Chris’s
Comments
(group member since Feb 25, 2011)
Chris’s
comments
from the Beyond Reality group.
Showing 421-440 of 934


Like many of McKillip's stories, it is dreamlike and misty, with not every loose end tied up. We enter the world of the story, inhabit it for a while, then step back out again wanting a bit more.

The most interesting to me was the way society as a whole dealt with immortality and material sufficiency, and how it affected the urge to explore. I am not sure I agree that this would necessarily be true. But I was happy to see our band of immortals still curious, still looking outward at the end.

Books of the Month - For January you selected:
-- Science Fiction: The Boat of a Million Years by Poul Anderson
-- Fantasy: Ombria in Shadow by Patricia A. McKillip
We also have our schedule set for the next two months:
-- February Science Fiction: Inversions by Iain M. Banks
-- February Fantasy: The Grace of Kings by Ken Liu
— March Science Fiction Sea of Rust by C. Robert Cargill
— March Fantasy: Song of the Beast by Carol Berg
Series news: We are currently discussing book 3 of the Daevabad Trilogy, The Empire of Gold. Information about our next series read will be sent separately.
Lastly, don't forget to stop by the "What are you reading in January 2022?" topic to share your reading picks, progress, and thoughts on any genre.



If intersystem politics may be too much for humans to manage (as we saw in earlier books), interstellar politics doesn't make things better. Perhaps we're better off getting our own local house in order, first. That may not sound like a hopeful message. But the actions of the Expanse characters do show that there are some shining personalities willing to act for something other than their own interests. A few people do act for the greater good. And now let me go privately cry for a bit.

Having also watched the recent TV series, I marvel at the way the TV series used the major themes in the source material to tell an almost entirely different yet internally consistent story. The book is very short on action and very long on conversations. Telling the story in a visual medium required converting many of the themes and explanations to actions. Probably the most obvious example is the Emperor, mentioned only briefly in the book, but central in the TV series as a means of understanding the longevity, history, grandeur, and corruption of the Empire.
I read this when I was in high school (NOT in 1951, much later), but it's still been quite a while. I'm glad to revisit it, and I think I may go on to read the rest of the trilogy.

So many superhero movies come with astonishing amounts of collateral damage, but few of them deal with it (the Marvel Segovia Accords an clear exception). Even action movies can have gratuitous wanton destruction: not just overturned fruit stands during a chase, but needless destruction that doesn't advance the plot (I think I'm thinking of Die Hard 5 here ....).
This story doesn't ignore the destruction. It quantifies it, analyzes it, assigns it a dollar value. It's superhero meets data analyst! Totally unexpected.
Yes, Shel, I totally agree about Quantum and Supercollider. Very squirmy.


Books of the Month - For December you selected:
-- Science Fiction: Foundation by Isaac Asimov
-- Fantasy: Hench by Natalie Zina Walschots
We also have our schedule set for the next two months
-- January Science Fiction: The Boat of a Million Years by Poul Anderson
-- January Fantasy: Ombria in Shadow by Patricia A. McKillip
-- February Science Fiction: Inversions by Iain M. Banks
-- February Fantasy: The Grace of Kings by Ken Liu
Series news: We are currently discussing book 2 of the Daevabad Trilogy, The City of Brass by S.A. Chakraborty. We will begin discussion of book 3 The Empire of Gold in mid-month.
Lastly, don't forget to stop by the "What are you reading in December 2021?" topic to share your reading picks, progress, and thoughts on any genre.

I'm not going to nominate for science fiction this time. Sea of Rust is already on the list, and on my TBR pile.
