Amy’s answer to “You. Are. Brilliant. I'm astonished by your creativity and extraordinary mind. I read making faces …” > Likes and Comments
1 like · Like
OK, I can accept this :-) I was simply curious about him. I have made many people read this series and have got into several debates on the translation of the ending. Did you mean to do this on purpose? Some of my reading friends didn't think they get a happy ending, I disagree. Am I right?
That's what I thought! So then he comes out of purgatory when he walks her out, right? And that is how he gets out of there, but this time with his memory...
They definitely get a happy ending. Johnny consciously chooses purgatory when he's thrust back in time, knowing that it will eventually lead to Maggie. He doesn't relive Purgatory, he simply remembers it and willingly accepts it, which changes the future (the present) and allows him to use the little bit of magic remaining in him to save Maggie's life.
Dang your good! Now I can argue with anyone else I make read who doesn't get it :-) Thank you!
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jenny Jo
(new)
Aug 21, 2015 12:27PM
OK, I can accept this :-) I was simply curious about him. I have made many people read this series and have got into several debates on the translation of the ending. Did you mean to do this on purpose? Some of my reading friends didn't think they get a happy ending, I disagree. Am I right?
reply
|
flag
That's what I thought! So then he comes out of purgatory when he walks her out, right? And that is how he gets out of there, but this time with his memory...
They definitely get a happy ending. Johnny consciously chooses purgatory when he's thrust back in time, knowing that it will eventually lead to Maggie. He doesn't relive Purgatory, he simply remembers it and willingly accepts it, which changes the future (the present) and allows him to use the little bit of magic remaining in him to save Maggie's life.
Dang your good! Now I can argue with anyone else I make read who doesn't get it :-) Thank you!
