Love and Other Consolation Prizes in Around the World in 80 Books

Jan 27, 2018 Rachel N. rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: friendship, read-in-2018, historical-fiction, romance, washington, prostitution, orphan, world-fair

Ernest Young is sent from China to the U.S. when he is five by his starving mother. Ernest is half white, his father was a missionary. Ernest is stuck in boarding schools until at age 12 he is raffled off at the Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition and ends up being a houseboy in a brothel. Ernest befriends Maisie, the owners daughter, and Fahn, an assistant to the cook. The book alternates between Ernest's childhood and 1962 when another World's Fair is occurring in Seattle.
I enjoyed Ernest's story ...more

5 likes · Like · see review

Oct 02, 2017 Lisa of Hopewell rated it really liked it

Shelves: read-in-2017, audio-books

Review:

The Story: Ernest is a young bi-racial Chinese boy of about 12 who is given away in a raffle at the 1909 Seattle World’s Fair. He is “won” by a “fancy” woman and enters the world of the red light district. Earnest’s story goes back-and-forth between 1909–1911 and 1962 when Seattle is again hosting a World’s Fair.
What I Loved: The writing of course! it’s Jamie Ford after all! I adored sweet, sweet Ernest. He was wonderful. And Professor True. I really liked him as well.
While this book is s Review:

The Story: Ernest is a young bi-racial Chinese boy of about 12 who is given away in a raffle at the 1909 Seattle World’s Fair. He is “won” by a “fancy” woman and enters the world of the red light district. Earnest’s story goes back-and-forth between 1909–1911 and 1962 when Seattle is again hosting a World’s Fair.
What I Loved: The writing of course! it’s Jamie Ford after all! I adored sweet, sweet Ernest. He was wonderful. And Professor True. I really liked him as well.
While this book is set in a “Sporting House” it does not contain graphic sex or graphic language. As I said, it is beautifully written.
What I Did Not Like: The story. I just didn’t like it much. The only character I really felt for was Ernest. I felt the others were cardboard and cliched. I sympathized with Masie and Fahn. The plight of girls and women in those days often left them no choice but to sell themselves in such places as the Tender Loin or worse.
I got really, Really, REALLY tired of being beaten over the head with the Big-Hearted Whore and the Frigid, Bigoted Christian Do-Gooder. We get it. Really. We get it. Funny, but even today a lot of folks don’t see prostitution in a romantic light. Whatever. That got so old, in fact, that I nearly quit reading. I’m glad I didn’t though. But, yes, I saw it coming a mile away that the “bad” woman would try to do “good” for the widows and orphans and the “Good, Christian Lady” would blow their cover and spoil it. What a cliche. That was really not worthy of such an outstanding story teller as Jamie Ford.
I also thought the reporter-daughter was a bit out-of-sync with her time. 1962 was very much the 1950s (I was born that year). It was not part of what we think of as the ’60s. It was conservative. (Oh, and Liquid Paper wasn’t on the market yet. I found a few other picky things that don’t impact the story. It wouldn’t work well on thin, onion skin paper anyway. I know. I’ve used both.)
Overall: That I didn’t like the subject of the story does not mean it isn’t an excellent book. I just do not find prostitution romantic, though I understand the difference between being well treated and viewed as valuable in a place like Madame Flora’s compared to being kept drug-addicted at the “other” sort of establishment. I love Jamie Ford’s writing though and am already anxiously looking forward to his next book.

Reading Notes:
In spite of not liking the story much, I LOVED Earnest and loved Jamie Ford's TELLING of the story--his writing is exquisite as always

Oh boy, let the cliches rain.... The Big-Heart-ed Whore vs the Frigid Christian.... oh my Review coming later this week.

Picky, Picky stuff.

"Comfort Food" became a thing in the 1980's, not 1962.
Liquid Paper wasn't available in 1962 and would work well on Onion skin paper anyway.... ...more

Like · see review