From the Bookshelf of Fantasy Buddy Reads…

An Artificial Night (October Daye, #3)

Seanan McGuire

Start date: March 5, 2023

Finish date: March 19, 2023

Discussion: Archive [Retired Buddy Reads]

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 3059 topics — 137,579 comments total

Archive [Retired Buddy Reads]

Installment Immortality (InCryptid #14)[October 5, 2025]
By Yanique , Thread Master · 37 posts · 22 views

last updated Oct 02, 2025 11:09AM

Howling Dark (Sun Eater #2)[July 18, 2025]
By Yanique , Thread Master · 46 posts · 20 views

last updated Oct 01, 2025 12:48AM

showing 10 of 10 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Aug 10, 2015 Veronica rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: urban-fantasy

I'm enjoying Toby's adventures even more during this reread. This time it's a trip into some of the darkest parts of faerie, complete with the Wild Hunt and an insane Firstborn. I'm starting to think maybe Toby IS just a tad suicidal. And she can't see what's right in front of her where Tybalt is concerned. Oh well, who said heroes had to be perfect? ...more

6 likes · Like · see review

Apr 09, 2016 Susan rated it really liked it

Shelves: audiobook, fantasy, female-lead, mystery, contemporary, urban-fantasy

An Artificial Night by Seanan Mcguire Note: Even tho this is Book 3 in the series, it works mostly fine as a stand alone. Several side characters were introduced in the previous books but one can get the gist of the main character’s relationship to them without having read them.
In this installment of the series, changeling Toby is called upon by her friends to look into the case of several missing children. The children come from changeling households, non-fae parents, and the court of cats. She An Artificial Night by Seanan Mcguire Note: Even tho this is Book 3 in the series, it works mostly fine as a stand alone. Several side characters were introduced in the previous books but one can get the gist of the main character’s relationship to them without having read them.
In this installment of the series, changeling Toby is called upon by her friends to look into the case of several missing children. The children come from changeling households, non-fae parents, and the court of cats. She asks for info and advice from several quarters, but most sources are being quite vague. Eventually, she realizes the horror of the situation – Blind Michael has stolen the kids for the Wild Hunt! But that’s not all that Toby has to deal with – her own personal Fetch has turned up and Toby now knows she has a forthcoming expiration date.
This series has been good to me, providing hours of entertainment and this book doesn’t disappoint in that quarter. This book takes the series on a darker turn. Characters are irrevocably scarred by certain events. In general, it’s just a bit more serious and I found I enjoyed the higher stakes. There are still moments of humor, such as kids tossing things out of car windows and Toby’s Fetch, May Daye, is much more lighthearted than one would expect. So it’s not all doom and gloom – it’s well balanced.
The Wild Hunt and Blind Michael (who is a rather powerful First Born) are these two dark chaotic elements that really add to the tension of the tale. Blind Michael is bound by rules and Toby has to figure out what those rules are as no one is really willing to talk about the matter. There’s only so many ways to get into Blind Michael’s realm and she has to figure them out in order to rescue the children. Each path has it’s own risks.
There’s a bit of odd weirdness between Toby and Tybalt that becomes apparent right off the bat, and that was something that didn’t work for me because it’s not resolved in this book. I think (but am only hoping) the author is setting us up for something later in the series concerning these two characters, but even with that in mind, it just didn’t work well for me for this book. Their friendship has been off and on for the first two books and I’m starting to feel like the story is messing with me personally on this front. In fact, I was so frustrated with not knowing what was up with Tybalt in this book that I want to throw my hands in the air and say, ‘Call it quits or come clean you idiot!’.
Setting that criticism aside, Toby’s adventures in this tale had me on the edge of my seat. If I didn’t already know that this series is several more books in length, I would have truly worried for her continued existence. I was pleasantly surprised by her efforts, again and again, to rescue the kids from Blind Michael. Toby finally stops bemoaning the fact that she is a hero and accepts it. As the Wild Hunt can be unpredictable, there were plenty of little twists and turns I was not expecting in this story.
We learn plenty more about Luna and I especially liked this aspect. In the first two Books, it was mostly Toby who grew, but now the side characters are taking on more depth. The Luidaeg plays a big role and I continue to be a fan, albeit a very respectful one as I like all my body parts in their current arrangement. Quentin has to do some serious growing up in this book, and once again I had to worry if he was wearing the Red Shirt. Even Connor (aka Seal Boy) gets to be a bit more than he has in the past. Over all, this book was satisfying and I look forward to reading the next in the series.

The Narration: Mary Robinette Kowal has once again made a very good Toby Daye. I really liked how she pulled off this happier sounding Toby for the voice of the Fetch May. I could always tell the two apart because of how Kowal gave Toby her normal moody inflections and how she made May sound a bit bubblier. She did great with crazy Blind Michael and all the kids in his court. I continue to enjoy her harsh Luidaeg voice. ...more

Like · see review

Dec 01, 2016 Karen ⚜Mess⚜ rated it it was amazing

Shelves: favorites

October Daye is one of my all time favorite fae books. It's fae done right. Filled with lore and wonderful characters. Plenty of action and story to tell. ...more

Like · see review