Playing Dirty (Leighton U, #4)
Rate it:
Open Preview
Kindle Notes & Highlights
Read between October 6 - October 9, 2025
2%
Flag icon
But there’s another rivalry here today; a hatred still fresh and raw in my mind. The one I have with Madden Hastings. Who, as of last week, is my stepbrother.
2%
Flag icon
But as for who they are at their core? There’s only bad and worse. And as for the one I’m currently glaring at? Well, he’s on a level all his own.
2%
Flag icon
And it takes every bit of my self control not to flip Madden the bird from where I stand safely on second base.
3%
Flag icon
And while his shoulders rise and fall with his heavy breaths, there’s the briefest second where his gaze flashes from my eyes, down to my mouth, before lifting back up again.
3%
Flag icon
I do have a leg up on Cinderella with only one evil stepsibling instead of two.
8%
Flag icon
“If you think that’s going to last, you’re even more delusional than them, MadDog.”
8%
Flag icon
“Whatever you say, Teddy Bear.”
8%
Flag icon
“Don’t fucking call me that.” Ah, so he can dish it, but he can’t take it.
9%
Flag icon
Okay, sure. Objectively speaking, Madden is an attractive guy. He’s catnip for anyone who’s into the dark-haired, brooding, inked-up bad-boy type.
13%
Flag icon
Unfortunately, after I come out of the bathroom from brushing my teeth, I realize the one massive problem I’ve overlooked. One that’s impossible to ignore now that he’s stripped down to nothing more than a pair of tight-fitting boxer briefs. Theo Greyson is hot as hell.
han :)
giggling
13%
Flag icon
“Left or right?” “I’m a switch,” I reply instantly.
13%
Flag icon
He stifles a laugh, and when I glance up, he motions toward the bed. “I meant for sleeping, not in the batter’s box, Hastings.”
15%
Flag icon
I can feel my face growing hotter, not just from embarrassment at my mishap but from his pointed stare as he silently watches me.
han :)
Theo lowkey a dork omg
16%
Flag icon
At this distance, I can see his irises are more of a warm, rich brown when the sunlight hits them. I notice the slightest dotting of freckles on the bridge of his nose, giving him an air of innocence that doesn’t quite fit with the whole tattooed bad-boy vibe.
17%
Flag icon
I shift my attention away from the six-foot-two bane of my existence in favor of my show. Which works…for all of thirty seconds.
17%
Flag icon
I’ve been dragged into an episode of Madden’s World instead.
18%
Flag icon
What the hell is happening? Is he pulling up static electricity and sending it straight into me every time we accidentally make physical contact? Jesus Christ.
20%
Flag icon
“And who’s to say I’m not meeting someone too?”
20%
Flag icon
Madden glances at me briefly, his assessing gaze lingering on my face for a moment before he murmurs, “Have a nice time with your friends.”
han :)
I SCREECHED
21%
Flag icon
He studies me for a minute with the same penetrating stare his cousin possesses before murmuring, “Nice meeting you, Theo.” I have no idea how he knows my name, seeing as Madden hadn’t used it when he introduced me, but it doesn’t really matter.
21%
Flag icon
Unfortunately, Madden’s faster than me—and possibly a mind reader—grabbing my wrist before I can even take a step back toward Camden. His skin singes mine where it makes contact, and there’s an intensity in his gaze as he leans in a little closer. “Don’t worry, Theo. The only guy ending up in my bed tonight is you.”
22%
Flag icon
Cam turns to leave, then pauses and glances back over his shoulder. “You don’t happen to have AirTags, do you?” I know my face has to be showing every bit of confusion currently running through my head when I slowly reply, “Um. No, I don’t.”
han :)
HAHAHAHAHAH NICE WORK CAM
22%
Flag icon
“Trust me. I’d rather take on your residency at Mass Gen.”
han :)
Cassidy mention
25%
Flag icon
“Believe me, Madden, you haven’t seen me try taking it out on you.”
