From the Bookshelf of Sci-fi and Heroic Fantasy…

Old Man's War (Old Man's War, #1)

John Scalzi

Start date: October 21, 2013

Finish date: November 20, 2013

Discussion: Book Discussions

Discussion leader: Christine McIntosh

Why we're reading this: Group Contemporary Novel Discussion October, 2013.
#1 on Locus Magazines Best SciFi novels of the 21th cen…more
[close] Group Contemporary Novel Discussion October, 2013.
#1 on Locus Magazines Best SciFi novels of the 21th century http://www.locusmag.com/2012/AllCentu...
#74 on NPR's Top 100 SF/F novels of all time (2011 poll) http://www.npr.org/2011/08/11/1390858...

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 250 topics — 8,801 comments total

Book Discussions

"Cyteen" by C.J. Cherryh
By deleted member · 48 posts · 103 views

last updated May 24, 2025 11:25PM

Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke
By deleted member · 46 posts · 150 views

last updated Mar 28, 2025 02:28PM

showing 10 of 36 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Oct 21, 2016 Rob Thompson rated it really liked it

Shelves: audio, reviewed, sci-fi, 2016-challenge

A SF classic or a superficial military SF?

For me it was more of the latter. Read on its own and not in the context of all the similar books that have proceeded it, this is a fun, military SF novel. The book is well written and entertaining.

The plot sees (view spoiler) A SF classic or a superficial military SF?

For me it was more of the latter. Read on its own and not in the context of all the similar books that have proceeded it, this is a fun, military SF novel. The book is well written and entertaining.

The plot sees (view spoiler)[John Perry, a 75-year-old retired advertising writer, joining the Colonial Defense Forces. They protect human interplanetary colonists. Volunteers sign letters of intent and provide DNA samples at age 65, which John and his now deceased wife Kathy had done ten years before the beginning of the story. After visiting his wife's grave to say goodbye (as volunteers can never return to Earth), Perry takes a space elevator to the CDF ship Henry Hudson, where he meets fellow male and female retiree volunteers who dub themselves the "Old Farts".

Following a series of sometimes bizarre psychological and physical tests, Perry's mind is transferred to a new body based on his genetic material. His new body is a younger version of himself, but genetically engineered with enhanced musculature, green skin, and yellow cat-like eyes. He now possesses enormous strength and dexterity,nanobot-enhanced artificial blood, enhanced eyesight and other senses, and a BrainPal—a neural interface that, among other capabilities, allows Perry to communicate with other members of the CDF via thought.

After a week of frivolity and orgies in their new bodies, Perry and the other recruits land on Beta Pyxis III for basic training, during which the CDF's heritage in the United States armed forces is made clear when the recruits are taught the Rifleman's Creed. After Perry learns that his drill instructor adopted one of his advertising slogans as a personalmantra, Perry is given the dubious job of platoon leader during the weeks of training before he is shipped out to the CDF ship Modesto. His first engagement is with the Consu, a fierce and intelligent, though zealous, alien species. Perry improvises a tactic which enables the CDF to win this first battle. This is followed by several battles with, among others, the bear-like Whaidians and the tiny Covandu. By the end of this last engagement Perry begins to suffer psychological distress over killing the Liliputian Covandu and accepts that he has transformed both physically and mentally.

Now a veteran, Perry participates in the Battle for Coral. The planet contains coral reefs valuable to the attacking Rraey, as well as a human colony (the Rraey also have a taste for human flesh). The CDF plans to counterattack with a force before the Rraey establish their coral strip mining operations, but the Rraey have somehow obtained technology to predict the appearance of a space ship's skip drive (a feat that should not be possible) and use this knowledge to ambush and destroy CDF ships as they arrive in the Coral system. Perry's quick thinking allows him and his fellow soldiers on a transport shuttle to escape the wreckage of the Modesto and make for the planet's surface, but they are shot down and Perry is the only survivor of the crash. Perry is left for dead by a Rraey search party (who find CDF soldiers inedible), but he is rescued by members of the mysterious "Ghost Brigades", the Special Forces units of the CDF. Perry thinks he has died when he sees a younger green version of his dead wife Kathy, who in reality is Jane Sagan, the leader of the Ghost Brigades rescue team.

After being repaired, Perry tracks down Sagan, who turns out to have been grown based on Kathy Perry's DNA sample, as legally allowed by her letter of intent to join the CDF. Unlike John, Jane has no memories of Kathy's life, as she is only six years old, but after learning about Kathy, Jane seeks to learn more from John about being a "realborn" person and what kind of life one can have outside the CDF.

Sagan manipulates her chain of command to promote John to an advisory role (as a lieutenant) to gather information from the Consu during a ritualistic meeting to get information. Perry discovers that the Rraey had received the skip-drive detection tachyon technology from the Consu, which was used to set up the ambush at Coral. Perry also manipulates his chain of command to have the last two of his friends from the "Old Farts" transferred out of combat duty to military research. Sagan and Perry then take part in a Special Forces operation in an attempt to capture or destroy the borrowed Consu technology in advance of a major attack to recapture Coral from the Rraey. Perry is instrumental in the successful outcome of the battle by capturing the technical manual for the Consu detection system (which was destroyed in the fighting), and saving Sagan's life after she is wounded. He never sees her again after delivering her to a shuttle which returns her to the secretive Ghost Brigades.

