Wuthering Heights in Classics Without All the Class

Dec 17, 2008 Russ rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: novel, historical, fantasy, favoritebooks, 2008

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. Wuthering Heights is the novel that taught me how good a 19th century English novel can be. It's not just tea time and romance - there's cruelty and violence in the wild moors of England.

I think I like it as much as I do because of the vivid images in my head of the characters and settings. Each time I read it, I'm taken back to that wild, foreign place. It is a place of little comfort, where the land is what one knows best. People, on the other hand, are much more difficult to deal with than a ...more

Like · see review

Jan 09, 2012 SarahC rated it really liked it

Shelves: challenge2012

I have spent some fascinating hours reading Wuthering Heights these past few weeks. It has been a more thorough read than in my earlier days when I think honestly I was more eager to get on with reading Jane Eyre, sister Charlotte’s novel. It may be one of the most studied works of literature and I see why because commenting on it here has not been easy. It is a book so easy to love but hard to completely understand. It is a blunt, deep examination of humans, written in the 1840s when that sort I have spent some fascinating hours reading Wuthering Heights these past few weeks. It has been a more thorough read than in my earlier days when I think honestly I was more eager to get on with reading Jane Eyre, sister Charlotte’s novel. It may be one of the most studied works of literature and I see why because commenting on it here has not been easy. It is a book so easy to love but hard to completely understand. It is a blunt, deep examination of humans, written in the 1840s when that sort of thing was not plentiful. The writing is beautiful - Emily Bronte may have written in a “private language” - I believed Charlotte Bronte stated -- but she had full command of that language and is able to bring the reader in to this page-turning world.

The characters are isolated, wicked, puzzling, conflicted, and revengeful. This is an undying love story, but more impressive to me is there is a sense of honesty and realism -- almost politics-- between Heathcliff and the elder Catherine. This doesn’t sound very romantic, but it clinched the story to me more than the strong emotional scenes of Heathcliff. This realism is present as Catherine confesses to Nelly why she will marry Edgar and in the confrontational discussion between Catherine and Heathcliff at Thrushcross Grange. I agree that Emily Bronte was a visionary in transitioning fiction writing toward realism.

The famous character Heathcliff is enigmatic. We will never know his origin and we are largely told his story through narrators. The narrator describes the revenge he attempts to carry out on the small collection of people he is adopted into, but we also see how these people contribute to the cruelty and madness that become his life. He is a violent, ruthless, frightening man, but carries on rational conversation with his only semi-ally, life-long member/servant of the household, Ellen Dean.

The rest of the family in the story become a part of perpetuated pain and anger and also loss common of the times. Through illness, the young children Hareton, Cathy, and Linton lose their mothers, causing them to become further victims of the wrongdoings and dysfunction of the joined families in the story. Thus Heathcliff lives to see some of his revenge but not his satisfaction on the outcome of this next generation of the family. Heathcliff’s own heart and strong hints of the supernatural take over to bring this unsentimental romantic story to a close.

Throughout the book we only ever see clues rather than facts of the story through Nelly (Ellen) as a narrator and Lockwood who records her narration and details his own detached part in the happenings. So we are left with more that we want to know and that we only will know through our own interpretation and imaginings

...more

3 likes · Like · see review

Jan 03, 2009 Ryan rated it liked it

I finally finished this book. It ended in a way that made me feel content. While there were some times when I was bored and was wising for the end, overall I enjoyed the story. I stuck with Heathcliff for the entire story and kept hoping that things would turn out where he would somehow get back in everyone's good graces. In my opinion, Emily Bronte made sure that happened, even though it wasn't the way we all would have liked and expected. ...more

Like · see review