access to a divine mode of death and rebirth.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
The privilege of rebirth after facing the inevitability of death.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
There is a lot more than Gutians involved in the collapse of Sargon’s empire.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Ur was a Sumerian as opposed to Akkadian polity? Or, had the two linguistic/cultural groups become fully integrated by that point?
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
The Akkadian/Amorite speaking rulers of Mesopotamia will apparently continue to use Sumerian for religious ceremonies and scholarship until 500 B.C?
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
I wonder why square-ing numbers seems significant. Maybe it’s the inherent symmetry in the thing.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Sky-Atmosphere-Earth is replaced by City-Sun-Venus.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Good cliff-hanger
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
I did not realize that Tiamat was part of the first couple.
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
As a virtue of being undifferentiated?
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Is a desire for quiet part of these gods' identity as forces of stagnation?
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Which sounds pretty awesome
13%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Giving us another link to divine, but also giving us a link to the bad guys.
14%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Is this an early intrusion of morality into theology? Is Tiamat the first evil goddess?
14%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Is this the first connection between materialism and profanity?
14%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Man is in some sense imperfect, corrupt, or profane.
14%
Flag icon
Noah S.
Maybe not as pessimistic as Eliade believes. There is a redemptive element in man's creation, albeit from profane materials, by a divine hand.
14%
Flag icon
Noah S.
A gnostic sect from the early Christian Era.
14%
Flag icon
Noah S.
All of which appear in festivals of modern religions.