From the Bookshelf of /r/Fantasy Discussion Group…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

I've been on the lookout for epic fantasy that isn't rapey and grimdark, and this series was recommended to me.
It reads like Sullivan took his favorite elements of recent fantasy (Tolkien's elves, long lives, with long names), dwarves, added goblins instead of orcs, and of course the bog-standard Evil Church, the protagonists thief buddies, but put all these standard elements together into an entertaining story.
I do wish he'd had a better editor, but on the other hand, it seems like it's sold by ...more
It reads like Sullivan took his favorite elements of recent fantasy (Tolkien's elves, long lives, with long names), dwarves, added goblins instead of orcs, and of course the bog-standard Evil Church, the protagonists thief buddies, but put all these standard elements together into an entertaining story.
I do wish he'd had a better editor, but on the other hand, it seems like it's sold by ...more

This book was a lot of fun -- adventure, intrigue, elves, all the stuff you want in epic fantasy. The weakest bit is that in these opening books I can't really tell the two main characters apart, but I hope this gets more developed.
...more

This wasn't a bad book, but I found it a bit too simplistic/generic. It reminded me a lot of books that I read and loved in the '90s, but I guess I'm looking for more now. If you are tired of gritty realism, nostalgic for the fantasy of the early '90s, or looking for something for a younger reader, this might be a good series to check out.
...more


Jun 06, 2012
Jennifer
marked it as to-read

Jul 19, 2012
forestsprite
marked it as to-read

Jan 28, 2013
Michael Underwood
marked it as to-read

Feb 16, 2014
Beth Tabler
marked it as to-read

May 22, 2014
Patrick Ahern
is currently reading it

Apr 29, 2016
Suncani
marked it as not-for-me

Jun 21, 2016
Hot Pink Mess
added it

Jul 03, 2017
Bassim Abbassi
marked it as to-read

Apr 19, 2018
Val
marked it as to-read

Jan 30, 2019
Brian
marked it as to-read


Jun 08, 2019
Eileen Johnson
added it