At the conclusion of the book, Perry is promoted to captain following his deeds at Coral and despite the separation, holds hope of reuniting with Sagan when their terms of service conclude." transferred out of combat duty to military research. Sagan and Perry then take part in a Special Forces operation in an attempt to capture or destroy the borrowed Consu technology in advance of a major attack to recapture Coral from the Rraey. Perry is instrumental in the successful outcome of the battle by capturing the technical manual for the Consu detection system (which was destroyed in the fighting), and saving Sagan's life after she is wounded. Yet, he never sees her again after delivering her to a shuttle which returns her to the secretive Ghost Brigades.

At the conclusion of the book, Perry is promoted to captain following his deeds at Coral and despite the separation, holds hope of reuniting with Sagan when their terms of service conclude. (hide spoiler)]

What is lacking is some inventive and new SF ideas. The novels that it draws from are in more original, more inventive and better. There is no real attempt to push out new ideas about how technology may impact on us in the future. Other writers have explored skip drives, nano tech cloning, splicing DNA before. If read as an military adventure novel, then its a gripping read. If you're looking for anything deeper then it'll disappoint you. ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Apr 24, 2015 J. rated it it was amazing

Really liked it, reminded me a lot of the starship troopers movie. But it has it's own tone to it. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Jan 04, 2016 Ash marked it as dnf

Shelves: science-fiction, to-re-read, space-aliens

I am planning to give this book another try since I liked Redshirts by this author.
-------------------
Jan 04, 2016:
I found this book to be boring. I read about 11% of it and finally lost patience. Maybe I am reading this when I am not in the mood to read paragraphs about alien technology or the author cannot make these paragraphs interesting. Either way, I have been putting this book down way too many times so it is better to just mark it abandoned until I feel like reading it again.

1 like · Like · see review

May 01, 2012 Mary rated it liked it

Shelves: read-since-joining-goodreads, have-ebook

I've already lost this review twice because GR was messed up. Maybe the third time will be, as they say, the charm.

This book is the first in a series of space opera/military sf. The story takes place hundreds of years in Earth's history and is told in first person narrative of John Perry a pretty nondescript 75 year old ex-advertising writer who becomes a new recruit for the Colonial Defense Forces (CDF). The CDF only take recruits over 75 and all new recruits are given a super, modified, young I've already lost this review twice because GR was messed up. Maybe the third time will be, as they say, the charm.

This book is the first in a series of space opera/military sf. The story takes place hundreds of years in Earth's history and is told in first person narrative of John Perry a pretty nondescript 75 year old ex-advertising writer who becomes a new recruit for the Colonial Defense Forces (CDF). The CDF only take recruits over 75 and all new recruits are given a super, modified, young, new body. Once they have done their time, usually 10 years, they are free to become colonists on another planet but they can never return to Earth. The CDF's job is to find and if necessary eradicate all alien life on these new planet colonies and then protect them from other intelligent alien races that are also looking for planets to colonize. (There is that word again...colonize. This story is very reminiscent of what I know of the slash and burn history and militarism of the British Colonial era.) There is almost no reasoning with other races, the only good alien is a dead alien. Pretty much all diplomacy and negotiation between the alien races has been stopped because the few times it has been tried, it has ended badly. (I found this premise a little to simple and a little sad.)

The beginning of the book started a little ho hum for me and the chapters describing when John first goes off world, becomes a recruit, meets his fellow recruits, finds out what it really means to be a CDF soldier, and gets his new body a bit silly. Mostly it is the conversations he has with his small group of 5 or 6 other recruits who become new friends (they affectionately call themselves "The Old Farts" club) that I find a bit banal. These were college professors, scientists and other former professionals and they are talking like giddy middle-schoolers on the first day of the new year at a new school. Maybe that was the author's intention but it didn't ring true to me.

Overall though, the story moved along well, was entertaining and well written and brought up some interesting new technological concepts like the skip drive, the BrainPals and smart blood. Every once in awhile Scalzi would start to touch on some of the tougher moral dilemmas and conflicts the characters experienced as a result of these perpetual wars but he never quite went deep enough for my taste. Consequently, the characters were a little lacking in depth. The end was the most interesting part and I probably will read at least one of the sequels to find out if and how the very unusual love story between Jane (the only character I really cared about) and John progressed. ...more

Like · see review

Jul 07, 2017 GONZA added it

Shelves: ebk, abbandonato

I tried to read this book because of the introduction of Scalzi to Haldeman's book (The forever war), but I found it I didn't like this one also, but for different reasons: I think that the humor was not to my liking at all, and the story was boring and the characters inconsistent. What it seems now clear to me is that I can stop reading sci-fi books, when I don't like them, much more easier compared to the other type of books, which I always tr to finish. ...more

Like · see review

Sep 03, 2013 Chris Massey rated it it was amazing

Fun read, reminiscent of Heinlein.

Reread, March 2015: Changing my review to five stars. It's only been a year or so since I read this but I find myself reading it again. Really great. ...more

Like · see review