The Bear and the Nightingale (The Winternight Trilogy, #1) in /r/Fantasy Discussion Group

May 30, 2018 Ashley rated it really liked it

Shelves: historical-fiction, i-do-believe-in-fairies-i-do-i-do, fantasy, bildungsroman, read-harder-challenge-2018

This was not quite what I was expecting. I think I was expecting something more along the lines of Naomi Novik's Uprooted, because people have compared them endlessly, but aside from taking inspiration from Russian folklore, the two books don't have very much in common. Uprooted is a fairytale, albeit one that is lengthened and deepened. The Bear and the Nightingale is a historical fantasy that is historical fiction first, fantasy second.

This book takes place in medieval Russia, then called Rus' This was not quite what I was expecting. I think I was expecting something more along the lines of Naomi Novik's Uprooted, because people have compared them endlessly, but aside from taking inspiration from Russian folklore, the two books don't have very much in common. Uprooted is a fairytale, albeit one that is lengthened and deepened. The Bear and the Nightingale is a historical fantasy that is historical fiction first, fantasy second.

This book takes place in medieval Russia, then called Rus'. The daughter of the prince of Moscow is married off to a rural boyar (Russian aristocracy) because her mother was a witch, and they want her away and forgotten about. Marina and Pyotr are happy and have four children, three boys and a girl. But Marina wants a fifth child, a girl who will be like her mother was, and knowing that she will die in childbirth, goes through with the pregnancy anyway. The result is Vasilisa Petrovna, a homely and gangly girl who makes everyone uncomfortable. They call her "little frog" when she is small. She is wild and willful. When she is six, her father travels to Moscow to find a wife who can take care of her, hoping to control or tame her somehow. What he brings home is an unwilling gift from the prince, a woman who sees demons and whose only wish is to go into a convent. Instead, she is forced to marry Pyotr and live in the wilderness. There are demons everywhere, and her youngest stepchild seems to be in collusion with them.

I saw a couple of reviewers describe this as a slow burn fantasy, and I think that's accurate. We are really immersed in the atmosphere of daily life in rural Rus'. We watch Vasya grow up, we get to know her siblings and her nurse and her father, and even her stepmother. We are steeped in their culture and beliefs, just in time for an outsider to come in and change everything, for the worse. It's hard to point to one specific plot point here and explain what was so enjoyable to read. It's a lot of small details adding up over time. But in the end it's Vasya's differences that enable her to save the day, her strong personality and self-knowledge, and her courage.

I will most definitely be reading the rest of this series.

Read Harder Challenge 2018: A book set in or about one of the five BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China, or South Africa). ...more

27 likes · Like · see review

Feb 04, 2019 Ketutar Jensen rated it it was amazing

I liked it a lot.

There were certain parts I would have done differently... for example, it would have been better if the household had taught Anna what the house spirits were and how to honor them... but then the book would not have been the same.

2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 30, 2023 Lulu rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: fantasy, books-read-in-2023

This was a gorgeous saga set in the frigid cold of Russia, and following the life of a young girl imbued with a destiny. I love how languidly it all moved, the stories, the fairytales, the ways Vasya interacted with the world etc. And I loved, loved, loved our minor antagonist, Konstantin. He is exactly the kind of terrible little man that I enjoy most.

Vasya is also a great protagonist; she is fighty and flighty, stubborn but kind. I am excited to follow her adventures in the next book.

2 likes · Like · see review

Feb 13, 2017 Mackay rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: historical-fiction, fantasy, mythology-folklore

A lovely tale, rooted in Russian folklore and fairy tale-tropes, but also grounded in a deep understanding of medieval Russian culture. Beautifully realized; Vasya, our heroine, is a great character, as are many of the supporting cast, including the household spirits and especially the horses. Reading it gave me the feel of being curled up snug by the fire while a winter storm blows outside, with a hot cup of tea or a glass of mulled wine. Terrors and beauties here - wonderful.

Like · see review

Jul 20, 2017 Alethea added it

DNF. No fault of the book, which was actually quite lovely, but the villain grated on my nerves enough that I was putting off listening to the rest...for months...

Like · see review