25%
Flag icon
“Play with fire, and you’re gonna get burned, Teddy Bear,” I utter, the warning coming out barely more than a gruff whisper. “Especially if you keep looking at me like that.”
25%
Flag icon
“I don’t need to read your mind, Theo. Not when your body is screaming.”
25%
Flag icon
I’m about to push away from him, to put some space between us again in hopes that this mixture of lust and frustration flooding my system might start to cool. If I don’t, there’s no telling if I’ll end up drowning in him or just fucking drowning him.
25%
Flag icon
But I don’t get the chance, because Theo’s hand lands on my forearm. And those emotions? Well, they boil over the second his lips crash into mine.
25%
Flag icon
I don’t know what caused me to snap, only that the second I do, I realize it’s the greatest mistake I’ve ever made. Because nothing—fucking nothing on this planet—could prepare me for kissing Madden.
25%
Flag icon
And the moment I give in? All sense of control falls directly into Madden’s hands.
25%
Flag icon
His fingers dig into my waist as he pulls me onto his lap, the harsh, sudden movement causing water to slosh over the edges of the tub.
26%
Flag icon
Madden releases my waist, one ink-covered hand sliding up my stomach before wrapping around my throat; not squeezing but gently guiding my head to a different angle with his thumb.
han :)
hhhhhwjat
26%
Flag icon
A tortured groan leaves Madden this time as the fingers of his free hand slide through my hair, knotting through the damp strands and pulling harshly.
26%
Flag icon
But doing so only earns a tightened grip and a whispered snarl. “Wanna tell me I’m full of shit again, Greyson?”
26%
Flag icon
“I hate that I want you,” I whisper, the words coming out in a snarl. His dark chuckle floats over my skin like satin. “About time we agreed on something.”
30%
Flag icon
Theo Greyson is in my bloodstream, whether I like it or not.
31%
Flag icon
Lexi Waters—the younger sister of the Sacramento Storm’s catcher, Keene.
han :)
queen
33%
Flag icon
“Why are you giving him a vivid recount of our first hookup?” “He asked!” “He asked how you felt, jackass.”
han :)
oak/quinn I love you both so much it hurts
34%
Flag icon
“Go?” he cuts in, arching a brow. “Why? You’re already here. You wanted to talk.” Pausing, he motions toward me. “Go ahead. Talk.”
han :)
idk why my clothes are off I love scary madden
34%
Flag icon
“I’m assuming this is about the part where you left me harder than granite in the hot tub and just disappeared into the ether?”
35%
Flag icon
Part of me is glad he’s finally starting to fray at the edges too. God knows I’ve been falling apart at the seams for a while now; it’s about time someone else joined the party.
35%
Flag icon
“What do you want, Theo?”
35%
Flag icon
“What do you—” “You!” I shout instantly. “Jesus fuck. It’s you, okay? I want you.”
35%
Flag icon
“Then what are you waiting for, Theo?” he asks in a gruff whisper. “I’m right here. So if that’s really what’s going on here, why aren’t you acting on it?”
35%
Flag icon
I’m almost certain he’s planning to tell me to fuck off or get lost. After the way I’ve been so hot and cold, he’d have every reason to. Except, he doesn’t. Instead, he wordlessly glances behind him to the front door, then opens it and drags me inside with him.
36%
Flag icon
“Fuck, I’m gonna have so much fun with you.”
38%
Flag icon
“You can. Some guys like—” “I don’t care about them, I wanna know how to make you feel good.”
han :)
omg ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️😋😋😋
41%
Flag icon
Theo: I can’t stop thinking about last night.
41%
Flag icon
I hate the way my pulse thrums as I read the text a few times, and I hate the little smile pulling at my lips even more. It’s almost…giddy.
44%
Flag icon
His smirk turns into a full-blown grin as he pulls the helmet on his head. “Look, I’m just saying, it’s okay if you need the extra practice. I won’t tell anyone.”
« Prev 1 3