The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake in Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge

Sep 14, 2010 jess rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fiction, food, ladyish, 2010

When this book starts, Rose is a nine year old girl. She has a mother who is alternately distracted and devoted, a father who's going through the motions, and an older brother, Joseph, who would be hard pressed to care less about Rose. At dinner one night, Rose discovers she can taste something strange in the food her mother has made. She can taste the feelings of the person who made the food - not just her mother, but anyone who makes food that Rose eats. Her mother's horrifying emptiness and e When this book starts, Rose is a nine year old girl. She has a mother who is alternately distracted and devoted, a father who's going through the motions, and an older brother, Joseph, who would be hard pressed to care less about Rose. At dinner one night, Rose discovers she can taste something strange in the food her mother has made. She can taste the feelings of the person who made the food - not just her mother, but anyone who makes food that Rose eats. Her mother's horrifying emptiness and echoing loneliness make Rose's taste buds revolt. To survive the intensity of the feelings/flavors, Rose turns to factory-made food.The concept is a little like Como Agua Para Chocolate in that the magic comes from tasting emotions, but Lemon Cake is much whiter, more contemporary, more suburban, less sexy, and just different.

Rose grows up, her family changes, she becomes an adult, she makes sense of her world even though it is often painful and strange. Whose world isn't often painful and strange?

Poor Joseph is a big loner nerd with only one friend - George - a charismatic, brilliant guy who takes time (much to Joseph's dismay) to listen to Rose and help her navigate the early days of the tasty feelings. George becomes a major player in Rose's life. Their relationship is built on patience and familiarity, but it's cemented by their shared loss. I thought George turned out to be a bit of a disappointment but it felt authentic when Rose caught a red-eye to go to his wedding, to dance with him and meet his redhead bride. Rose's mom was such a wild spirit and weird person. I felt very strongly (almost all at once) that she needed to be free like a wild bird and also redouble her commitment to her family. And the obsession with carpentry -- I know it's partly a referential thing to all the other stuff going on (making things, crafting, seeking love, providing, etc) but seriously, the mom is a carpenter wtf. Also, I loved Rose's dad. He was a subtle guy, but his nuances were endearing even if the idea of being his daughter makes me cringe.

The discussion of eating disorders in young girls was fascinating -- I mean, the school nurse asks Rose if she thinks she is fat, and why she isn't eating, and when she gives a crazy answer (e.g. because the food tastes empty), it's all brushed under the rug. That was real. Since I've read this book, I have felt a lot more self-conscious about my feelings while I'm making food for people. In the off-chance that someone like Rose crosses my path, I want to leave out the hurried distractedness, the self-imposed unreachable standards and all the stress when I cook. Also -- the way that random magical skills are a genetic probability, and Bender crafts these obscure manifestions of "magical power" -- this made the book seem plausible in a way that no book about a little girl tasting feelings should ever seem.

Lemon Cake is as much coming-of-age as it is a food book. At the end, having waded through metaphors and suspended disbelief for nearly 300 pages, I found myself thumbing through very slowly. It was hard for me to finish. Not because I knew what would happen, but because there was no way that Aimee Bender could fuck it up and I never wanted it to end. Toward the end, the least developed and most glorious characters are introduced - Madame & Monsieur, with their restaurant, and their glorious, honest, sincere, wonderful food and they way they appreciated Rose without questioning or deriding her. I love them. I want them to adopt me and feed me organic lettuce and appreciate my own special talents, even though I may not have any.

The moment when Rose eats the sandwich at the bakery with George, and she tastes all the desperate love and longing that some guy's girlfriend felt when she made the sandwich -- that was beautiful. All that shit about Grandma's packages and folding chairs, though.... that was overreaching the weird factor. It was almost too much, but Joseph brought it home again and kept it relevant. I would very much like to re-read this book in 2 or 3 years and see how I feel about it then. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Aug 09, 2010 Gina rated it really liked it

Shelves: fiction

Obscure, sad, beautifully written; I loved this book. The story of Rose who is cursed with the ability to taste the emotions of whomever has prepared her food--every ingredient. Beginning with her mother, she has to taste her mother's dissatisfaction in her marriage and subsequent affair (and guilt) that follows. Her character is most interesting, especially how she develops and learns to deal with her abilities. The book takes a bit of a strange turn when it focuses on her brilliant but strange ...more

Like · see review

Dec 07, 2011 Mandy rated it it was ok

I think this was a good idea but the author got lost along the way. I loved the idea of being able to taste people's feelings but I'm not sure the author knew exactly what to do with this little gem and suddenly you have a story of a family but with very little coherence and actual plot. I finished the book because it was an easy read but honestly, I don't think anything actually happened per se and I was left very disappointed.

Good idea, poor execution. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Apr 26, 2011 Megan rated it it was amazing

Shelves: contemporary, american-stories, favorites, goodreads-firstreads-giveaways, great-now-i-am-hungry-fiction

I borrowed my Mom's FirstReads copy of this book and am so glad I did! This book reminded me of the magic realism Latin American authors I've read and loved in the past. It was inventive and so different from many of the books I've read recently. The story centers on Rose who discovers one year on her birthday that she can taste the feelings of people through the foods that they cook. She doesn't reveal her abilities at first, not sure how others will react. Over the course of the book, her fami ...more

Like · see review

Jun 18, 2011 Gabrielle S rated it it was ok

Okay I didn't really like this. I thought the premise was really intriguing but it fell flat in the execution. I still have no idea what really went on with her bother either. Disappointing. ...more

Like · see review

Nov 05, 2010 Amy Ellis rated it it was ok

This book was kind of weird but had an interesting plot--a girl who can taste the emotions of the cooks of her food. The family is kind of messed up, though.

Like · see review