From the Bookshelf of taylor swift songs and reading at centennial park <3 …
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

OH MY GOD WHAT JUST HAPPENED. 4.7/5
the book was SO SO SO SO GOOD it just didn't have me so extremely hooked after every few chapters which i know is a lot to have for a mystery book standard, but if im not constantly wanting to read it (for any book really) i wont have the motivation until i force myself to like i did today at midnight, LMFAO so it took me a while to read but it was worth it.
spoilers below!!!!
im scared for Pip in book 3, like our poor baby just witnessed a murder????
also..... C ...more
the book was SO SO SO SO GOOD it just didn't have me so extremely hooked after every few chapters which i know is a lot to have for a mystery book standard, but if im not constantly wanting to read it (for any book really) i wont have the motivation until i force myself to like i did today at midnight, LMFAO so it took me a while to read but it was worth it.
spoilers below!!!!
im scared for Pip in book 3, like our poor baby just witnessed a murder????
also..... C ...more

Jan 01, 2023
Cassidy (Kenji Kishimoto’s Version)
rated it
it was amazing
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
favorites,
spooky-books
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ STARS!!
Playlist I made for the book: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1hy...
"Maybe I don't have to be good, or other's people's versions of good. And maybe I don't have to be likeable. fuck likeable."
This. Book. Is. A. Masterpiece. I love love love love this. Holly Jackson is officially a must read author. Anything she writes I will read.
Characters: ✔
Plot: ✔
Relationships: ✔
Themes: ✔
"A serial rapist walked free today. Jamie has been missing for six whole days and might be dead. Oh, but t ...more
Playlist I made for the book: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1hy...
"Maybe I don't have to be good, or other's people's versions of good. And maybe I don't have to be likeable. fuck likeable."
This. Book. Is. A. Masterpiece. I love love love love this. Holly Jackson is officially a must read author. Anything she writes I will read.
Characters: ✔
Plot: ✔
Relationships: ✔
Themes: ✔
"A serial rapist walked free today. Jamie has been missing for six whole days and might be dead. Oh, but t ...more

Mystery books are not supposed to be sad. They're not supposed to leave you in tears. Just No.
...more

I DONT KNOW WHAT SOME OF YOU GUYS ARE REAADING WHEN YOU GIVE THIS BOOKLIKE TWO STARS BUT THIS WAS BY FAR MY FAVORITE OF THE YEAR SO FAR
like oh
my
gosh
this was one of the best YA mysteries ive read yet (i havent read one of us is lying yet but that one also seems pretty popular)
i dont have time to write a review rn but i will BE BACK LATER
like oh
my
gosh
this was one of the best YA mysteries ive read yet (i havent read one of us is lying yet but that one also seems pretty popular)
i dont have time to write a review rn but i will BE BACK LATER

4.5 ⭐️
i have never ever cried for a character i barely know, until now. i’ve heard the next book won’t be much happier than this one, looking forward to it :D and please Holly Jackson, give Pip a break
(the only reason i’ve given this book 4.5 stars is because it was quite slow in the beginning and a bit hard to get into but fck did that change not even halfway through)
i have never ever cried for a character i barely know, until now. i’ve heard the next book won’t be much happier than this one, looking forward to it :D and please Holly Jackson, give Pip a break
(the only reason i’ve given this book 4.5 stars is because it was quite slow in the beginning and a bit hard to get into but fck did that change not even halfway through)

wow.
This book is one of those books that immerses you so much that you feel like you ARE the main character. Throughout this book, and its prior, I WAS Pip. (So much so that I’m borderline having a panic attack right now due to what happened to her)
IM SO EXCITED FOR THE TV SHOW. Emma Myers is SO perfect for Pip and I pictured her face throughout this whole book!! Also can’t want to associate my undying love for Ravi with a face as well. Seriously. Where can I find a Ravi??
This book is one of those books that immerses you so much that you feel like you ARE the main character. Throughout this book, and its prior, I WAS Pip. (So much so that I’m borderline having a panic attack right now due to what happened to her)
IM SO EXCITED FOR THE TV SHOW. Emma Myers is SO perfect for Pip and I pictured her face throughout this whole book!! Also can’t want to associate my undying love for Ravi with a face as well. Seriously. Where can I find a Ravi??

Apr 03, 2022
rose ୨୧
marked it as to-read

Apr 08, 2022
Zoe ➳ (Taylor's Version)
marked it as to-read

Aug 23, 2022
Katelyn Dracup
added it

Aug 21, 2023
addi
marked it as to-read