From the Bookshelf of Vampires, Weres and Fae! …
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

#0.1 The Demon in the Wood ★★★★★
#1 Shadow and Bone ★★★☆☆
#1.5 The Tailor ★★★★★
#2 Siege and Storm ★★★☆☆
#3 Ruin and Rising ★★★★☆
First we had to find the firebird. Until then, all our hopes rested on the shoulders of one untrustworthy prince.
If you’ve read my review for Shadow and Bone (especially if you read my reread update that was recently added), you already know that I have some very ambivalent feelings towards this series. When I first started it, I loved it, but by the time I reread it, I h ...more

2.5 stars + 0.5 stars just for Nikolai = 3 stars
Parts of this I liked better than the first book, parts of it I liked less. I mostly had issues with Mal and also some with Alina. The romance in this series really is a mess. On occasion, I still felt sympathetic towards the two of them, but for the majority of the time I just found them irritating - much more so than in Shadow & Bone. When Alina was away from Mal though, she also had some moments of greatness. She really started to grow into her ...more
Parts of this I liked better than the first book, parts of it I liked less. I mostly had issues with Mal and also some with Alina. The romance in this series really is a mess. On occasion, I still felt sympathetic towards the two of them, but for the majority of the time I just found them irritating - much more so than in Shadow & Bone. When Alina was away from Mal though, she also had some moments of greatness. She really started to grow into her ...more

Kinda blown away by that ending. There are quite a few twists I REALLY didn't see coming and I truly appreciated that.
I'm a bit bummed about the romance aspect which seems to go around in circles...
Also, Alina says she can bring the capitol city down yet, I see no evidence supporting that. Everyone is like 'oh she's so powerful!!' and I'm reading while thinking '...in what way??'. I don't see how she is powerful especially since they have to keep making her new mirrors or contraptions in order ...more
I'm a bit bummed about the romance aspect which seems to go around in circles...
Also, Alina says she can bring the capitol city down yet, I see no evidence supporting that. Everyone is like 'oh she's so powerful!!' and I'm reading while thinking '...in what way??'. I don't see how she is powerful especially since they have to keep making her new mirrors or contraptions in order ...more

Sep 16, 2015
Maya
marked it as to-read

Mar 22, 2016
Marie-claude
marked it as to-read


Aug 16, 2016
TK
added it

Oct 06, 2016
✎Stacey "The One Night Biter"
marked it as to-read

Dec 31, 2016
Katory
marked it as to-read

Mar 11, 2018
Cheyenne
marked it as to-read


Oct 16, 2019
Yvonne
marked it as to-read

Dec 03, 2020
Bran Pendergrass
marked it as dnf-omg-such-a-let-down

Jan 28, 2021
Kelly
marked it as to-read