Pretties (Uglies, #2) in Crazy Challenge Connection

Apr 11, 2012 Melissa (ladybug) rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: yearly-challenge, 4stars

I don't understand it, but I liked this book better than the first book. In this book, Tally has become "Prettie" and is as air headed as the rest. But, David and the Smokies have a plan to help her to find her brain again.

I found this book engrossing and easy to read. I loved Zane and found myself rooting for some of the characters. I felt bad for other characters such as Shay and the other Crims. I did have some problems though and these caused me to rate it as 3.5 stars. It would have easily ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Feb 22, 2011 A. S. rated it it was ok

As I entered puberty, I exited the YA section of the bookstore. I felt too grown up for what I deemed beach novels for girls with little gray matter. As an adult, I realized that I was cutting out a whole section of potentially good stories with this point of view. The problem is that as a (technically) young adult, I now know how to critique a story much better than before. Thus, from the get-go, I realized that Scott Westerfeld's second of four books in the Uglies series, Pretties, has some se As I entered puberty, I exited the YA section of the bookstore. I felt too grown up for what I deemed beach novels for girls with little gray matter. As an adult, I realized that I was cutting out a whole section of potentially good stories with this point of view. The problem is that as a (technically) young adult, I now know how to critique a story much better than before. Thus, from the get-go, I realized that Scott Westerfeld's second of four books in the Uglies series, Pretties, has some serious problems. The first is that Westerfeld, like most old people, cannot write natural-sounding teenage slang and dialogue for his life. The second is that the novel contains far too many recent YA genre tropes to make for a fresh story.

The first problem makes itself apparent by the first chapter. I understand that slang and names would have changed in a millennium (and that passage of time was not made clear in the first book), however there should at least be an explanation of some of the slang. The nicknames, for example: why the are the endings "-la" and "-wa" tacked onto the end of certain names? Also, I understand that the characters, once changed into Pretties, are supposed to be vapid creatures. However, the word "totally" suffers an abuse in Westerfeld's novel that only rivals Stephenie Meyer's flagrant misuse of "chagrin" in the Twilight books. Unfortunately, the words "bubbly" and "bogus" suffer an alarmingly similar degree of use. The writing style is jarring to the point of unreadable. I as of this point am seriously questioning why readers were extolling these books, because if I hadn't already gotten the rest of the books in the series, I wouldn't bother continuing.

The second reason I dislike this book is that the love-triangle deal I predicted would materialize in this book did so. While it's not Peris/Tally/David like I originally thought (it's Zane/Tally/David instead), its very existence irritates me. Why does a YA novel featuring a female main character always involve romance? Why is it always a love triangle (almost always two guys fighting over one girl)? If you have to include a romantic subplot, can't the protagonist know what she wants from the get-go so she can focus on the task at hand? Additionally, a large chunk of the plot really doesn't go anywhere--it's meaningless "action" sequences that could be cut out. Some parts were so boring I just skimmed over them, just like I did the "action" sequence in Twilight.

Unless the writing improves in the third book, I'm going to rage. ...more

Like · see review

Jul 23, 2009 Lori rated it really liked it

Shelves: own-print

This second book in the Uglies series was very good. I enjoyed it very much. And I have to admit that the ending was a little unexpected for me.

Like · see review

Jan 26, 2013 Rachel N. rated it liked it

Tally has become a pretty and is mainly concerned with becoming a member of the Crims clique. Then Croy from her Smoke days shows up and Tally begins remembering more of the past. Tally and her new boyfriend Zane get a potential cure to being pretty and try to break themselves and the other crims out of the city. Another slow start and another cliff hanger. I'm interested enough in the series to read the last one. ...more

Like · see review