From the Bookshelf of Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge…

North and South

Elizabeth Gaskell

Start date: December 4, 2015

Finish date: December 6, 2015

Discussion: 2015 Challenge Prompts

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 51 topics — 2,511 comments total

2015 Challenge Prompts

Prompt 25: A book you were supposed to read in school but didn't
By Ann · 67 posts · 992 views

last updated Jan 17, 2023 03:51PM

Prompt 39: A book with magic
By Ann · 48 posts · 446 views

last updated Jan 02, 2019 05:46AM

What Members Thought

Jan 08, 2022 Ketutar Jensen rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Such whiny people.

Very unsatisfactory, because I find the hero pretty unlikable. How much would it have cost him to give the "hands" a raise? But, sure, he got married to a rich heiress, and didn't need to... uh.
What ever.

Elizabeth Gaskell is a good author, but I dislike this book rather much.

It starts with a selfish man dragging his family away from their home to this dirty, sad industrial town in North, and then whining rest of his life because of the consequences.
His wife was terminally il Such whiny people.

Very unsatisfactory, because I find the hero pretty unlikable. How much would it have cost him to give the "hands" a raise? But, sure, he got married to a rich heiress, and didn't need to... uh.
What ever.

Elizabeth Gaskell is a good author, but I dislike this book rather much.

It starts with a selfish man dragging his family away from their home to this dirty, sad industrial town in North, and then whining rest of his life because of the consequences.
His wife was terminally ill, and chose to not discuss with anyone (either), so when her family finds out, it's a terrific blow.
The father of the family expects his 18 years old daughter to deliver all bad news to his wife, and the mother makes the daughter responsible for the father's peace of mind. So when the mother dies, the daughter cannot mourn, because she has to take care of the father. Who, of course, mourns with all the emotional flagellations and excuses one can expect.
And, servants don't have any feelings, so we don't need to care one bit about the mother's maid, who loved her probably more than her husband and daughter. But, as servants don't have any feelings, it's totally fine to expect her to keep working without a hitch as if nothing had happened.
Also, for some weird reason, the couple had send their daughter to live and be raised by the mother's sister in London. So, when the father goes and dies at the old age of 55, the aunt comes and takes the girl back to London, where she is being treated as her cousin's companion.
The cousin is newly wed and has a son, and Margaret becomes the boy's nanny. Her cousin seems to be a total airhead who doesn't do anything.
So - next dies Mr. Bell who is a rich man who left his fortune to Margaret, and - of course - the London family decides she should marry her cousin's husband's brother, who is in love with her, to keep her close by as the cousin's companion, the boy's nanny, and to keep the money in the family.
But, Margaret has gone and fallen in love with what ever f his name is, the conservative a-hole mill owner, in the proper Pride and Prejudice manner (he asks her to marry her, she refuses, and then spends rest of the book being ashamed of how she did it, and Elizabeth Gaskell even invented a smaller scandal the guy can save Margaret from, to add more burning coals over her head, and make her "understand" what a swell guy he really is, even though the first impressions told differently.)
Frankly, I don't believe in that love, or the happiness of the marriage. The hero's basic values are very much against the heroine's basic values, his mother hates her, and there is a history of miscommunications, misunderstandings, and carrying a grudge.
Urgh. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Feb 02, 2025 Isabel Jazmín rated it really liked it · review of another edition

En esta novela conocemos a Margaret Hale, una chica que siempre ha vivido en Londres, en el norte y por azares del destino, debe mudarse junto con su familia al sur, de regreso al pueblo de su familia. Este contraste entre lo que vivió y a lo que se enfrenta, la autora lo utiliza como un pretexto para presentar lo prejuicios de la época de lo que se consideraba aceptable y no.

Lo que más me sorprendió es la variedad de temas que se abordan, no solamente desde la perspectiva de Margaret sino tambi ...more

Like · see review

Jun 03, 2017 Amy marked it as to-read · review of another edition

Feb 15, 2019 Joan rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: connect-with-the-classics

Mar 27, 2022 Kaitlyn marked it as to-read · review of another edition

« previous 1 2 3 4 next »

Group Home Bookshelf Discussions

Photos Videos

Send invite Members Polls