From the Bookshelf of Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

I like John Green and I very much like David Levithan. This was a cute collaboration between them, though I would bet they essentially each wrote the chapters for one of the Wills. will (no caps) was quite depressed and rather depressing, which depressed me. I didn't think his chapters had enough...something to them. I felt for him, but I didn't quite believe him. Surprising since will was most likely David's creation. While Will (caps) wasn't completely believable to me either, his supporting c
...more

Like all of John Green's other books, this one was richly funny, while tackling serious social issues. It was so important that multiple key characters in the book were gay; the bullying and suicide of GLBTQ teens is high school issue that Green both had a responsibility to which to lend his very popular name, and it is also an issue that my own book club has discussed. I loved everything about Tiny Cooper (I kept picturing him as Omar Benson Miller, which also helped me love him). However, the
...more

I really loved seeing two sides to this story. I had a clear preference for a Will Grayson/writing style, but I still really enjoyed it as a whole. Tiny was practically sprung from a Steve Kluger novel (which is to
say, I loved him). The end was over the top, but I was so sucked in that I
didn't care. It was kind of like the Glee finale. The emotion transcended
the melodrama. ...more
say, I loved him). The end was over the top, but I was so sucked in that I
didn't care. It was kind of like the Glee finale. The emotion transcended
the melodrama. ...more

I really liked it and thought it was funny and perfectly high school angst-y, but it was also set in my neighborhoods (Frenchy's is half a block away from my office and I walk past it at least twice a day, and I live on the far north side of Chicago, so Evanston is a little over a mile away), so I think that added to its charm and appeal.
...more

Dec 02, 2010
Janine
marked it as to-read

Jan 04, 2014
Samantha
marked it as to-read

Jul 28, 2014
Arianna
marked it as to-read


Feb 13, 2015
Nicole Adrienne
marked it as to-read

Apr 16, 2015
Jeanne Bufkin
marked it as to-read