From the Bookshelf of Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

This was a DNF for me back in 2014, and for some reason, I felt called to give it another chance. I’m very glad I did.
As a person who constantly wishes for do-overs on some life events, this spoke to me on a cellular level. I was deeply confused by the ending, but apparently, I’m not alone. Perhaps A God in Ruins will answer some questions.
As a person who constantly wishes for do-overs on some life events, this spoke to me on a cellular level. I was deeply confused by the ending, but apparently, I’m not alone. Perhaps A God in Ruins will answer some questions.

The conceit of the book is that Ursula continues to be reborn (Groundhog Day-style) into the same life, but slight differences change the outcomes. She has vague deja vu memories of previous incarnations, but not perfect recollection (i.e., not quite like Groundhog Day). The writing was quite lyrical and managed to both be the most evocative descriptions of the London blitz that I've read but also witty and quirky characters. I loved the way the stories fit together and the author managed to mak
...more

I really enjoyed this book. It took me 20 pages to get into the ebb and flow of the different lives, but I liked the subtext commentary on "fate" and how individual choices and moments can change our trajectories significantly.
Popsugar Reading Challenge - A book with an upside-down image on the cover ...more
Popsugar Reading Challenge - A book with an upside-down image on the cover ...more

All of the reviews for this book were excellent and people keep talking about how amazing it is. Maybe I'm missing something, because I did NOT feel the same way. The concept intrigued me - the main character dying and getting to relive her life again and again. The actual book did not intrigue me. I felt it was dense and boring at times. The concept was also very vaguely developed and was sometimes hard to follow. There was a lot of development of Ursula's character and yet I never felt that I
...more

I loved this book. The idea that one small thing can change the outcome of your life is what is addressed here. How long Ursula lives and what her experiences are depend on certain incidents. Sometimes this means she doesn't survive childhood but she is always born again. Later on as her lives progress she sometimes remembers snippets of her past lives.
This is one of those books I was sad to leave. ...more
This is one of those books I was sad to leave. ...more

I loved the concept of this book, that Ursula Todd lives her life over and over again, giving her opportunity to right the wrongs that eventually lead to her death each time. Early on, she has little control, as she dies at birth and as a young child, but as her awareness grows, she gets feelings of foreboding when she approaches the scenes of her previous deaths. Born in England in 1910, Ursula lives through both World Wars, plus the aftermath of each, and readers are taken along on the various
...more

This book lost me 348 pages in! Ack! I couldn't finish it, because I didn't like the turn it took. The premise is interesting, though...a girl who gets reborn over and over but only has a little déjà vu. Good writing but rambling.
...more

Jan 11, 2015
Beth Given
marked it as shelved
Such an interesting premise for a story, and SO well executed, too!
But.
The whole thing had kind of a dark, melancholy tone that just didn't sit well with me. About halfway through, there was a rape, then some grisly violence (both domestic and war-related), then quite a bit of casual infidelity. The last straw was a string of four or five f-bombs, 80 or 90% of the way into the book -- there hadn't been a whole lot of swearing up until that point so this kind of shocked me, I guess. So even thoug ...more
But.
The whole thing had kind of a dark, melancholy tone that just didn't sit well with me. About halfway through, there was a rape, then some grisly violence (both domestic and war-related), then quite a bit of casual infidelity. The last straw was a string of four or five f-bombs, 80 or 90% of the way into the book -- there hadn't been a whole lot of swearing up until that point so this kind of shocked me, I guess. So even thoug ...more

Dec 07, 2013
Leslie
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
audio-books,
2015-reads
This is one of those books that raises more questions than it answers, though that's not a bad thing. Trying to puzzle it out leaves me thinking about it for much longer than if it had handed me the answers. I enjoy it when "literary" authors play with sci-fi-esque concepts, but sometimes it can get frustrating because more literary novels often don't really establish rules in the way that a pure sci fi novel would. I kept trying to apply an internal logic to Ursula's experience, but I finally h
...more

Apr 07, 2013
Gina
added it

Jul 16, 2013
Joanna Hennon
added it

Dec 03, 2013
Ashley
marked it as to-read

Dec 19, 2013
Larissa
marked it as to-read

Jan 23, 2014
Yusra Asaad
marked it as to-read

Jan 25, 2014
Terina
marked it as to-read

Mar 25, 2015
Jen (NerdifiedJen)
marked it as to-read

Jun 03, 2015
Erin
marked it as to-read