From the Bookshelf of Ender's Jeesh…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

Well written as always, but the story didn't grab me this time. Too much Ta-Kumsaw, too little Alvin.
...more

Maybe the newness of the idea has simply worn off, but I didn't enjoy this second in the Alvin Maker series as much as I had the first. I still found the characters fascinating. And the plot of the history that might have been was pretty well-done, too. But the conceit of the place names, not quite the same as the actual place names, and of the people, not quite the same as the historical people with those names, wore pretty thin.
...more

Aug 12, 2011
Bert
marked it as to-read

Jan 28, 2013
Mina Henley
marked it as to-read

Mar 19, 2013
Paul
added it

Jun 24, 2013
Adrian Perez
added it

Feb 20, 2014
Ross
is currently reading it

Jan 02, 2015
Bob
marked it as to-read