More on this book
Community
Kindle Notes & Highlights
I eye the door longingly, and he quickly bisects my path before I can so much as even take a step. I glance to the door to Izzy’s room next to me, and the song abruptly cuts off. “I will tackle you to the floor.”
you, Izzy, Way, and me…it is what it is. It’s you three on one side, and me on the other.”
“Fuck, I know in a lot of ways it looks like it’s always been the three of us one side, and then you—” “Because it is.” “But there’s me and you too,” he argues back. “You know that, right?”
“Mason…” I push off the sink, taking a step. “You keep pushing me away.” My frown deepens, and I think, I have to. I have to push you away, because if I don’t… If I don’t…
“What about our friendship?” he says quietly. “What about us? Do I mean nothing to you?” You mean everything to me, and that’s the problem.
“You’re my best friend, Mason,” I whisper. My only friend, really. And if that isn’t just the saddest thing ever. “And you’re mine.”
“But you’ll always be hers first,” I whisper before I can help myself. “Theirs,” I quickly amend, turning around to face the sink. I clear my throat. “You’ll always be theirs first.”
“You are loved, Jeremy,” he says fiercely, the words wrenching from his chest. Glittering black orbs clash with mine, bright with unburied emotion. “You are so damn loved by so many people, and you just…you won’t let any of us in.”
“What did I do to make you shut me out? For years now, you’ve been…pulling away. Just tell me what I did.” You chose my sister.
He could never love me in the way I crave so desperately…not in this timeline. Not in this universe. Our stars are only ever meant to exist from opposite sides of the sun burning brightly forever between us.
“I’m not that kid in the song, okay?” I say raggedly, my words surprising us both. His eyes flare. “That’s not—” “I’m not history repeating itself. It’s not a prophecy. It’s just a song. That’s all it is. Stop putting expectations on me,” I plead. “Stop putting me into this narrative, where I lose.”
I love that song, I do, I love that it makes me think of him, us… But I also hate it for those very same reasons. Hate it for the image he so clearly has in his head of me. The poor bullied boy who’s headed down a path of destruction.
“You scare me sometimes.” Eyes burning, all I can do is stare back at him, biting my tongue like my life depends on it. And in a way, it does. Because he scares me too. He terrifies me.
“It’s not your fault. The bullying, your anxiety…it’s not your fault.” “From where I stand, it doesn’t make much of a difference. You’re all still over there,”—I gesture in his direction—“and I’m…” I wave a hand around my room. “I’m here.”
He’s got his gaze on the floor, like it has the answers. Solutions to impossible puzzles. And I’ve got my eyes on him, taking their fill while he’s not paying attention.
New York is you and Izzy and Waylon’s dream.” I press a hand to my chest. “Not mine.” Eyes creasing, he says, “What’s your dream then?” You. You’re my dream.
“Never again.” Something stutters in my chest. “For me.” I frown. “If you won’t stop for you, stop for me.” A rock of emotion lodges in my throat, and all I can do is nod.
If not for me, for him. Always for him. Because I might not be a hero like him, but he is and always has been my kryptonite.
I think of Jeremy…of what my life is going to look like next year, when it’s just Izzy and Waylon and me. How it’s always been…but also not.
And gay or straight, I don’t care, as long as he’s happy and whole and not bleeding from his wrists. Even if…even if that means he can’t be happy and whole here, with me. With us. In New York, living…living our dreams… He’ll be safe there. That’s what matters. Safe and happy.
It happens insidiously—the way the images in my head shift. Starting first with the eyes, and then the neck, and then the chest. Wrong, so wrong… But by the time I even think that, it’s already too late.
He’s beautiful. Try as I might to tear myself away, I can’t… Not when it hits me—really hits me—that this is all I’ll ever have of him. That this is the only way I can watch him, with my heart cracked open, and him no more the wiser to it. Because his heart’s too busy beating for someone else, so loud it drowns out anyone else’s. Drowns out mine. In a rhythm that was never meant for me.
It was never just my sister I had to compete with… I see that now more than ever. It’s his love for music. And both are so intrinsically tied, there’s no one without the other. I think of their matching tattoos, and as much as it kills me… I get it now. A Mason without Izzy is unfathomable… Because a Mason without music is unfathomable.
I watch the guy I’m pretty sure might be the love of my life…watch the love of his playing her actual...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
mine is locked on the falcon head handle topping his cane. It’s gaudy and pretentious as fuck.